3 ms·
>I ask honestly and earnestly, how would the Homo sapiens and the cosmos progress and advance if more people understood Principia Mathmatica? Not much, I'd say
by coldtea 5y ago
>I ask honestly and earnestly, how would the Homo sapiens and the cosmos progress and advance if more people understood Principia Mathmatica?
Not much, I'd say.
For one, it bears no moral significance. You can be a net negative scumbag and understand Principia Mathmatica.
Second, it's a formalization of mathematics. It doesn't necessarily yield relevant new insight to advance homo sapiens beyond it's (quite narrow) scope. Understanding Principia Mathmatica doesn't mean you'll know how to make penicillin, for example.
Third, even for pure mathematical work, it's not that interesting in the end. Tons of great math work is being done that has no relation to it.
- schoen 5y agoFurther to that, there are large ongoing efforts in formalizing mathematics on computers now. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25118372 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25118372 Several of them are getting pretty far, and none of them are directly using PM notation (although all of them ultimately owe something to PM). You can learn more math, or contribute more to math, nowadays by learning one or more of these systems. To my knowledge, all of them are eager for new volunteers to continue formalizing theorems in their respective databases.
- jvvw 5y agoAgree, and I suspect only a tiny percentage of mathematicians have read it (I certainly did a degree and doctorate in maths at Oxford and sat the logic and set theory paper in my finals and it never went through my mind to read it). I get the impression that it's one of those books that was very influential in certain ways (Godel read it!) but is more a historical artefact now.
- taneq 5y agoBeing morally righteous isn't going to teach you to make penicillin either though.