6 ms·
> Investigators say they were able to tie the downloads to Sharp and his work-issued laptop because his Internet connection briefly failed on several occasions
by duxup 5y ago
> Investigators say they were able to tie the downloads to Sharp and his work-issued laptop because his Internet connection briefly failed on several occasions while he was downloading the Ubiquiti data. Those outages were enough to prevent Sharp’s Surfshark VPN connection from functioning properly — thus exposing his Internet address as the source of the downloads.
Not the first time I’ve read about a VPN unable to mask someone’s ip when they were on a wonky connection.
- NullPrefix 5y agoThis doesn't sound too good for VPN users
- XorNot 5y agoIt's an operating system issue. OS's are really difficult to give absolute invariants that you can trust. If network connectivity security is vital, then the only real solution is to setup your environment in a VPN or on a separate box that will lose the adapter routing info if it goes down.
- thakoppno 5y agoThere’s a huge gap in operational security for a hack of this size. At minimum, use a burner IP address and hardware from Craigslist.
- karmajunkie 5y agoit sounds like a misconfigured VPN to me, like he didn’t have the interface set to block traffic on failure.
- kobalsky 5y agoif a security tool lets the user shoot themselves on the foot it's a problem of the security tool not of the user.
- sgjohnson 5y agoI’d be willing to bet that for most of the VPNs that are getting advertised by YouTubers (NordVPN, SurfShark, ExpressVPN, PIA, et al) it’s 100% marketing and they don’t actually care whether their “kill switch” works 100% of the time. After all, they are not as trivial to implement as it sounds.
- _jzti 5y agoSomething I don't understand is that he executed it fairly well... With the exception of using a weak, evidently broken, vpn instead of something like mullvad + tor. If you are going to do something like that (which is already a big "why???"), why put such little effort into your own security?
- Const-me 5y agoThe suspect allegedly stole gigabytes of data, need bandwidth for that. Last time I tried to use tor, I was getting like 32 kbit/sec, on top of a symmetric 100 mbit/second internet connection. That was many years ago but I doubt they fixed the speed, very hard to do without centralized servers.
- rtpg 5y agoTo be clear, at least ExpressVPN has a "prevent traffic going through outside the VPN" mode which would handle this case, and it's on by default. I am not sure how it's implemented, but it's pretty easy to imagine someone deciding to not use it cuz "it's slow/annoying" or whatever.
- 1_player 5y agoThat option isn't enough, it works only when the VPN connection is up. If your internet connection is flaky and lose connectivity to the VPN itself, your OS will revert to using its default gateway, and your home IP, which is how the guy got caught. You need your firewall to block any internet access when the VPN is down. I have something like that set up in a Docker container for my torrenting VPN system, so I never connect with my residential IP.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikepurvis 5y agoPresumably this is an OS-level thing, that it helpfully tries to fall back? If so, I suppose it could be mitigated either by a software control that prevents using the bare connection, or by running the VPN elsewhere, for example on your router. (I see posts elsewhere in the thread now describing how to do this with iptables.)
- kobalsky 5y agowhat I heard some naugthy people say is that one way to deal with these kind of issues is to have two virtual machines, one that connects to the vpn and a second one (without host networking) that can only access internet through the first one. the firewall on the gateway vpc has to be on drop by default and only forward traffic from the 2nd vpc to the vpn interface. the gateway vpc should NEVER provide DHCP or DNS to the second vpc since this is the easiest way to shoot your foot off since a single dns request may give your identity away. that or use qubes os.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoEven if you did that, if I have oversight of the network in a country, like a 5+ eyes level of oversight and you were in a 5+ eyes country, I'd still be able to see where you are and what you would be doing. Road & Rail networks have a lot in common with digital networks, when you think about it. Personally I'd have a machine in a foreign country and used that either via an app or friend in front of the machine to do the download(s) with a time delay to avoid obvious links and then sneak it back across the border in bits. Insecure home networks can be useful, and there is no limit to the number of times and algo's that can be used to encrypt files Russian Doll style. Foreign country's which do not data share or extradite have their uses, but media like news orgs, Youtube and others can be helpful for establishing what hackers have been extradited. Assume all country's have hackers attacking the US or some other country and then look for missing news stories, YT videos and that sort of thing. Then look into what relations are like between the two country's and go from there. If you do your research or homework there shouldnt be any risks. I dont think the hackers behind this have ever been caught. https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0010s10/the-trick https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0010s10/the-trick https://web.archive.org/web/20120719071718/http://www.norfolk.police.uk/newsevents/newsstories/2012/july/ueadatabreachinvestigation.aspx https://web.archive.org/web/20120719071718/http://www.norfol...
- thejosh 5y agoMost come with a killswitch, so if it wonks out you can't access the net.
- Semaphor 5y agoAre killswitches actually fast enough? Serious question, I don’t know much/anything about networking internals. I never trust killswitches and when I want to ensure I don’t leak anything, I bind to the VPN interface instead, but I don’t know if that actually gives better security?
- numpad0 5y agoSpeed should not be a problem and hardware solution should not have to be a better solution, ideally. Shame that has to be brought up still.
- shbooms 5y agoI've never used surfshark myself but they advertise as having a killswitch inlcluded in their VPN [0] so it sounds like in this case, it definitely failed. [0] https://surfshark.com/vpn#vpn-page-essentials https://surfshark.com/vpn#vpn-page-essentials
- deadbunny 5y agoJust setup your routes/firewall so that the only possible way traffic can leave your machine is via the VPN device. VPN dies? no traffic going anywhere. Pretty much networking 101 stuff.
- Semaphor 5y agoThat should be the same when bound to an interface, shouldn’t it?
- roastedpeacock 5y agoKill-switches are a misnomer. What you really want is a firewall external from your "target" system that blackholes all traffic not to the VPN gateways IP address. Than make sure packets traveling the parent interface are ONLY VPN traffic or nothing in case of the tunnel dropping (wireshark is good here.)
- dreyfan 5y agoProper opsec is you blackhole all traffic when the vpn isn’t active.
- duxup 5y agoPersonally I’d feel most comfortable with a separate hardware VPV solution that won’t let anything through leaving the local software to do its thing.
- ziml77 5y agoIs there a good reason for that to not be the default when using a VPN? At the very least it should be easy to configure. I remember when I tried using a VPN on Ubuntu a bunch of years ago, I had to set up iptables rules even though the VPN connection could be configured through the network manager GUI.
- therein 5y agoWith wireguard since there is no "connection" to be maintained, you could argue this is a non-issue.
- mynameisvlad 5y agoBut Wireguard itself relies on an active internet connection, which needs to still be set up to not fall back on in case the wg connection deactivates.
- midasuni 5y ago> With wireguard since there is no "connection" to be maintained
- mynameisvlad 5y agoWhat does that even mean? Let's say you have a Wireguard configuration, wg0 which runs off ens0. If your wg0 connection dies, for whatever reason (let's say the remote server goes down), your computer falls back to ens0. What does "not having a connection to be maintained" change about this?
- paulpauper 5y agoVPNs are not intended to mask illegal behavior. The assumption is no one will care enough to try to get the real IP. So blatantly breaking the law throws that out the window.
- duxup 5y agoYeah and I don’t trust that a vpn would really care for my $5 a month or whatever when faced with state actions that if it came to that.
- gruez 5y agoAt least one VPN provider did just that https://torrentfreak.com/private-internet-access-no-logging-claims-proven-true-again-in-court-180606/ https://torrentfreak.com/private-internet-access-no-logging-...
- throwaway248329 5y agoThis was before they got a new owner.
- duxup 5y agoSaying “ I don’t have a log” to me isn’t the same scenario I’m thinking of. I’m thinking after the fact, if the government asked them to log future events.
- cm2187 5y agopfsense does that by default. If the VPN connection is deemed to be down (it does some pinging to evaluate it) it silently defaults to unencrypted. There is a convoluted way to configure it so that it blocks VPN IP packets from going directly to the WAN, but I noticed it seems to terminate connections when some packet is lost.
- stavros 5y agoOr he didn't screw it up and that's the FBI's standard excuse.
- jaywalk 5y agoMy first thought. They could have used some undisclosed (illegal) tools and methods to find him, and then cooked up this story to explain it.
- aksss 5y agoI'm skeptical. Maybe the FBI did use some illegal tool or more likely, a legal tool that they control the backoffice for, but the story I read outlined some pretty common blunders. This makes all the more sense if he was a mono-technical web app guy for most of his career. If he did pay with paypal, that was his first mistake. Theoretically, you pay for your VPN with a gift card you bought with cash, maybe even one you got in another state and use anonymous email receiver to get your keys. Rotate accounts as project phases are completed. Theoretically, use a purpose-built machine to keep fingerprints out of the mix, and as others have said, a killswitch using iptables/UFW to only allow traffic through the VPN gateway. Probably wouldn't have hurt to rotated the VPN egress points as well. Theoretically, he should have been connecting this VPN over a public hotspot not his home network. I get that this wouldn't be conducive to downloading gigs and gigs of data, but if you're the one setting it up and monitoring/junking any logging on the other side, you could also afford to do this with an SBC (or several, again bought with cash) concealed at some location(s) that just pulls the information by slow drip over public connection via VPN. SBCs get tossed into Willamette as they're rotated. The FBI cyber guys are good and creative but with a reactive situation like this I think old-fashioned gumshoeing, interviews and subpoenas would get them a long, long way. Once they had an inkling that it was an inside job, man, just relentlessly picking away at that with some face time would be really productive. Guaranteed that guy wasn't prepared for the bright light of honest incidental questioning, over and over, much less focused questioning. Not to mention, they are free to lie to your face in those interviews about what they do/don't know. Once they had a list of four people, start shoving out the subpoenas and see what clicks. Part of their toolbox is also having an idea of what real attacks look like, knowing what those actors care about leaving behind or not concealing, and in the absence of those earmarks, they know they're looking at something "unusual". Now if I start telling you that I did find evidence of an attack of type Y where there absolutely is none, and you're all too eager to help me prove that theory, that's probably a bad sign. Did he have a plan of his own in place to frame some other ransom toolkit or plant seeds of a breach? I mean, what would you think if you walked into a company that got hit with a massive ransom demand, evidence of data theft, but no typical signs of a data breach from the usual suspects? State actor? Now this is serious. Was it their Exchange or RDP server in the closet? Oh, you're cloud-only? What platforms are we talking about? A state actor has zero-days into a major cloud platform?? MS? AWS? Now this is really serious. Or... maybe none of that is the case. Log files are all missing? Who made that decision? I mean, on and on it goes, but it seems pretty easy to see it unravelling once you start pulling on a thread. If one was really interested, they could probably find some good information in PACER about the information that supported the indictment. Chances are he's already confessed and is attempting to plead out. They'll surely throw the book at him. Insider ransom jobs on US hardware companies are not a tolerable phenomenon.
- jerrygoyal 5y agoWonder if tor browser would've been a better choice