4 ms·
I think mushroom leather is a cool invention, but at least at the present time, the vast majority of animal leather is a byproduct of food production, to the po
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I think mushroom leather is a cool invention, but at least at the present time, the vast majority of animal leather is a byproduct of food production, to the point that there is a surplus of leather because people like hamburgers more than leather products: https://qz.com/1308051/the-popularity-of-sneakers-is-leaving-the-beef-industry-with-a-glut-of-unwanted-hides/ https://qz.com/1308051/the-popularity-of-sneakers-is-leaving...
- jszymborski 5y agoI've always had a hard time reasoning about this. On one-hand, it's a waste-stream, which means that finding a purpose for it means that the resources gone into the animals from which leather is made become more efficient. On the other, if you believe that meat production at its current scale is bad for the environment, you're making it cheaper and subsidising it. Then there's the impact of all the chemicals involved in leather tanning, which are not inconsequential. I don't know what to think about leather in all honesty.
- colechristensen 5y agoIt looks to be 1-5% of the value of the animal at this point but some are just discarded entirely.
- notatoad 5y agoIt's important to consider the durability of leather products. IME, good quality natural leather products easily last 3-4x longer than alternatives. The tanning process isn't exactly environmentally friendly, but it doesn't have to be if it can reduce overall consumption by enough.
- causi 5y agoIndeed. Good leather products can last for years or decades. Leather belts, wallets, shoes, bags, etc all last far longer than their fabric alternatives.
- xorcist 5y agoCenturies, if cared for properly.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoBad quality, leather, on the other hand, disintegrates within a few months. I was at the Apple WWDC, where they passed out those leather jackets with the big blue "X" on the back. Mine didn't make it to the next WWDC, and I took great care of it. I think that they may have had a couple of versions of the jacket. I saw it reappear, for quite a while, on the bodies of Apple favorites (I wasn't one), for many years.
- Tepix 5y agoWhat do we know about the durability of mushroom leather and how does its environmental impact compare with animal leather?
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoOne wonders how the total life cycle of cotton or nylon compare to the leather production process. Mushroom leather could be used when the look really matters, but otherwise I would think a lot of leather products could be made with heavy canvas or nylon. Anyway I am a vegan so using animal skin as an industrial output is something I think we should make a conscious effort to end as much as possible.
- i_am_proteus 5y agoLeather is also a byproduct of dairy production! Many may relinquish their hamburgers, but few will relinquish their pizzas. One must consider the cow a miraculous piece of technology: an efficient reactor for converting cereals and grasses into valuable fats, proteins, as well as useful materials.
- ballenf 5y agoOne more complicating question -- does the hide value of an animal incentivize better treatment during its life?
- car 5y agoLeather itself is a driver of deforestation and not just a secondary byproduct. https://www.stand.earth/publication/forest-conservation/amazon-forest-protection/amazon-leather-supply-chain https://www.stand.earth/publication/forest-conservation/amaz...
- colechristensen 5y agoThe point being that if you shrink the leather market you don’t really reduce the cattle market at all and what would be made into leather is just discarded.
- netrus 5y agoIf you cannot sell the leather, the meat will have to become more expensive (same cost to raise the animal, additional cost for discarding the skin, less income). If meat is more expensive, less will be bought, shrinking the meat market.
- wiseowise 5y agoYep. Let's return back to times when only rich and wealthy were able to afford meat.
- Freak_NL 5y agoIf the price for alternatives goes down in return, sure. Tax meat more heavily, subsidize vegetables and plant-based alternatives with that tax, or come up with some other clever scheme. It'll drive change a lot faster than just depending on the few who (can) care enough. We eat, on average, too much meat as it is, and with meat the negative externalities such as deforestation are completely ignored in the price.
- fnord77 5y agoreading the post about medieval jobs, I don't think this time ever existed.
- beowulfey 5y agoA great point, and I think an important thing to note about mushroom leather is it is ALSO a byproduct of food demand! It is (or was, at least initially) made from the waste of commercial oyster mushroom farming.