4 ms·
> Everyone who leaves the military has a very high opinion of their peers' professionalism, dedication, and so forth. Are you talking about the US military and
by wolverine876 5y ago
> Everyone who leaves the military has a very high opinion of their peers' professionalism, dedication, and so forth.
Are you talking about the US military and do you have some data on that? I see people with no experience of the military imagine a storybook entity (which is a very popular public concept these days), but the US military has significant retention problems, very high rates of suicide and sexual assault (signals of and, for the latter, a cause of a toxic environment), and a lot of morale, discipline, and corruption problems. As a couple of examples of the latter, around a year ago, the head of special operations said that it was their top priority. In ~ the last year, the Navy was having trouble filling higher ranks because so many officers had been kicked out due to corruption scandals (e.g., the 'Fat Leonard' scandal).
The glorification of the military might seem patriotic, but I think it's the opposite: It's a way of not seeing and addressing problems, which weakens defense and leaves the people serving to deal with the problems and suffer the consequences (including the environment, more and longer tours, and possibly their lives). It's like a case of extreme over-confidence in a CEO - a very dangerous flaw.
> Compare that to the Googlers who constantly complain about their employer
People in the military don't gripe?
- Retric 5y agoYes, you can find some seriously messed up stuff in the military. I was looking at some criminal data and seeing a huge number of attempted murder charges related to one case I thought the data might have been in error. But no, throwing a live grenade into a tent is quite serious. That said, it’s easy to underestimate just how large the US military is and how many people cycle in and out every year. Just unemployment benefits alone get quite expensive during any economic downturn. Recruit millions over time and even if you reject the most obvious problem cases you will eventually get some seriously unstable people.
- FpUser 5y ago>"Recruit millions over time and even if you reject the most obvious problem cases you will eventually get some seriously unstable people." So you think they had specifically selected bunch of unstable to work in Abu Ghraib?
- GhettoComputers 5y agoThose people were abusive, not unstable. It had been going on and would have continued. North Korea is stable. Dennis Rader was stable.
- perl4ever 5y ago>Recruit millions over time and even if you reject the most obvious problem cases you will eventually get some seriously unstable people. I think that's an erroneous way to look at it. The fundamental problem is that the military is, and has been, made up of volunteers for a long time. It's not that with more people you get proportionally more bad apples, it's that when you accept volunteers, you get people self-selecting and that's way worse. You get the people who are mentally ill and not self-aware and seeking something they can't find anywhere else signing up. Consider Tim McVeigh, who was taught to kill in Iraq. Allegedly (may be controversial) "schizotypal". That basically means "has some weird ideas, might develop schizophrenia some day, but not actively psychotic". Plenty of people could be like him - unstable in a lot of respects, but after talking to a recruiter go "nah, killing people on the other side of the world doesn't sound fun". So they don't enlist, and that shapes the military. The only way to fix this is a return to the draft. Of course that's easier said than done. I know little about them, but people always mention Switzerland and Israel as having practically universal military service. So if it seems impossible, yet it must be possible somehow.
- Retric 5y agoSelf selecting populations can be very different from the overall norms when your talking 0.001% of the population. However, when your talking 5+% of the population you can only stray so far from those norms. Recruit say the smartest 5% of the population and their median IQ is ~130. The tallest 5% and sure you get everyone in the NBA, but also the more normal person at 6’ 1”. Considering in the real world you can’t select the most extreme in every category and the US military is more or less forced to be fairly average compared to the US population simply because they want multiple things. Select for decent health, decent intelligence, and decent physical capacity and you can only focus so much on mental health.
- perl4ever 5y ago>However, when your talking 5+% of the population you can only stray so far from those norms I would expect the top (or bottom) 5% of the population in any dimension to be far from the norm. >Select for decent health, decent intelligence, and decent physical capacity and you can only focus so much on mental health I think these are wishful thinking, not what is actually selected for. As long as there's no draft, the military does not get to select people. Someone takes the ASVAB, and decides against going further, there's nothing that can be done. People select themselves. The minimum standards weren't that high when I last talked to a recruiter and over the years I've read a lot of articles that suggest they've gotten lower. The military, like a lot of difficult jobs (police officer, teacher, etc.) doesn't pay proportionally. So recruits are selected for willingness to put up with that. From an abstract economic perspective, someone who accepts lower than market pay must receive some other form of non-monetary compensation that explains it. It would be nice to attribute it always and only to patriotism, but there are other possibilities, conscious or unconscious, just like a devotion to justice and protecting people is one particular reason for becoming a police officer. In letting people select themselves for a difficult and low paid job, you will get people who are not near average because they highly value access to things that cannot be found anywhere else, for any amount of money. And they will be concentrated together, changing the character of an organization. Modern Western culture holds individual freedom, social mobility, and self-direction in such esteem I think we may have a blind spot with regard to how random selection and assignment of people to jobs can sometimes produce better results.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Recruit millions over time and even if you reject the most obvious problem cases you will eventually get some seriously unstable people. While it's impossible to hire millions of excellent performers, I think that focuses too much on the people and not on the organization. The institutions themselves have real problems - like other large institutions, but these are problems the citizens are responsible for addressing.
- UncleEntity 5y ago> People in the military don't gripe? I had this platoon leader who was wondering about how much I used to gripe about everything and I told him when joes stop complaining is when you have to worry because they’re probably plotting your death or something.