2 ms·
You still have the question of directionality. Suppose humans migrate to Europe from Africa, then have some local divergence from their ancestors. Then those h
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
You still have the question of directionality.
Suppose humans migrate to Europe from Africa, then have some local divergence from their ancestors. Then those humans interbreed with neanderthals, so that those divergent genes spread within the neanderthal population as well.
Putting aside the question of whether the existence of interbreeding makes neanderthals not a separate species, it's going to be difficult to tell where those genes originated.
Suppose the first person to have those genes was a human who bred with both humans and neanderthals, but it so happens we have fossils of some of the earliest neanderthals with those genes and not the earliest humans with them.
Then you could have the result that some "neanderthals" descended from humans but not vice versa, and be unable to distinguish that from the other way around.
- jjk166 5y agoThis would be an issue if you were naively looking at a single mutation in a single gene in a single individual without context, but the problem disappears when looking at large numbers of whole genes in many individuals with fossil evidence for context. You can see more basal forms of genes, combinations of genes which get passed on together, biological clocks indicating when a mutation occurred, and geographic information indicating where it originated. If a gene variant exists for hundreds of thousands of years in one population, and then a nearly identical variant suddenly starts showing up in another population, it's safe to assume that some hanky panky took place. We do indeed find neanderthals who descend from humans, interbreeding went both ways. For example we can see that around 100,000 years ago, the neanderthals' y chromosomes were almost completely replaced with a modern human y chromosome whereas even as late as 38,000 years ago there were still neanderthals with purely neanderthal mitochondrial DNA.