2 ms·
I'm sure it would have to help; but i would not make any bets in the close presence of lightning and long wires. weird shit happens. My experience says that a
by h2odragon 5y ago
I'm sure it would have to help; but i would not make any bets in the close presence of lightning and long wires. weird shit happens.
My experience says that a free length of wire grounded at a midpoint (like when you disconnect the far end) will still be a potential resonator for enough volts to cross a respectable gap; so unplug it and insulate the unplugged end. Been there, seen the sparks.
I maintained various configurations of wire and fiber across a 1/4 mile run through heavy woods on a ridge that gets direct lightning strikes a dozen times a year. nothing involving a conductor that length is simple in that circumstance: see the things the power companies have to do.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoThanks. I do have the other end up bundled up, but I guess I might as well make a note to disconnect and bundle up the remaining side, too. > I maintained various configurations of wire and fiber Separately or at the same time? What was the wire for in your case if you had it parallel to the fiber, and what did you do to protect it against the lightning strikes? We have it between two directly adjacent buildings that are maybe only 150ft apart (mostly underneath an asphalt access road) but there are no lighting strike rods/redirector on either structure.
- h2odragon 5y agoI had this link between two buildings (no line of sight and radio was too expensive and slow then anyway), it began as redneck engineered "leased line" with modems on either end, with multi pair copper and replacing the modems periodically. The battery that floated that line was kept outside because it would occasionally "vent vigorously" with storms. USR modems had good isolation hardware those so they were pretty robust. Upgraded that to coax Ethernet as soon as I could, 3c509 cards in cheap linux routers at either end of the link, with "modem failover" until the incident that blew away the 25pair. Those cards would lose one or both with every other storm it seemed; but were ~$2/ea off ebay at that point so not so bad. I've got at least one of those motherboards still, somewhere, with multiple bodge wires where i repaired traces blown off by lightning strikes. When we got the fiber we buried the first run, with coax beside it, in conduit again. That lasted a few years before a "landscaping accident" tore out enough that there was no fix. Then we went to suspended coax, and then another fiber tied to that, for a few years, before the business folded. I tried various grounding strategies over the years. The power companies and "best practice" suggest regular connections throughout the span of the line, and at both ends. I found that seemed to invite strikes by being a very good RF ground in the air. Grounding at both ends is bad because of ground surge, pick one or the other end and have the best ground point there you can get, but let the other float, and hope. Also, any actual power system imbalances between two ends of a grounded line will seek to use that nice conductor rather than the cold earth. 150ft isn't that far. Also you haven't got trees to complicate things, they draw lighting and ground it deep. Hickory trees were my bane; they got deep roots that found our high iron sandstone layer and combed the sky for electrons. I'd say consider the switches at either end of that link to be sacrificial buffer parts, and not really worry about it. If its worth considering running fiber under a street, it might be worth considering a free space laser link or something.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoThanks for taking the time to share that. It sounds like you made pragmatic decisions which are much harder to discover online since no one with the actual expertise/experience wants to ever officially/publicly recommend anything less than "this is the textbook-correct way of doing it," which never takes $finances into account. I do understand why you would want to leave an end floating but I'm not sure to what extent that is possible since ground surge voltage is probably enough to jump from the cable shielding to the inner twisted pairs, and so you're always going to have some grounding on both sides (via the switch fabric through to the mains), but I guess all you can do is make the alternative grounding path lucrative enough; if it's a short run and you have a nice, fat ground on one end, hopefully that should direct the surge away from the skimpy 20awg cables grounding it on the other end.