3 ms·
I'd be more convinced if he'd also registered domains with two, three and four bit-errors in them. Having gathered as much statistics as he did, they should sho
by tripzilch 15y ago
I'd be more convinced if he'd also registered domains with two, three and four bit-errors in them. Having gathered as much statistics as he did, they should show clearly half as much, resp. 1/4th and 1/8th as much hits.
If that would indeed have been the case, he could say with very high confidence that his hits were indeed caused by bit-flip errors, and not by character errors or who knows what other unknown anomalies.
So far, he's advocating to upgrade memory to prevent this vulnerability, but there's only a rough hypothesis that this might be caused by memory bitflip errors.
And even then, between the client and the DNS-server, there's a lot of machines, the bitflip could occur anywhere, right? How can he say upgrading client memory will solve anything??
- gjm11 15y ago> half as much, resp 1/4 and 1/8 as much hits No. These errors are very rare. You only get any of them (according to the hypothesis we're considering here) because there are so many DNS requests made. The probability of getting two bit-flip errors in a single request is much smaller than the probability of getting one, so the expected number of 2-bit hits would be way less than 1. Something like this might be a useful check in a different way: bit-flipping errors will almost always be single-bit errors, whereas typos and suchlike won't. So if the bit-flipping theory is correct, you'll see systematically more single-bit than multi-bit errors.
- vessenes 15y agoHis math was wrong, but his point stands, it's a simple test to see why these hits show up.