8 ms·
Zrythm: A highly automated and intuitive digital audio workstation
- kiddico 5y agoThis is a bit off topic, but this is the first time I've actually used sourcehut and I've got to say I love it. Nearly instant account creation and sometimes I don't notice a page is already loaded because I blinked when I clicked. well done sircmpwn
- Mizza 5y agoLooks nice, particularly the piano roll. Do any Free DAWs have Ableton-like VST "hiding"? I can't leave Ableton because of how insane window management gets on complex projects when 10 different VSTs are all fighting for screen space. Even the screenshots for this app look chaotic from all of the VSTs covering the screen at the same time.
- maximedupre 5y ago> Even the screenshots for this app look chaotic from all of the VSTs covering the screen at the same time. That's one of the first things I noticed - how messy it looks. Perhaps that's just because they tried to showcase all the features in one single screenshot lol.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoDue to your question, I just added this feature to Ardour. There's now a user preference that if set will only allow one plugin GUI window to be visible at a time. Lots of our users would find that irritating, but you get the choice now. https://github.com/Ardour/ardour/commit/c7b70c6318456b375ccb92f8dd745ddec72ce882 https://github.com/Ardour/ardour/commit/c7b70c6318456b375ccb...
- Mizza 5y agoThat's awesome! I've had Ardour on my systems for years, since the first Ubuntu Studio, thanks for all your work!
- themodelplumber 5y agoSome Qs I've had about this recently in case you or someone else could offer insights: Is it realistic to run Ardour for music composition on regular Intel sound hardware these days? Is it still pretty easy to migrate from Ubuntu to (presumably realtime) Studio? Thanks for any input; I'm interested in Ardour, Jack, etc. but not "buy new sound card" interested, as LMMS on ALSA is not too bad for what I do.
- speed_spread 5y agoArdour does not have significantly higher requirements than other audio software and should work just fine with any decent-ish machine. The audio interface is really up to you, it's just a matter of sound quality. If onboard audio suits you, then who are we to judge? I myself used the onboard audio with an external mixer for quite a while. I've since upgraded to a 24 track FireWire rig assembled from cheap used hardware that no longer ran on Mac or Windows because of obsolete drivers. In-tree drivers is major advantage of Linux when it comes to hardware support.
- marcan_42 5y agoYou don't need a fancy card for music production if you're not recording external audio. As long as it has decently good quality output and you're either using amplified speakers, a headphone amp, or it has a good enough internal amp, you can get away with internal audio. You'd be surprised at how many music producers do all their work on a laptop and headphones these days. If you just want to mess around, any internal card will do for sure. This applies to all DAW work on Linux regardless of what app you use. LMMS, Ardour, it's all the same. JACK runs peefectly fine on internal cards.
- marcan_42 5y agoAnd this is why I use Ardour. It just keeps getting better and the devs are amazingly responsive! I'm really looking forward to Ardour 7 :-)
- udbhavs 5y agoThere was a comment on the recent Blender 3.0 thread posted here wondering why there isn't an equivalent program for audio. This looks very polished and much more approachable compared to Ardour or LMMS, and seems like a good candidate. But one feature I really wish my dream "Blender for audio" had would be the convenient device view that Ableton and Bitwig offer for working quickly with effects. It's so much faster than the type of effect chains offered by DAWs like FL and makes it fun to mess around and experiment with effects-based synthesis. Looking at the screenshots and videos it looks like Zrythm doesn't have this feature, although I understand how tedious it would be to implement because you would essentially have to write your own effects or create wrappers around others to expose an interface that can fit in a device view. Probably not high on the list of priorities for a work in progress DAW
- fb03 5y agoI'm keeping an eye on Bespoke Synth for that. Am a keen user of Renoise which is not free but it's really good (if you enjoy trackers) and also very affordable. In the meantime, hyped for how the foss audio world is shaping up. We soon might not even a commercial daw at all anymore, just like Blender is doing in the 3D world (I work with artists in a studio and we switched almost our whole pipeline, sans simulations, to Blender).
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI would argue there are many more, and much more widely differing, workflows for DAW use than there are for 3D (maybe even 2D) graphics. There are somewhere in the range of 12-20 "significant" DAWs out there, with a very wide range of workflows supported (not all of them by all the DAWs). This doesn't include "generation environments" like VCV Rack, Reaktor, Bespoke and many others that don't have any traditional DAW features but are immensely powerful tools for synthesis and compositional discovery and creation. Depending on the uniqueness of your imagined or actual workflow, there is probably a tool that comes close, but the potential variations do imply that its not hard to come up with a description for "what I really want in an audio tool" that just doesn't exist (at least not without you doing significant work yourself e.g. programming in PureData).
- adamgordonbell 5y agoWhat I want is a way to run VSTs from the command line. Often I just have the same chain of VST with saved settings that I want to run a file through and a DAW shouldn't be required. mrswatson is the only thing close I have found but it doesn't seem to work at all. I'll admit my usecase is unique, just running certain Izotope plugins over interview audio to clean them up but I really wish command line composition and automation were possible. https://github.com/teragonaudio/MrsWatson https://github.com/teragonaudio/MrsWatson
- mixmastamyk 5y agoLook at gstreamer.
- hunter2_ 5y agoMy first thought was to see if ffmpeg could do this. Unfortunately it seems like not currently [0] but what caught my eye is a mention that "the VST SDK has a linux command line VST Host you can compile" which might be all you need. [0] https://superuser.com/questions/1661505/naive-query-vst-plugins-in-ffmpeg https://superuser.com/questions/1661505/naive-query-vst-plug...
- jdevera 5y agoMaybe you can cook something quickly with Spotify's Pedalboard: https://github.com/spotify/pedalboard https://github.com/spotify/pedalboard
- TheRealPomax 5y agoWhat is "a file" in this case? Because VST don't have idea what that is, so you're still going to be generating your projects in _something_ That said, what you're describing sounds pretty close to using cantabile in headless mode (https://www.cantabilesoftware.com/guides/commandLineOptions https://www.cantabilesoftware.com/guides/commandLineOptions), where you just create a project with your desired VST chain, and then take it from there.
- adamgordonbell 5y agoBut don't VST's have settings? mrswatson can feed them fxp settings files so I assume its a standard. mrswatson just only seems to work with older or simpler vsts. I'll check that out cantabile headless thanks!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- delgaudm 5y agoSeems pretty cool, but looking at the screen capture on the front page of that site makes me wonder, "intuitive for who?" (But, I use Reaper, so who am I to talk)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoMy remarks on this "intuitive" thing (I'm the lead developer of Ardour, another FOSS DAW): https://discourse.ardour.org/t/reflections-on-intuitive/78335 https://discourse.ardour.org/t/reflections-on-intuitive/7833...
- rectang 5y agoMy instinctive reaction to any software product advertised as "Intuitive", "Simple", or "Fast", is full-on Generation X "what utter bullshit" skepticism. A greenfield software project in an inherently complex domain may be intuitive, simple, and fast at first, but claiming it will stay that way is like advertising a rock you throw into the air as "Flying".
- rvense 5y agoI don't like the word at all when describing interfaces. It's an overly broad term that in my experience doesn't tend to lead to very good conversations about what's good or bad. Case in point, we recently did a complete UI make-over at $JOB and the bossman keeps referring to it as the new 'more intuitive UI'. We moved a few buttons around and changed some font sizes, but the most visible change is the completely new colour palette. So yeah. I'd also argue that nobody is born with an intuition to work a DAW or any other piece of software, and in that sense I think it's just a misleading term. I think there are much better words to use to talk about whether a UI is successful or not: "Familiar" is a good word, because then you can ask "familiar to whom" and have a good conversation about what kind of users you have, their backgrounds, how much work you expect them to put into learning your software, etc. "Internally consistent" is another thing you can talk about and to some extent quantify. Being "discoverable" is another thing where you can talk about the balances between having everything right in front of you and a complete information overload. And of course, you can't really get around whether or not a UI is attractive, displaying good colour sense and being visually balanced and such. While you can certainly make pretty things that are impossible to understand, I would tend to argue that there is a bare minimum of prettiness needed to make something that's friendly and engaging. (PS: Thank you very much for Ardour, it is a remarkable piece of software.)
- BoysenberryPi 5y agoI saw this a while ago and wanted to contribute so I found my way to their source. Unfortunately, this was my first interaction with SourceHut, the site they use as their central point of development, and found it completely unintuitive. After 15 minutes of fumbling around I basically just said "I'll try it again later" and never got back to it. This might just be because this was my first encounter with the site.
- maximedupre 5y agoI didn't even know about SourceHut. It seems like the weird cousin of Github. But I'm also a Github fan boiiiii.
- zucker42 5y agoYou just use git-send-email[1] to send a patch to their mailing list[2]. Project page is here[3]. [1] https://git-send-email.io/ https://git-send-email.io/ [2] https://lists.sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm-devel https://lists.sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm-devel [3] https://sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm/ https://sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm/
- alextee 5y agowe keep a mirror there if you prefer to use github (https://github.com/zrythm/zrythm https://github.com/zrythm/zrythm) but we don't actually use github for development if you really want to use github pull requests instead of sending patches feel free to do that and I'll still look at them but we recommend patches via email because it's an open and standard system
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y agoJust wanted to say that I personally really appreciate the setup, workflow and the way you are organized! It looks like you are really caring about building upon open tech both in development and communication. Actually made me very curious. Same for the choice of dependencies and the documentation in place, was surprised with how easy it was to compile myself. Hadn't had the time to give the program itself a full try yet, but I'm actually looking forward to do try some recordings with it next week.
- maximedupre 5y agoSo, I'm curious, what's the big thing about Zrythm? Is it that you can automate much more params than on Logic/Ableton? The fact that it's open-source is pretty cool though.
- odiroot 5y agoI haven't tried it myself but at least the piano roll seems better than Bitwig's. And Bitwig is my current choice for Linux.
- 999900000999 5y agoI understand why, but it's really hurting adoption of this project to lock the installers behind a paywall. When I'm looking to download something like this, I already have garage band and logic. I'm not willing to really give you 15$ without any proof this will work for me. However, if the installers were available for free, I would have no trouble paying €5 or so on the honor system. Assume it works for my computer and all that stuff
- alextee 5y agothe "paywall" system has been proven to work by ardour and zrythm to fund the project's development >I'm not willing to really give you 15$ without any proof this will work for me if you want to try it out you can download the trial version at no cost. all features are there besides saving/loading projects (you can still export audio though)
- 999900000999 5y agoThe problem here is it's competing against Audacity which is free. Then again audacity is selling user data. Even if I'm down to pay 15$ then I can't share projects with anyone who doesn't want to pay. Folks who , since it's proven, already use Logic.
- mixedCase 5y agoAudacity is not a DAW. This is competing with Ardour, if you want to limit it to FOSS options.
- breakfastduck 5y agoThis is absolutely not competing against Audacity. It's a full scale modern DAW.
- iostream23 5y agoI think that you are being unreasonable. Logic gives you zero demo trial period and its price is significantly higher. Most audio software is relatively expensive, if you have any experience, which I doubt given your claim that this competes with audacity. Audacity competes with Ntrack, perhaps. This competes with Ableton or Bitwig. Go check their prices
- schmorptron 5y agoMeta: I always really like HN Threads about DAWs, a lot of people with a ton of knowledge and good recomendations tend to show up :)
- mxmilkiib 5y ago#zrythm on libera IRC is a very active channel (as is #ardour, #lad)
- wrycoder 5y agoDistributed at Sourcehut under the GNU Affero license, with branding reserved to unmodified copies. The business model is interesting. https://git.sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm https://git.sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm
- marcodiego 5y agoI don't know exactly what kind of software is better suited for FLOSS. I'm a bit sad that there are no AAA FLOSS games. Open source libraries have been in common use for games for long time, there are a few somewhat adequate engines and Godot is a major promise for changing the landscape. Now, consider linux, gcc, llvm, apache, the rest of the gnu project... these are technical projects. It looks like "technical people" are willing to improve the tools they use and that drives FLOSS technical/system software to continually evolve through the years. Regarding artistic software... well they are definitely technical and advanced, but an artist is much less willing or knowledgeable to make any contribution. But, when the right sauce finally mixes in, we get Blender. So, I think there is hope for the DAW market. If proprietary options don't take care to make good offers, they will be eaten just the same way the traditional proprietary UNIX world was. MacOS survives, but the market the survive into is very different.
- egypturnash 5y agoI'm a bit sad that there are no AAA FLOSS games AAA games are typically the result of a small army of artists, working overlong hours for a year or three. Go read the credits of one all the way through sometime, and compare to the credits of a summer tentpole action/effects film. Do you have any proposals for ways to get this many people to work for that long for free? Or for a way to fund them and release the full source for the executables and the assets for free?
- marcodiego 5y agoI said nothing about the assets. Actually I really think this is a path for good FLOSS AAA games: paid assets. Not even Stallman is opposed to that: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/nonfree-games.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/nonfree-games.en.html the part that says "Game art is a different issue, because it isn't software."
- betwixthewires 5y agoYup, and if you look at Quake 3 Arena as a good example, the game is free software but the assets or not, and as a result of that you wind up with games lime Open Arena and the dozens of other arena style games built from quake. It can still be that way.
- dandare 5y agoWith a free software like this I am always wondering what is the business model, how do they make money?
- FractalHQ 5y agoCheck out their download page- they offer premium subscriptions for access to more plugins
- tapland 5y agoAnd for the save/load functionality? I'll check the free version out but that seems like a big hurdle of the free version
- kristopolous 5y agoyou can always build it yourself. But that's turning out to be non-trivial
- billfruit 5y agoDoes it have a tracker-style interface? I think trackers are more intuitive than the piano rolls many audio software have.
- emsy 5y agoTrackers are just vertical piano rolls with all tracks visible concurrently. Piano rolls are is better, I’d argue, when working with audio clips and automation.
- pierrec 5y agoI use and like both, but I'd say they're quite different. With trackers, you're editing a series of events. Events can be notes, parameter changes, or commands such as "reverse this sample's playing direction now" or "move the playhead for this sample to exactly 50%". Those are common tasks when making electronic beats. With pianorolls, everything has to be represented as a note or an automation curve. The examples I gave above become difficult to represent properly, and are often done with plugin-specific keyswitches or velocity switches. You end up with a D sharp that actually means "change to sample number 2", that kind of thing. I don't really see how it's better for working with audio clips.
- alextee 5y agosomeone requested it but it's very low priority https://todo.sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm-feature/482 https://todo.sr.ht/~alextee/zrythm-feature/482
- iostream23 5y agoI disagree. I used trackers for decades but I’ll take piano roll any day.
- chirau 5y agoSo how do we pronounce this? I think the name is unnecessarily complicated.
- alextee 5y agozee-rhythm
- quitethelogic 5y agoI'll use it if you allow zed-rhythm as well
- dancemethis 5y agoPower Rangers called, they want their villain back
- owlbynight 5y agoJust let me put FL Studio's piano roll into Ableton, please.
- 0des 5y agoAlways nice to see another SourceHut project :)
- mhitza 5y agoWanted to give it a try, unfortunately under Fedora 34 the alpha AppImage segfaults when run via pw-jack (pipewire jack "bridge")
- no_time 5y agoAfter taking a cursory glance at the sources, It's rather unique in a way that it's GTK based yet looks nothing the average GTK application. I wonder what made them pick GTK instead of QML or even something unique like many DAWs do. btw congrats to the team, I'm not musically gifted to give an opinion on how usable it is, but the design looks very crisp and more akin to something you see in closed source apps with an army of designers behind them.
- alextee 5y ago>I wonder what made them pick GTK instead of QML GTK works with C and has a nice API, and also it's built with free software in mind
- luckydata 5y agoI've been making music for a LOOOOONG time (mostly Logic and Ableton user but I tried everything under the sun). I looked at it for a minute and the only thing I could think was "what a mess".
- commoner 5y agoDo you have any specific suggestions for improving the interface? The main Zrythm developer is reading this thread.
- spacechild1 5y ago> Fully JACK aware, including support for PipeWire, JACK transport, ALSA, PulseAudio, WASAPI, Windows MME, CoreMidi and CoreAudio. No ASIO support?
- alextee 5y agowe use RtAudio which has ASIO support, but we can't legally distribute binaries with that so our RtAudio is built without it. if you want ASIO support you'd have to build RtAudio yourself with ASIO support and replace the DLL if you're using our binaries
- spacechild1 5y agoIt's a grey area. There are quite a few open source audio apps that ship with ASIO support, some of them even GPL licensed. AFAICT, the problem is that Steinberg forbids redistribution of the SDK which would conflict with the GPL. Now, if you would get a license agreement from Steinberg and just don't include the SDK in your source code (to comply with Steinberg's terms), who is going to sue you for not complying with the GPL?
- johnsoft 5y agoOnce upon a time, Google copied the Java APIs. Oracle sued Google. Google won. We now have precedent. What's stopping someone from copying the ASIO APIs and shipping a compatible SDK?
- spacechild1 5y agoYes! In the end, ASIO is just a COM interface ("iasiodrv.h") + some structs, constants and typedefs in "asio.h". All the actual code in the .c files are just helpers. I definitely think it would be possible to take just the specifications and build an alternative SDK as long as you avoid the ASIO trademark. So far, nobody dared to do that, though. At least, I'm not aware of anything. On the other hand, people did do that with the VST2 SDK a while ago. I'm pretty sure Steinberg knows about it but they probably don't want to risk a court case (which could set a clear precedent) and the bad publicity.
- anigbrowl 5y agoLooks good. Perplexed by the lack of information on the features page vs the landing page, though? I wanted to know more about this 'chord pad' before downloading it but the Features pages seems unfinished.
- alextee 5y agothere's more information in the user manual for now https://manual.zrythm.org/en/chords-and-scales/overview.html https://manual.zrythm.org/en/chords-and-scales/overview.html