3 ms·
The popularity based recommendations are only shown to brand new users - so they have some content to rate. A new user starts off weakly connected to all other
by lonk11 5y ago
The popularity based recommendations are only shown to brand new users - so they have some content to rate.
A new user starts off weakly connected to all other users and to feeds the existing users are connected to.
But as you submit or upvote links to content you liked - your recommendations will be based on your explicit upvotes, and will be less popularity based.
> aren't you recreating some of the same issues with social media?
1. The algorithm.
Social media algorithms are black box ML models that optimize for time-spent on the platform (ie, ads watched). LinkLonk also uses an algorithm, but there is 0% of machine learning. All it does is keeps track of how useful the past recommendations of every RSS feed and every user have been to you. You define what is useful to you based on what you upvote. This makes it so that each user can make decisions of what they want to optimize for. Social media algorithms make these decisions for you.
2. The types of actions
In social media we have two types of actions:
- Inbound: follow/subscribe - they affect what I see as a user. The target of these actions is myself in the future.
- Outbound: comments/likes/dislikes/retweets/etc - they affect what other people see. The target - are other people.
The problem is largely with the outbound actions - social media give us tools to influence other people and we use them for that. In other words, they give us megaphones and we each crank up the volume of our own megaphone to the max. There is little incentive to not set the volume any lower than the max.
I understand your perspective - traditional RSS readers don't have any outbound actions. You only decide for yourself who you trust to get information from.
And your concern is that LinkLonk provides tools to influence other people and that these tools will be inevitably abused.
What makes me hopeful about LinkLonk is that it does not have separate outbound and inbound actions. There is only an upvote which is both inbound (determines what your future self sees) and outbound (it affects what other people see). So you may want to be more careful about what you upvote - because you don't want your future self to receive useless stuff. For example, maybe you would be less likely to upvote an article without reading it purely based on the title that says "Look how terrible the other side is".
3. Proof of work
The amount of attention someone gets from you is directly proportional to how useful their past recommendations have been to you. In other words, to get your attention they need to prove to be good curators of content for you. They cannot fake it by upvoting the most popular content. That’s because you connect only to those users who have upvoted the content you like before you did it - ie, before the content became popular.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoThanks, that's some fairly reasonable considerations on how this could remain better than current social media models!