4 ms·
Surge protectors are for standard load dumps, like air conditioners or other engines that can dump 1000V into your powerlines. Lightning is like 300,000,000 vo
by dragontamer 5y ago
Surge protectors are for standard load dumps, like air conditioners or other engines that can dump 1000V into your powerlines.
Lightning is like 300,000,000 volts. No surge protector is strong enough for that.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoYou’re not going to see the 300MV unless you had the lightning strike a pole with your cables connected to it, though. I wonder if optically isolated Ethernet couplers (do they even exist??) could work instead of the much more expensive fiber hardware on either end.
- AdrianB1 5y agoCompletely optically isolated Ethernet couplers requires a power source on each side, but it can be done; the most accessible one is a set of media converters with a very short optical patch cable. In this particular case to protect both the garage and generator side keeping the CAT6 cable underground you need one optical double conversion on each side and an independent, sacrificial power supply for the copper part converters. Doable, but too complicated.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoRight, that's the obvious option. I was thinking of a barebones "on the wire" approach but I'm not sure that's possible. The fastest integrated optoisolators I can find seem to all max out at 50MBd/s which simply isn't going to be enough to switch 100BASE-TX (which has a ~125MBd/s rate) without needing some sort of ethernet-aware logic (e.g. a primitive MAC controller) on either end to handle buffer overruns. 10BASE-T should be plenty possible though: it only needs a 16MHz channel and even sampling that 2x at the Nyquist rate of 32MHz is still within the capabilities of the $1 optoisolators. 10Mbps is plenty for an application like this one (and probably most industrial control purposes) but it's not exactly something anyone will publicly confess to wanting or using even if it's in order to pay two orders of magnitude less.
- AdrianB1 5y agoI don't know how the small optoisolators do when the current from a lightning strike can easily arch over several inches or a few feet. The ugly solution with a fiber patch cord on each side gives several feet of electrical insulation.
- detaro 5y agoFiber hardware really isn't that expensive anymore though. Gigabit SFPs are <$10, you can find switches with SFP ports for <$100.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoFiber itself is cheaper than CAT6 and SFPs are indeed affordable (mainly thanks to the likes of FS.com where I can get for $30 an SMF transceiver that HP sells for over $250 and uses DRM to enforce in even their switches that cost less than the cost of a single transceiver), but switches with more than two (and extremely recently, four) 10G SFP+ ports are still too expensive for my liking (and haven't really yet hit the second-hand market).
- AdrianB1 5y agoMikrotik has that famous CRS305-1G-4S+IN switch with 4 SFP+ for just $135. If you need more ports, CRS309-1G-8S+IN gives you 8 ports for $300. Double the ports again, you have CRS317-1G-16S+RM for $400, at $25/port it is the best price for many ports.
- colechristensen 5y agoSurge protectors are absolutely enough for most lightning related surges which are absolutely not the full current of a lightning bolt going through your equipment, but a little bit finding the path through to ground though your stuff. Back in the dialup days we used to lose a few modems a year to lightning, our computer didn't explode into a ball of fiery doom. (and the ancient phone would ring for a fraction of a second and you'd think "shit, I forgot to unplug the modem, there goes another one".