2 ms·
For what it's worth I have never used any of the cryptocurrencies. It just seemed to me that this is a viable solution to a difficult problem - a way to associa
by dotancohen 5y ago
For what it's worth I have never used any of the cryptocurrencies. It just seemed to me that this is a viable solution to a difficult problem - a way to associate a cost with a behaviour that we'd like to limit, in a way that does not prevent the poor, disadvantaged, or those who wish to remain anonymous from participating.
- xfer 5y ago> in a way that does not prevent the poor, disadvantaged, Yeah mining coins totally doesn't exclude poor people. If it costs less than the profit spammers make they will use it. You can't just handwave the thresold away, and pretend you are solving the problem by just asking for money(thereby excluding large swaths of people). Just use your iMessage.
- emacsen 5y agoThis is probably the worst part about any kind of payment based system, whether it be money or proof of work- these systems do reflect the disadvantages of the economies of the world. That said, since this problem already exists in the world, it is often overstated. If a stamp is a reasonable cost, and only a one time cost, it will be largely invisible. 25 cents (a price set by the recipient) to send a message from a stranger won't have a big impact on most people, and it's important to recognize it's only the first time. It's further important to know it would even be possible to refund the cost of the stamp back to the sender once the message is sent. The recipient could have a button that says "Return stamp" which would then let the sender re-use or in some other way organize the stamp. Now let's contrast to today... Let's say I want to send a message to a big movie star or a CEO. The chances that I will be able to get their address is relatively low. Even if I do, they likely have someone they pay to filter their messages before it gets to them.
- xfer 5y agoI am sure such a scheme embedded into a protocol would work with certain group of people. Most people would just get the same amount of spam, because they can't afford to up their threshold in a way that would deter the "marketeers" to stop such activity.
- emacsen 5y agoI actually think it would dramatically cut down on spam, but not hate messages.
- cabalamat 5y agoIf the sender is on the recipient's allow-list then it goes straight through. Otherwise the recipient has to solve a captcha. This allows humans to send small numbers of emails easily, but makes it harder for spammers. Also, recipients could have deny-lists and automatically share them with others they trust. The deny-lists might be a list of senders' cryptographically generated IDs, in which case it should be reasonably hard to generate new ones (e.g. 10 minutes on an X86 cpu using an algorithm not conducive to parallelisation or special hardware).
- denton-scratch 5y ago> Otherwise the recipient has to solve a captcha. No way am I going to solve captchas for incoming emails! Not any.
- snmx999 5y agoSpam from hell: you don't know if the email is real and you have to solve a CAPTCHA to find out.
- rtpg 5y agoShouldn’t the sender be who needs to solve the captcha?