3 ms·
The main problem with email is simple lack of privacy in my opinion. Privacy is the primary attraction of instant messaging. End to end encryption is OK but mo
by jqpabc123 5y ago
The main problem with email is simple lack of privacy in my opinion.
Privacy is the primary attraction of instant messaging. End to end encryption is OK but most users don't really need it and it tends to complicate operations.
Fixing the privacy issue doesn't require any changes to protocol or email clients. The solution is really just a configurable email forwarding service.
Every user should have both a public email address used for sending and a private email address used for receiving. The mail server automatically replaces the private address with the public address on all outgoing mail.
Received mail gets forwarded from public to private only if it meets certain rules setup on the mail server. Otherwise, the address is rejected as unknown.
A simple rule set would be a list of allowed addresses. If an address is not on the list, it gets rejected. Addresses are automatically added to the allow list by sending an outbound message to the recipient's address OR by sending a coded message to the mail server. Likewise, an address can be deleted from the list by sending a coded message to the mail server. If you actually want email from anyone, don't apply any rules.
What does a "coded message" look like? How about one addressed to the target but with an empty body and either "!ADD" or "!DEL" as the subject?
I have considered building this myself on occasion but all the reputation machinations currently in place that attempt but largely fail to address the spam problem act as a deterrent.
- cogman10 5y agoI'd call spam one of the biggest problems with email. To solve it, I'd say a protocol extension is needed. In the ideal case, you could have a certificate authority and everyone's email gets signed. Spam and get your cert revoked globally. That would be hard to pull off though.
- dboreham 5y agoThis has been tried (several times). Email server operators are too lazy to configure it. Spammers subvert the servers that do have it configured.
- jqpabc123 5y agoSpam is the lack of privacy I was referring to. To solve it, I'd say a protocol extension is needed. Or maybe a protocol reduction. The relay system is the source of lots of evil and was really designed for a bygone era. Eliminate "open" relays --- only accept email directly from the source server --- and most spam goes away with a simple privacy filter as I described above. It is easy to "spoof" an address, much harder to "spoof" a server.