5 ms·
What desktop Linux needs to succeed in the mainstream
- guilhas 5y agoI am happy as it is right now. Use Linux for most things, if I need to play a Windows only game I just launch virt-manager/qemu Very smooth, and all malware gaming related is inside the box not messing my data and work Windows has its market. And Linux development continues full force. And people use whatever they like
- koffiezet 5y agoI used linux on the desktop full-time until 20 years ago, and even back-then it was already going to be "year of the linux desktop". It's simply never going to get there, and I'm fine with that.
- Bostonian 5y agoMaybe it should be accepted that the dominant form of "desktop Linux" will be Windows Subsystem for Linux (WSL, especially WSL 2), now that WSL accommodates Linux GUI programs. One gets all of the functionality of Windows and much of the functionality of Linux. (I understand that many Linux users on HN do not want all the Windows functionality for reasons of privacy and security.)
- petepete 5y agoI'd argue that it's actually ChromeOS. It doesn't get too much attention but the numbers keep growing - especially in education.
- gryph0n 5y agoDoesn't that crown (most dominant Linux) belong to Android ? WSL's appeal is limited to mostly techies/geeks, while average "Joe" is pretty much familiar with the Android OS.
- gtsop 5y agoI generally agree. A point on Linus' videos though: his criticism is objectively not fair to the community. I have been using linux for everything (work/gaming/devops etc) for over 7 years now. To this date I still stumble uppon simple issues that a normal user would probably never figute out how to solve. Linus is right in this regard, there is waaay to go, linux distros are not yet plug and play for normies. However, and this is my problem with Linus' criticism: He has taken an existing subset of the people in the linux community (toxic gatekeepets who will also claim limux is noobie friendly) and he is replying to the whole community in frustration, as if we all are these people. So the thousands of volunteered effort, delivered for free to all of us, gets a slap from Linus because some specific people set some arbitrarily high expectations. He actually disclaims this fact, but I don't buy the disclaimer. It is not polite/fair to say "this sucks, the other sucks, X thing is horrible" when people have volunteered so much free work to get it to this state. For that reason, I am annoyed at his take on the challenge. I see luke's stance as waay more appropriate. I am grateful to everyone who has contributed to this wonderful ecosystem. Yes, there is way to go.
- 1MachineElf 5y agoI was very shocked after watching the first and second Linux challenge videos. In the third video Linus uploaded yesterday[0], it seemed like he was being a lot more diplomatic, and distinguished between a small number of toxic gatekeepers vs. the wider community and their positive contributions. [0] https://youtu.be/TtsglXhbxno https://youtu.be/TtsglXhbxno
- V__ 5y agoI recommend checking out Linus's WAN-Show videos, they discuss it there with more context and nuance, something which the shorter cut videos can't do that well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mN3QFw2BEcw&t=3587s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mN3QFw2BEcw&t=3587s [timestamp: 59:47] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MAlgKdsdvg&t=1820s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MAlgKdsdvg&t=1820s [timestamp: 30:20] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h0boUNc1JOg&t=3148s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h0boUNc1JOg&t=3148s [timestamp: 52:28] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9PcNrhiMUc&t=2292s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9PcNrhiMUc&t=2292s [timestamp: 38:12]
- esarbe 5y agoI don't buy it. The premise is that the Linux desktop developers were just just follow these concepts or to follow that strategy, Linux would all of a sudden achieve desktop supremacy. There's no such thing as an 'intuitive interface'. It's been claimed that "The only intuitive interface is the nipple", but as many a parent knows, not even the nipple is intuitive enough by itself and every baby needs guidance. Every desktop has idiosyncrasies. Windows' UI sucks in many, many use cases. This hasn't stopped it from continuing to be dominant in the Desktop area. The reason is ... guidance. Everyone can wreck their computer by doing stupid shit and ignoring all the warnings thrown in their face. They will not read it and complain if something breaks. With Windows (and to some degree OS X) this is not so much of a problem. You can just call that one friend that "knows computers" and after some begging and crying, you'll get help. Or you can bring your bricked computer to the next support store and they'll try to fix it. (Almost) every elderly person above a certain age is lost when it comes to computers. Most people alive cannot be trusted to install an application - not on Windows, not on Linux and not even on OS X (well, maybe on OS X nowadays, because you cannot install unsigned software these days) because all that software might be compromised. Every time you let a software on to your system, you can potentially brick it. And then you need a solid understanding of what's going on. For most people, computers are black boxes whose internal state is a mystery that is far too complex to be explored. They have no interest in exploring these mysteries. They have work to do; forms to fill, letters to write. And these people need the aforementioned informal support they can turn to whenever they need to diverge from the well-trodden paths. It doesn't depend on the operating system, but on the surrounding support system. The Linux as a Desktop operating system is simply lacking the market share to boast such an informal support system. That's all.
- tomnipotent 5y ago> There's no such thing as an 'intuitive interface' I can't remember where I read it (maybe Design of Everyday Things?), but something that really stuck with me was "intuitive is just another way of calling something familiar".
- grumpyprole 5y agoExactly, that is why Gnome is not as intuitive as it could be, it does not work at all like Windows or Mac OS. Sway works very differently to Windows and MacOS, but at least brings potential productivity advantages in doing so.
- treis 5y agoThis is somewhat an odd read. As examples, I don't recall ever having my desktop crash. It's way more stable and performs better than Windows. Then his point about the install of ODS doesn't make sense. Yes, the text of the button says build instructions. But the page it's a link to has easy install instructions for every distribution under the sun. You have to scroll past them to get to the instrucitons to actually build the package.
- fomine3 5y agoI've had many desktop crashes with GeForce. I don't blame Linux desktop for this.
- noir_lord 5y agoThis is going to sound somewhat selfish but I don't actually care if desktop linux succeeds in the mainstream. It's been my primary operating system on the desktop since the very early 2000's and in all that period it has never been 5%. There is enough users and momentum to keep it going beyond that I don't care. For a developer it's basically a solved problem.
- toper-centage 5y agoIt's funny that people think that even 1% of all desktop users is "little". That's hundreds of millions of users.
- Paianni 5y agoI don't think there are 10 billion desktop users.
- slategruen 5y agoSame sentiments but I have my reservations. I wish we just have enough Linux users to drive open standards. A lot of proprietary standards became proprietary because companies just doesn't care about a few Linux users.
- karmakaze 5y agoDesktop Linux succeeding (if we're talking about mainstream consumer use) seems like it would be too late at this point. We need mobile Linux on phones, tablets, and AR/VR devices to succeed. And this is where it gets confusing to me. 'Linux' to me is for general purpose computing, a creators platform. Mainstream consumer mobile devices are not that, because many/most users don't need it to be. The closest thing that might be a mobile creator-capable device is the iPad Pro or Surface Tablet. Desktop Linux was an elusive but seemingly achievable/well-defined target. A mobile Linux to catch up to an iPad Pro for general users seems much less well defined or achievable. Even starting with Android (AOSP) doesn't seem close to a creators device. A good device in the meantime could be a (open/degoogled/jailbroken) Android phone that works well in some desktop mode connected to a USB-C display and bluetooth kb/mouse running standard Linux server and development software. This view (and I) may be too old and instead that device only needs to be a client for cloud-based development. TL;DR the Linux Desktop ship has sailed, aim for the next target.
- ncmncm 5y agoIf distros would just turn off the Caps Lock key by default, all would be good--especially, on Live images that can't remember settings from one boot to the next. Make it work as Ctrl. And, make Linux Libertine the default font. There is no reason why people should have to suffer with stupid typefaces.
- Sayrus 5y agoI'm using mine as Escape but almost everyone I know use it as Caps Lock. To be honest, outside of the people using Vim/Emacs, I haven't seen anyone remapping Caps Lock. Usually users with remapped key know how to change their keymap to match their needs, users not remapping don't. It is a small inconvenience for a minority of the users that they can easily handle. Changing this to Ctrl/Escape/Whatever else by default would be a huge inconvenience for most users. And the Caps Lock key is not useless either, my older relatives can't keep Shift pressed while typing an uppercase word or sentence. Even for single uppercase letter, it makes sense for them to sequentially use Caps Lock > Letter > Caps Lock.
- ncmncm 5y agoThere is no legitimate use for Caps Lock. If you think otherwise, what you lack is education, or are a cockroach named Archie. Using it to shift one letter is much worse than silly. It is what is called, in court, an Attractive Nuisance. Courts often order those to be disabled, so there is ample precedent. Sayrus's remark demonstrates firmly that a "Linux Desktop" that appeals to windos users would be a disaster.
- peakaboo 5y agoI hope it never succeeds in the mainstream. Reason: Look at windows and mac os and the enormous user exploitation and disregard for privacy and choice. How anyone can enjoy tech using those platforms is beyond me. I guess we have very different ideas of what my computer and my privacy means.
- pydry 5y ago>I am one of the original developers of the Sway >The most frustrating moments for a user is when the software they’re using does something inexplicable Lol, speaking of... I tried installing sway a few weeks ago on ubuntu because I thought it sounded cool and because I still get somewhat nostalgic for ion. It logged in to a blank screen with zero indication about what to do next. I guess it expected me to already have all of its keybindings memorized? Or maybe I was supposed to write a config file first? Was it a bug? Maybe I was supposed to already be an i3 user who knew what to do next? I kind of expected it to do something. I quickly lost interest.
- rickstanley 5y agoI was eager to try Sway out, but if they don't provide some kind of "telescope" where I can type keywords to find the keystrokes of a command that I want to do, then I'm out.
- 8K832d7tNmiQ 5y agoYou missed the punchline: > However, it is designed for me: a professional, expert-level Linux user. I am under no illusions that it is suitable for my grandmother
- pydry 5y agoI saw it. I'm also a professional expert level linux user. I'm well aware that I could throw myself into researching how it works and figure it all out I just figured that the starter implied that the main course wasnt worth holding out for. I don't object to this level of user hostility since it is, after all, free software and he has no obligation to me. If he writes it just for himself thats absolutely fine. I'm not aggrieved. I just found it a tad ironic that he is lecturing us on UX for grandmas given the level of user hostility his own software exhibited to experts. (That is, assuming it's not a way out of date version or a debian bug or something that caused this - im trying to be generous here)
- abenga 5y agoWhy would a computer system do anything without input from you? I don't understand what you expected? A tutorial slide show, maybe?
- jefurii 5y ago> It is silly to suggest that Formula 1 vehicle designs ought to accommodate non-expert drivers, or that professional racecar drivers should be driving mini-vans on the circuit. However, it is equally silly to design a professional racing vehicle and market it to soccer moms. Another good example would be a commercial truck or construction vehicle. You wouldn't expect a regular person to be able to climb up into a big rig or an excavator and be able to drive away in it.
- akomtu 5y agoDo you really want it to succeed? Popularity among average users comes with greedy businessmen who tend to spoil everything they touch. Do you want apt-get to display ads or send em.. telemetry to god knows who? Do you want a "clouds powered" bash terminal that's an electron app rendering a remote terminal running on AWS? How about ffmpeg with a mandatory DMCA module for "safety reasons" or MS arbitrarily adding and deleting packages on your Ubuntu and rebooting it because you happened to be in some experiment group? Because that's where the money are.
- johnisgood 5y agoWhat you are saying is absolutely true. Do not let them poison us.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoto be honest i don't really think linux need to do anything to accommodate those unable to read any doc, they already get an os free of charge, and honestly i was there when Ubuntu came out and i doubt Linux communities need another wave of individuals who can barely tie their shoes
- simonblack 5y agoLinux is mainstream. Just because it may not be on your desktop doesn't mean anything. Linux is on my desktop and that's all that matters to me. I drive a Mercedes, the fact you might drive a Ford is not going to impact my life in the slightest. And if all of the invisible Linux machines in your personal life suddenly disappeared you would be helpless. "I reckon that we could use a commercial, general-purpose end-user Linux distro." There are any number of those already available. How many more do you need?
- johnisgood 5y agoWho cares? All of my friends use Linux as their desktop. They have been for over a decade. Additionally, I made others Linux users just by installing it on their laptop instead of installing Windows. It made no difference to them. One of them told me she wants to have Opera and whatever else on it. I installed them. Everything works, and she is now a Linux user. In any case, Linux is already doing pretty good. All my packages get updated, my favorite programs along with libraries I use are maintained, and I hear a lot about Linux-related stuff. It is doing pretty damn good!
- agraham 5y ago"Linux is one of the best operating systems for professional programmers and sysadmins, to such an extraordinary degree that most programmers I know treat Windows programmers and sysadmins as the object of well-deserved ridicule." I make video games on Windows for Windows. I don't see why I'm well-deserving of ridicule for that. It's not clear if it's the author's opinion as well as the opinion of programmers he knows. Either way to me this sentiment is part of the reason Linux is seen as unwelcoming and this article makes me less interested in desktop linux than ever.
- phendrenad2 5y agoIt's always shocking to me when otherwise good programmers, smart people, can repeat such obvious tritenesses. He managed to fit two into this sentence: 1) "Linux is one of the best operating systems for professional programmers and sysadmins" 2) "Windows programmers: the object of well-deserved ridicule" I'm sure DD can't back up either of these claims with logic. Probably a case of playing to one's audience a bit too much.
- phendrenad2 5y agoMost Linux users don't care if Linux succeeds in the mainstream. You're fighting an uphill battle if you need to get the general community on-board, and they literally just don't care. Users who don't care, don't care because they went through the trouble of becoming Linux experts, and they had fun doing it. They don't care about anyone else's experience. In fact, maybe changing Linux to be more beginner-friendly will cause it to be less fun for this type of user. The ones that DO care, overwhelmingly just want to see Linux "win" (whatever that means) without compromising a single thing about how Linux currently is (see the blowback against systemd, snap, flatpak, nvidia drivers, Ubuntu in general, System76 making a new DE in Rust, etc.) The remainder of users who do care, just want to help people regain their privacy by leaving the big tech ecosystems. These users don't really care if Linux is hard to use, they will go to great lengths to maintain privacy. And they expect newly converted Linux users to do the same. So if the userbase is hostile to what you want to do, what do you do? You can change the minds of the userbase (hard to do when everyone is so dogmatic), or you can expand the userbase and bring in a new segment of users who care about different things. Usability over privacy and "winning". System76 is quietly doing this already. And that mirror's Drew's conclusion in this post. To make something with mass appeal, you'll have to charge money for it.
- Epiphany21 5y agoWith great power comes great responsibility. Users who want more powerful tools need to understand that there's a steeper learning curve. Desktop Linux is already fine for a lot of people, even non-technical users. My father doesn't even know what an operating system is and he can still work his way around Ubuntu well enough to use the web browser and office suite and manage photos from his phone. He also has enough common sense to read error messages and would never answer yes to a prompt saying it could hose the system.
- lproven 5y agoEveryone is forgetting ChromeOS. Only @petepete seems to have mentioned it. It is by far the dominant desktop/laptop Linux in the world. ChromeBooks run nothing else and have been consistently selling 20 to 30 million units per year for half a decade or so. Roughly as many ChromeBooks sell annually as the historic total desktop users of all distros put together since desktop distros first appeared. It is eminently usable by the general public without training or documentation.