3 ms·
It's not an arbitrary definition of "successful". Singapore is a prosperous city with a well-fed, well-housed, educated, healthy population. These are all key d
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
It's not an arbitrary definition of "successful". Singapore is a prosperous city with a well-fed, well-housed, educated, healthy population. These are all key development and quality of life metrics and are indeed a good example "human achievement".
Of course we can debate what role the authoritarian nature of their system played in that, if any.
We may tend to see things through a "1st world problems" prism, but when the people start with nothing, starving in a shack (which is still the life of many people on this planet) the metrics I mentioned are infinitely more important than the death penalty for drug trafficking (which is hardly a massive issue in any case).
- robbedpeter 5y agoGangsters legitimizing their money, and a society willing to whore itself out to profit off of it, tarnishes any overall definition of "successful" you can apply to Singapore. They're much like Saudi Arabia, which is also very successful financially, with a fairly high quality of life. In both cases, the injustices and degradation of liberty is more important to my view of what a successful society looks like. They're an ethical Potemkin village, keeping the "dirty"things from which they profit a few degrees of separation from their ostensibly clean financial dynamo. Singapore, on the surface of things, almost has things right. The problems arise when you look past to the superficial goods into the overall social functioning - there's some really dark evil with deep ties to Singapore. Also, to make things clear, the US has its fair share of problems like this. Notably, the war on drugs and the cartels enabled by our failed policies are an absolute travesty. The advantage of liberalizing speech is the ability of a society to continually evolve toward the improvement of human wellbeing. When societies suppress speech, that's a telltale signal that those in power are engaged in shady business they don't want the peasants to squawk about. All that said, Singapore is a remarkably civilized and pleasant place to visit - I just wouldn't want to live there. If it gets held to account through revolution or civil breakdown, its failure mode will be spectacular.
- lotusmars 5y agoEurope is choke full of Russian or Ukrainian criminal money: mafia, oligarchs, police, prosectutors all launder their money to Montenegro hotel property and Italian villas. Corruption is rampant in Europe. It's only layman's money will be AML'd. Real crime will easily find a way around it. At least Singapore and Dubai allow money to be laundered officially.