4 ms·
> There isn't a platform any large number of people use that is exempt from this. I can think of a few. TCP/IP, email, BitTorrent, TLS, RSS. Millions of peopl
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> There isn't a platform any large number of people use that is exempt from this.
I can think of a few. TCP/IP, email, BitTorrent, TLS, RSS.
Millions of people use Linux. A single digit percentage of people, but millions of people. Not even counting the majority of servers on the internet.
And the way Linux does it proves that you can do it that way. The largest platforms just don't.
- BoorishBears 5y agoThis is abusing semantics to the point you just make yourself look unknowledgeable. And honestly I feel like you know better... TCP/IP? Protocol. Email? You mean SMTP the protocol, or email platforms like GMail that people get locked out of all the time, or you mean a tiny platform with a fraction of the users? BitTorrent... the protocol. TLS... the protocol. Are you joking callling this a platform? RSS... same. Linux the OS? Because Linux sure doesn't have a centralized platform built into it last I checked. When you forget your Linux password where's the reset link? - Like to be clear, my statement is tautological. For any useful definition of "platform with large number of users" you need to have fraud protection. It's not really an ideological thing, anyone who's run any platform of a meaningful size knows you get attackers, and attackers scale. So you need to defend against attacks, and legitimate users can accidentally trigger any form of attack detection, human or otherwise.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Email? You mean SMTP the protocol, or email platforms like GMail that people get locked out of all the time, or you mean a tiny platform with a fraction of the users? Email is a platform. Anyone on any provider can email anyone else on any provider. And then you can choose one you trust not to lock you out, or run your own. The others are the same. A platform is something you build other things on top of. HTTPS is built on top of TLS. Webmail services are built on top of HTTPS and SMTP. You want a more traditional platform? Java. > Linux the OS? Because Linux sure doesn't have a centralized platform built into it last I checked. Who said anything about centralization? The centralization is the source of the defect. > When you forget your Linux password where's the reset link? Boot from live installer and reset the password. But also, why is "password resets" necessary for something to be a platform?
- cmeacham98 5y agoI'm going to assume you're acting in good faith and just haven't seen this definition of platform. The one everyone else in this thread is using is "an application or website that serves as a base from which a service is provided" (that's straight from Merriam-Webster) Examples include (also from M-W): "music streaming platforms" "has built a cloud-computing platform for use by others" "billions of photos scraped from Facebook and other social media platforms" The only one that really could count in your examples is email, and if you think that doesn't have problems try setting up your own server and sending to gmail, hotmail, and other large providers without getting sent to spam or outright bounced.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThat's definition (b) from M-W. Definition (a) is "operating system." Though that's kind of a layman's oversimplification and it's more specifically the operating system's API implementation, which is why Java qualifies by providing the same thing. But also, how does email not fit under (b)? Or Signal etc.?
- cmeacham98 5y agoDefinition (a) goes on to include "also : the computer architecture and equipment using a particular operating system", which I think is largely accurate and I agree something like java would probably fit. Email and Signal are kinda on the fence for me, because they're split up in a way where it's not really one cohesive platform in the same sense as a social media platform. Regardless, even if you consider them platforms in this sense, both have the same issue with the detection of spam and other bad actors.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoAs far as I know Signal doesn't do spam filtering at all and has no means to read your messages. They just separate things sent from people not in your contacts until you add them, which happens entirely at the discretion of the peer and not the service.
- cmeacham98 5y agoTCP/IP: Not really a "platform", but if you consider the internet as a platform: Your ISP puts you on a CGNAT with an abuser, or you random into a floating IP that is blacklisted as a bad actor Email: Try setting up your own email server and sending to $largeESP BitTorrent: Not a platform, but: This issue exists one layer up at the level of BitTorrent trackers (without which BT is mostly useless) TLS+RSS: Same as TCP/IP Linux: Not a platform, but you could probably get banned from package mirrors if you get the same IP as some asshole trying to DOS them and waste bandwidth
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> TCP/IP: Not really a "platform", but if you consider the internet as a platform: Your ISP puts you on a CGNAT with an abuser, or you random into a floating IP that is blacklisted as a bad actor So then you use a VPN. It's also not the same thing because that's being done by endpoints instead of the platform as an intermediary. > This issue exists one layer up at the level of BitTorrent trackers (without which BT is mostly useless) Modern BitTorrent uses a DHT for this. Trackers, to the extent that they still exist, are just to make peer discovery faster. > Linux: Not a platform, but you could probably get banned from package mirrors if you get the same IP as some asshole trying to DOS them and waste bandwidth There are many independent package mirrors and also you can access them from any IP address (e.g. using a VPN again). Also, this: http://manpages.ubuntu.com/manpages/bionic/man8/apt-p2p.8.html http://manpages.ubuntu.com/manpages/bionic/man8/apt-p2p.8.ht...
- georgyo 5y agoTCP/IP relies on your ISP routing you. They can disown you, taking you offline. Email is fairly dependent on DNS which is fairly dependent on a domain. Your TLD can deregister your domain, and domain hijacking is still a thing. Similarly, most people do not have an appetite to self host email and are subject to the whims of their provider. BitTorrent is a decent example, DHT are fairly robust but also not easily searched. The discovery method of BitTorrent is frequently subject to DMCA takedowns. These takedowns have taken down legitimate torrents as well. TLS and RSS are not platforms, and fall victim to the same thing as email. The internet is built on many levels of trust, but just because we trust in it doesn't mean it isn't possible to deplatform at very low levels.
- hermitdev 5y agoNot to mention self hosting your email will likely mean facing an uphill battle against spam filters blocking you. And seriously, fighting that alone could become a full time job unless you don't care to email.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> TCP/IP relies on your ISP routing you. They can disown you, taking you offline. They can cancel your service, obviously, but that prevents you from using Verizon, not from using TCP/IP. You go sign up for AT&T or Comcast or Starlink and you can still communicate with anyone on the internet. > Email is fairly dependent on DNS which is fairly dependent on a domain. Which is why I didn't list DNS. But dependencies are something else. In theory anyone can deny you access to anything by putting you in prison, but by then you're really arguing that preventing this is impossible because a military could wrongfully kill you, rather than talking about whether some specific thing is the thing causing it.