5 ms·
It should be unlawful, maybe criminal, to revoke access to digital goods a customer bought and paid for. How the heck have we normalized *theft* as standard bus
by perihelions 5y ago
It should be unlawful, maybe criminal, to revoke access to digital goods a customer bought and paid for. How the heck have we normalized *theft* as standard business practice?
- FrancoisBosun 5y agoFor better or for worse, we have “agreed” to the teens and conditions …
- novok 5y agoThat doesn't matter when it's illegal. Statute overrides contract.
- User23 5y agoIn California at least it's actually tortious to offer certain illegal contracts of adhesion. That right is rarely exercised, but you do in fact have standing to sue simply because you were asked to sign a contract with clauses that oppose California public policy.
- pronlover723 5y agoThere are plenty of laws that override terms and conditions. A one example, on many countries landlords can not throw out tenants on a whim. Telephone companies can not cut off service on a whim. There are similar laws for utility companies and banks. Arguably it's about time for similar laws for Apple, Google, and Microsoft who potentially hold the keys to your entire life.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoGotcha capitalism and inverted totalitarianism. Submit to the interests of the plutocrats and go into debt buying today's fancy widgets, or be banished.
- donmcronald 5y agoIn my jurisdiction I swear you could sue them in small claims court. I think it’s pretty easy to do and lawyers aren’t allowed. You’d probably end up with someone from the nearest Apple store representing Apple and they’d have no answers. Even if you lose, there aren’t any downsides and Apple would have to send an employee to participate. I would absolutely do it if I ended up in the same position.
- dataflow 5y agoIsn't small claims unable to issue injunctive relief though? Or can they do that in your jurisdiction?
- User23 5y agoThis sounds like an area where the arbitration clause could actually work in your favor.
- donmcronald 5y agoI have no idea. The point would be to make them spend more time and money than they’d have to if they simply had better support escalation.
- kortilla 5y agoTheft of what though? You don’t own any of the music you pay to access. It’s all just revokable licenses to consume media.
- perihelions 5y agoTheft of something that was purchased in a transaction for perpetual use, a digital analogue of physical property. It's not a private company's place to redefine how civil property rights work, to their one-sided benefit.