3 ms·
In this case ... it's all but certainly a losing battle. Keep in mind that when this was written, the Web had been in general release for about 7 years. The r
by dredmorbius 5y ago
In this case ... it's all but certainly a losing battle.
Keep in mind that when this was written, the Web had been in general release for about 7 years. The rant itself was a response to the emergent phenomenon that URIs were not static and unchanging. The Web as a whole was a small fraction of its present size --- the online population was (roughly) 100x smaller, and it looks as if the number of Internet domains has grown by about the same (1.3 million ~1997 vs. > 140 million in 2019Q3, growing by about 1.5 million per year). The total number of websites in 2021 depends on what and how you count, but is around 200 million active and 1.7 billion total.
https://www.nic.funet.fi/index/FUNET/history/internet/en/kasvu.html https://www.nic.funet.fi/index/FUNET/history/internet/en/kas...
https://makeawebsitehub.com/how-many-domains-are-there/ https://makeawebsitehub.com/how-many-domains-are-there/
https://websitesetup.org/news/how-many-websites-are-there/ https://websitesetup.org/news/how-many-websites-are-there/
And we've got thirty years of experience telling us that the mean life of a URL is on the order of months, not decades.
If your goal is stable and preserved URLs and references, you're gonna need another plan, 'coz this one? It ain't workin' sunshine.
What's good, in this case, is to provide a mechanism for archival, preferably multiple, and a means of searching that archive to find specific content of interest.
- Andrex 5y agoAre losing battles still worth fighting? Personally I believe yes, because there are still those that benefit in the interim. Compare that to not bothering to fight at all in the first place.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere's a good recent School of Life video on rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic (Alain defends the practice). There's also performing maintenance to defer the inevitable. I'm generally in favour of that. But if you're getting exercised and emotional over something that simply and repeatedly proves not to work ... and there's some specific goal for that behaviour ... which can be more readily achieved by other means ... then I'd strongly suggest bailing on that fight. TBL got some things right about the Web. He had a specific purpose in mind. The Web has (IMO very much for the worse) moved beyond that. As I see it: - The goal behind the advice is to create a long-term useful addressable archive of online content. - The method advised ... has failed in this. Spectacularly. - Other methods exist. They are being used, and work reasonably well. - At some point you cut your losses. That said, I'm cutting mine in this thread. Cheers.
- Andrex 5y agoEven though you cut your losses, I wanted to thank you for this comment. I sincerely appreciate the reading/watching material.
- tjoff 5y agoFor the absolute vast majority of cases this is a quite a simple problem. Most don't care though. A rewrite of a site does not rewrite all the content. It is still there, the database might have been migrated but all the information is still there and the conversion process has everything it needs to do the final step of preserving one ID, or one string, that trivially can map an old URL to a new one that contains the same actual content. Sure, some intermediate pages might get lost but that is not something that is particularly valuable anyway and not something one usually links directly to. Don't let perfect get in the way of good enough.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSites aren't merely re-written, they're abandoned, hosters/maintainers die, they're hijacked, bought and sold, or vanish in datacentre fires or other disasters. Entire TLDs may disappear or get transferred. The foundations, in a word, are profoundly unstable. The entire ediface has little robustness. If you want preservation, find a better mechanism. URIs ain't it.
- tjoff 5y agoSure, but that is not really what the article is about. And rewrites are the most common of them and also being the easiest to actually have control over, and most can't even be bothered with that.