7 ms·
I don’t understand why (from a technical or legal perspective) this company exists. Their product’s user experience is strictly worse than having an HTTPS port
by hedora 5y ago
I don’t understand why (from a technical or legal perspective) this company exists.
Their product’s user experience is strictly worse than having an HTTPS portal that lets people upload and download files. Is the value add that 99% of companies that receive signed documents are too incompetent to secure such a server?
The only other thing I can think of is that it’s the javascript “blindly click through this PDF to sign” widget.
Surely, there’s some value add behind the scenes? Right?
- castillar76 5y agoI think you’ve got it there: it’s the “click here to sign this” thing that they’ve packaged into something a non-IT-focused company can use. It was relatively useful for them before, but with the pandemic you have tons of companies looking for a way to get people to sign agreements and submit paperwork in a legally binding fashion without needing to meet in person. The “legally binding” thing is important, I think: you could set up a click portal, but it seems like DocuSign is standing on their “this will hold up in court if challenged” claims. That transfer of liability is the other attractive element.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoThere's also the "why go for the less known option when you can afford the industry leader" effect. Many companies have/used to have this advantage: Salesforce, Oracle comes to mind
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rossdavidh 5y agoIf, legally, your company needed to defend in court why it set up its legally binding signature software in the manner it did, then "we used the company everyone else uses", will probably be enough to demonstrate due diligence. Few judges or juries are going to find "doing things the industry standard way", to be criminal negligence. Someone with a more software-informed background may disagree, but the judge and jury are unlikely to be programmers. It's the modern equivalent of the old "nobody got fired for buying IBM".
- ushakov 5y agoif i sign using Apple Preview is it less legally binding? do we have a law, which says "use DocuSign" else a signature is not as legally binding? honestly, it feels like a marketing and scaremongering to justify the higher price and preference over the competitors
- dsomers 5y agoI just had this conversation with my lawyer, in the Netherlands, and probably most or Europe, signing digitally is not legally binding. I’m sure this will be different for different jurisdictions.
- ryanlol 5y agoThis is nonsense. Adobe offers a handy review of the Dutch law on this subject https://helpx.adobe.com/sign/using/legality-netherlands.html https://helpx.adobe.com/sign/using/legality-netherlands.html
- dsomers 5y agoI don’t think you read or understood the link you posted or my original comment? You know I was saying that in the context of gp asking if it’s legal to sign in Apple preview which is essentially appending a picture of your signature to a pdf with no guarantee from a third party if it’s you that signed it. I don’t know, maybe English is not your native language, in that case, you’re mistake is understandable.
- ryanlol 5y agoYour mistake, not mine. You’re confusing “legally binding” and “binding evidence”, these are two different things. You will have a bad time if you sign a contract using apple preview and then try to argue that you’re not bound by that contract.
- 5y ago
- krisoft 5y agoYes it is in the name. They provide an interface so the parties can sign the document. And then they store the fact that the document was signed in a database and attest to it if required. Even if you know how to develop that (many companies don’t) and even if you wish to spend your developer resources on that instead of whatever brings in the money its not a good idea to roll your own in this case. Why? Because you are a party to the agreement you wish to attest to that it has been signed. If there is a disagreement about anything: who signed the document, when did they sign the document, what was the exact document they signed it will be your database against their word. Who knows, maybe you modified your database for your own sake? Changed the document or faked the signature altogerher. But if you paid for the service of a 3rd party who doesn’t have a financial incentive in the agreement then in any potential dispute you can get them to testify (probably in writing) to what document was signed and who signed it and when.
- vincnetas 5y agodoesn't private key signature guarantee authenticity even if you control the db where signed documents are stored? you know the public key and can check if document was signed with private key of signer.
- cosmojg 5y agoWhat are the odds that the client has a verifiable private key?
- celtain 5y agoAt least 99% of the people signing documents won't have a public key that anyone else can verify. Even if you help them generate one, they'll probably forget about it and you'll be the only one with a record of it, so once again we're left having to trust that you didn't tamper with your records.
- hedora 5y agoIn particular, the business could sign the version it sends to the consumer, and the consumer wouldn’t even have to know about it (pdf’s support attachments). I get the feeling this whole business could be wiped off the face of the earth by an open source hobby project and an enterprise sales team.
- kaetemi 5y agoFunny part is, at the end, a lot of people will "Print to PDF" the resulting PDF, which strips electronic signatures (last time I checked).
- SkyPuncher 5y agoMost people only experience this part of DocuSign - a simple workflow that may require two parties to sign. There are significant use cases around complex workflows and document management. Red-lines, mutli-party contracts, delegation, record keeping, etc.