4 ms·
Your very own account was created less than three weeks ago.
by Apocryphon 5y ago
Your very own account was created less than three weeks ago.
- HNTA_1 5y agoExcept this isn't reddit, I'm not making karma farming posts, and there haven't been federal investigations and congressional hearings that confirmed HackerNews is a known target for propaganda campaigns. You're actually agreeing with me.
- Apocryphon 5y agoI agree that it does seem rather suspect that a subreddit can seemingly multiply its number of subscribers in a matter of months. I further agree that it does seem like agent provocateurs are at work, namely in this very thread, because if I was in charge of a disinfo op, the easiest thing I would do to throw off the trail is to immediately prematurely saturate it with hyperbolic paranoiac allegations like “greatest psyop of our time”, to discredit the idea that my op is an op, by making the idea seem ridiculous and absurd and fringe and cringe.
- HNTA_1 5y ago>I further agree that it does seem like agent provocateurs are at work Doesn't "seem" like it, they are at work. We had a federal investigation and congressional hearings that confirmed this to be true. >namely in this very subthread This isn't reddit. Are you schizophrenic? >because if I was in charge of a disinfo op, the easiest thing I can do to throw off the trail is to immediately prematurely saturate it with hyperbolic paranoiac accusations It's neither paranoiac nor accusational. We had a federal investigation and congressional hearings that confirmed the fact that reddit is a target for propaganda campaigns. >to discredit the idea that my op is an op, by making the idea seem ridiculous and absurd and fringe. What else do the voices tell you?
- Apocryphon 5y agoPlease do not debase yourself with personal attacks and unsubstantiative remarks. > We had a federal investigation and congressional hearings that confirmed the fact that reddit is a target for propaganda campaigns. That is correct, and in fact you should have led off to that, instead of immediately jumping to "may be one of the greatest psyop of our time", which completely drowns out any merit to your message. Saying something is suspect is one thing, immediately accusing it of being the work of phantom Russian hackers essentially frames yourself as being QAnon of another political stripe, and discredits your own position. There were many many #resistance grifters and fabulists during the heady days of Russiagate, and you do yourself no favors by using the same sort of accusatory tone and language as that ilk. Do try harder next time.
- HNTA_1 5y ago>Please do not debase yourself with personal attacks and unsubstantiative remarks. You should follow your own rule here and stop posting. >instead of immediately jumping to "may be one of the greatest psyop of our time", which completely drowns out any merit to your message. Saying something is suspect is one thing, immediately accusing it to be the work of phantom Russian hackers Nothing wrong with jumping to something that factually happened, on the specific subject platform where it happened. Only you believe it drowns out merit because apparently facts and history go against your narrative. They weren't "phantom Russian hackers", they actually were Russian hackers. We know this because we had a federal investigation and congressional hearings that confirmed the fact that reddit is a target for Russian propaganda campaigns. >essentially frames yourself as being QAnon of another political stripe, and discredits your own position. IMAX-level projection. "Believe my false narrative or you're Qanon-like!" >There were many many #resistance grifters and fabulists during the heady days of Russiagate And there it is, the mask slips off, "Russiagate". Straight from the Trumpers Qanon script. >and you do yourself no favors by using the same sort of accusatory tone and language as that ilk. It's accusatory because it actually happened, on the same platform. >Do try harder next time. No need, this worked perfectly.
- Apocryphon 5y ago> You should follow your own rule here and stop posting. I shall never stop posting. > Nothing wrong with jumping to something that factually happened, on the specific subject platform where it happened. It is wrong insofar if you're trying to build a credible case, spouting off wild accusations in a know-it-all manner is not only off-putting, it's downright gauche. We've all lived through the nonstop coverage of the Mueller report and seen what very little resulted from that. Have some perspective, please. > They weren't "phantom Russian hackers", they actually were Russian hackers. We know this because we had a federal investigation and congressional hearings that confirmed the fact that reddit is a target for Russian propaganda campaigns. They existed. And how many votes did they move, exactly? The problem is that what is ascribed to foreign intelligence operations can easily also be attributed to political incompetence and a failure to connect with the people. What happened back then is directly analogous to the r/antiwork situation- you are saying that the Internet Research Agency is at fault for worker discontent. And not, actual material conditions. So it's very easy to point at foreign scapegoats, while not enacting policy to actually improve peoples' lives. And I say scapegoats because the work of these foreign actors, even if they might serve to add further chaos and to catalyze a situation, is not truly at fault for the situation; the fault is in our own doing, for letting it get so bad that it's even possible for an outside catalyst to destabilize things further. > "Believe my false narrative or you're Qanon-like!" Well, some of the mental gymnastics and reaching people did in the shock of political developments back then did seem to be a mirror version of QAnon. There was certainly a lot of cope that led to magical thinking to rationalize policy failure or simply political incompetence. > And there it is, the mask slips off, "Russiagate". Straight from the Trumpers Qanon script. The way I see it, consensus reality broke in American public life after Bush v. Gore and it's been splintering ever since. Russiagate, QAnon, the DNC rigged the primaries against Bernie... everyone's got a narrative these days. It's all gone very hyperreal and Adam Curtis shaped. Hell, it's even how pop culture fandoms work these days: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanhatesthis/the-star-wars-misinformation-hell-is-the-new-future-of https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanhatesthis/the-star-... > It's accusatory because it actually happened, on the same platform. Okay, what's your narrative? What makes r/antiwork such a perfect op? Did it create the Great Resignation? Did it inspire the Amazon unionization efforts already underway? Is it the r/The_Donald behind Striketober? Is it the mastermind conspiring to foment a new Occupy movement? Please, pray tell, explain how a subreddit full of disgruntled workers trading memes is engendering the downfall of the Republic? Do you have any sympathy at all for those people? Or are they all bots and psyops in your outlook? Don't you understand that this makes you look out of touch and callous towards their suffering? Have you no sense of decency? > No need, this worked perfectly. Oh?