5 ms·
Hacker news has a minimum karma requirement for downvoting; you can't just create an account (or a dozen accounts) and start downvoting something you don't like
by kazinator 5y ago
Hacker news has a minimum karma requirement for downvoting; you can't just create an account (or a dozen accounts) and start downvoting something you don't like, or to harass someone with serial downvotes. You must first attract a certain number of upvotes for your comments and submissions.
That fixes many of the abuse problems with downvotes.
HN situations are also monitored by the site operators themselves, who intervene. YT is too vastly big for that.
- busymom0 5y agoAm I wrong or does Stack Overflow deduct a point from your own karma if you downvote someone else?
- smusamashah 5y agoThey do subtract 1 point.
- arpafaucon 5y agoSomething a bit more complicated if I remember well. Something like: - You can down vote questions for free - but down voting answers costs you 1 karma (and encourages you to provide a proper answer instead)
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y ago> HN situations are also monitored by the site operators themselves, who intervene. YT is too vastly big for that. Agreed. Another way of framing this is that HN is sponsored by an organization that makes a lot more money per HN user than Google makes per YouTube user. In other words, HN users don’t have to pay for their own moderation by generating revenue in the same way YouTubes users do.
- cbozeman 5y ago> YT is too vastly big for that. No it's not, it's our society that's fucked. It's our CEOs' legal requirement of fiduciary responsibility that causes these problems. YouTube was 10.9% of Google's revenue for the year 2020, with something around $19,770,000,000 of income. How many employees could Google hire to manually investigate and take action against users? Even 10% of that income to address this problem would hire literally tens of thousands of people to tackle the issue. The "problem" with Big Tech is that they're convinced of their own intelligence and they all believe they can automate their way to Utopia. Well you can't. You're not that smart. You're not that wise. You need bodies on the ground, you need hands doing work. We may get there some day, but it won't be today, tomorrow, ten years from now, and it may not even be a hundred years from now. A little painful hubris in the form of some of these enormous social media platforms collapsing not under their own weight, but under their own arrogance in the form of thinking they can automate their problems away, would be a good dose of medicine sorely needed.
- hamburglar 5y ago> It's our CEOs' legal requirement of fiduciary responsibility that causes these problems. This is nonsense pretty much every time it’s trotted out. There is no objective “requirement of fiduciary responsibility” that governs every action a CEO might take in a given situation, especially not for dumb minutiae like “allowed unfettered downvoting.” If it was this simplistic, we wouldn’t need CEOs at all.
- TheSpiceIsLife 5y agoThere is no fiduciary duty to maximise shareholder value. Use your preferred search service to search for fiduciary duty myth.
- kazinator 5y agoSuppose a person hired by Google is paid $60 per hour, and can review 20 video comments in that time with a reasonable thoughtfulness. So every human review costs Google $3. The entire revenue of $20B could be blown through on reviewing 6B comments. If you want to keep this activity to 10% of revenue, that caps you to 600M comments. > No it's not And I specifically said the site operators; people hired by Google to moderate are just hired help. They are not equivalent of a dang.
- popcube 5y agoyou trust you just need 20$/one hour, and at outside of USA, it will be cheaper
- ltbarcly3 5y agoSuppose a person is hired by google is paid $1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 per hour and they can review one video every 5000 years. Google is bankrupt in 8 minutes and we are all dead for thousands of years before one video is reviewed and all the economic activity of all of humanity between now and then is not enough to pay the bill for it. GIGO, your numbers are incredibly rediculous.
- kazinator 5y ago
- Epitom3 5y agoop has no problem with karma requirement. They are saying all downvotes and all upvotes should be visible to provide a better picture.