3 ms·
Was ready to jump on this as FUD, but the article does make a few valid observations, even if they don't do enough to justify the sensationalist headline and th
by Apocryphon 5y ago
Was ready to jump on this as FUD, but the article does make a few valid observations, even if they don't do enough to justify the sensationalist headline and thesis.
> Consider whether American culture and society actively demand proper job training and education that facilitates meaningful work. Frankly, it's the opposite: American culture and society are notoriously anti-intellectual and market-oriented. Every institution has profit as its fundamental driver, and education is not above this. When this is coupled with the general social attitude in America that chastises the educated or those interested in obtaining a better education, one cannot help but be pessimistic on whether or not the millions of workers who left their place of work are being sufficiently trained or educated to attain meaningful work.
I think it's a valid social critique that neither U.S. institutions nor its "culture" sufficiently supports widespread retraining of workers seeking to uplevel from less skilled work.
> The sectors hit the hardest by the Great Resignation also consist of the most readily-automatable jobs. There's very little chance in the short-term that many will return to working for service and retail jobs—even with astounding benefit offers, these jobs still aren't being filled. But the demand for these industries is quite high, giving them all the more reason to speed up automating such jobs.
I'm really unsure of how much of these service and retail jobs are easily automatable.
> Unfortunately, institutions are not likely to reorient themselves toward helping Americans find meaningful work. What is more likely is that only a select few already hyper-educated workers will reap the benefits of the Great Resignation.
I think it's certainly true that tech workers on places like Hacker News are more likely to be those "hyper-educated" enough to benefit from the Great Resignation, in contrast to those who would be left behind by it.
> Suppose these jobs are swiftly automated, and anti-intellectualism retains its predominance in American life
The former is a dubious supposition, and the latter is likely to continue but it's more of a broad social critique than anything actionable, sadly.