5 ms·
Condo Association Bans Owners from Parking EVs in the Garage
- hbrav 5y agoI'm confused about the argument regarding the sprinkler system. I can understand water sprinkler being a dangerous combination with a battery fire. But for a gasoline powered car, isn't a fire likely to be a flammable liquid fire, for which water sprinklers are also a dangerous choice?
- busterarm 5y agoSmall amounts of water can spread gas fires but large amounts of water smothers and deprives it of the oxygen needed to react & burn. It's also really hard to get liquid gas on its own to ignite -- it's the vapor that you have to worry about. This is why gas is atomized and combined with oxygen and compressed to burn in your vehicle.
- m-p-3 5y agoHave you ever seen what happens when a chemical fire is sprinkled with water? It's basically the same thing as trying to extinguish a cooking oil fire with a glass of water, you'll make it even worse.
- tssva 5y agoI'm not saying I agree with the condo association but I am confused by the counterpoint the article author tries to make. Their response is regarding the odds of an EV catching fire vs the odds of a ICE catching fire. They even state that if the odds of an ICE catching fire is equal or greater than an EV than ICE's should also be banned. But the associations argument against EVs in the garage isn't based mainly around the odds of them catching fire vs an ICE. The garage has a sprinkler system and is designed to allow fire fighters to bring enough water to bare to put out an ICE fire. EV fires can't be put out with water so the sprinkler system is of no use and the garage doesn't provide the access needed to allow fire fighters to deliver the required volume of chemical fire retardants to extinguish an EV fire.
- Arrath 5y agoOne (redundant and costly) solution might be for building code to require two side-by-side sprinkler systems for garages, one that sprays water and another that sprays chemical fire retardants suitable to fighting battery fires and the like.
- listenallyall 5y ago...and a simple alternative to an expensive fix is to simply ban the cars. I would expect that if fire codes require retrofixes, similar bans will become widespread (and popular).
- Arrath 5y agoCertainly. I was imagining a more forward-looking requirement with grandfather clauses for existing systems. EV's will only become more widespread, fires will naturally be an occasional fact of life, and it seems untenable to ban keeping them in garages forevermore.
- adriancr 5y ago> it seems untenable to ban keeping them in garages forevermore. Concern is if something bad happens it's catastrophic, even if the chance that it happens is slim... So, until buildings are retrofitted to deal with EV fires this proposal seems reasonable. It's going to be interesting when EVs become the majority, but by that point they can be self driving and shared vehicles / always running and doing something.
- busterarm 5y agoYou need not only chemical fire retardants but a fume extraction system. Lithium battery fires are extremely toxic.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoAnd for some reason it wasnt needed for a ICE car fire?
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoCondos and apartment buildings are going to be a significant barrier to widespread ev adoption (esp in metro areas where these are more common). It's 2021, my condo hoa has no plans (even 'someday') to add ev chargers. They don't even have the electrical infrastructure in the garage to allow owners to install chargers at their own expense.
- mint2 5y agoThis is why regulations are sometimes the sole feasible option.
- busterarm 5y agoYou don't want regulation forcing these things into your properties without also some way of containing their fires and their fumes (which are highly toxic).
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoWhy are you more concerned about EV fires when gas fires have been a thing for the past century? We had a parked car go up in flames at work and nobody was calling for the company to ban ice cars.
- busterarm 5y agoParked ICE cars _rarely_ catch fire just sitting parked. When they do it's usually electrical system issues that started a larger fire (I'm looking at you, VW, Audi). Battery fires commonly occur while at rest. More importantly, they can't be put out (and are accelerated) by common indoor sprinkler systems and the toxic fumes will keep you from getting close enough to use a Class D extinguisher anyway. Much unlike ICE cars. Additionally, lithium batteries burn at 1000+ degrees vs gas fires which burn at hundreds and batteries tend to EXPLODE, whereas gas just burns unless the fire starts from inside the pressurized tank (which is virtually impossible).
- nielsbot 5y agoWonder if EVs could come with built-in extinguishers... maybe just for the battery compartment. Would CO2 work? Probably not remotely practical.
- teeray 5y agoWith lithium battery fires, you need to both extinguish the fire and cool the battery. They’re like those trick birthday candles. Water is usually best at both jobs. What would be better is a charger hooked up to a standpipe with orifices in the car to extinguish and cool the batteries.
- busterarm 5y ago> With lithium battery fires, you need to both extinguish the fire and cool the battery. They’re like those trick birthday candles. Water is usually best at both jobs. What would be better is a charger hooked up to a standpipe with orifices in the car to extinguish and cool the batteries. No, this is stupid. Lithium, the main component of this battery chemistry, reacts _intensely_ with water, producing both lithium hydroxide and flammable hydrogen gas. It's an exothermic reaction and lasts longer than sodium in water. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vxqe_ZOwsHs&t=61s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vxqe_ZOwsHs&t=61s
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nielsbot 5y agoParent comment seems to be correct: the key thing to do is lower the temperature. Here's an interesting FAA study I found about it: https://www.fire.tc.faa.gov/pdf/TC-13-53.pdf https://www.fire.tc.faa.gov/pdf/TC-13-53.pdf Also, just googling it returns this, for example "Traditional fire extinguishers, such as foam and water, don’t work on lithium battery fires. The only way to extinguish a lithium battery fire is to flood the battery with water." [https://bridgehill.com/fire-blankets/lithium/ https://bridgehill.com/fire-blankets/lithium/]
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoConsidering that Tesla is moving to LFP batteries which are much safer and less likely to catch fire and I think other auto makers are expected to follow. I would not be surprised if this is a none issue in a year or two. Are there any shipping cars using LFP batteries yet?
- brianwawok 5y agoAFAIK Tesla has no plans to move their high end cars to LFP. It's currently for cars made in China, and would be for the lower end cars, such as a standard range 3/y. X and S have no immediate plans to switch, or they would be at a competitive disadvantage to people like Lucid and Rivian.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoLFP increasing density (200 wh/kg in 2022 according to CATL roadmap, 230 in 2023) is coming, but it's just the short range Model 3 that is feasible with LFP in the current state. All the sexy models (S, X, LR version, CT, etc) will be NMC for at least 2 years I'd guess. The 230 wh/kg LFP cells will probably be better than the 260 wh/kg NMC cells since pack level there's less cooling/safety needed. So if 2023 230 density is achieved, then we can talk. Solid state continues to be a nothingburger. It's strange that the Quantumscape 10 layer demo was such a news dud, which tells me that the major problems of scale and cost are still in prototype.
- redis_mlc 5y agoI lived in an apartment building that had an old ICE car with an electrical problem catch fire at night, then explode. Flames were 20' high. Luckily it was parked under a carport area, so destroyed the carport roof and adjacent laundry building, and not the residential building (just singed.) It took about a year to deak with the insurance adjuster and rebuild.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoThis is standard fare for condo associations. These are almost always chock full of old crotchety rules lawyers that undoubtedly don't want their association dues to increase one red cent just because some whippernsapper dogooder lazy millenial wants this. They are the knowitall Boomer generation! Of course this will fix itself VERY QUICKLY once condo associations realize NOT having sensible charging infrastructure in a parking garage will hurt your condo's resale/property value. Fussing about the association dues is peanuts compared to the new third rail of white politics: your home's property value.
- brianwawok 5y agoIt's why you want to get on the board of your condo. yah more work for no pay sucks, but far better to control your own fate. In many smaller condos, they practically have to beg people to run for office..
- HWR_14 5y agoI mean, alternatively old crotchety people don't care about resale value because they won't have to move to chase a job or follow a partner who needs to move.