2 ms·
Say at some point there wasn't a proper title transfer. Maybe a relative gave it to you or loaned it indefinitely to you and no one thought about the title and
by ghaff 5y ago
Say at some point there wasn't a proper title transfer. Maybe a relative gave it to you or loaned it indefinitely to you and no one thought about the title and the relative passed away. Or some other informal joint ownership. People's names change. Edge cases? Sure. But there are a lot of them and the manufacturer has every incentive to just go "Here's the rules. No exceptions."
- gambiting 5y agoUhm, yeah, I'd absolutely expect an official dealership to refuse to produce a key for a car you cannot prove ownership of, regardless of whether it was loaned to you, inherited, or if you found it in a ditch - no proof of ownership, no key. If you are one of those edge cases, there are tonnes of unofficial garages which will happily make you a new key for money. The manufacturer - and by extension, they official dealerships - should never make keys for anyone but the legal owner.
- ghaff 5y agoI've never owned a car with modern keyless fobs but I've certainly had new spare keys made and I'm sure I've never had to produce a title to do so. Of course in that case I already had a key and I was in their computer system in some manner.
- gambiting 5y agoI think it's a bit different if you turn up with the car and a working key already - in that case making you another key doesn't really change anything about the situation(although I suppose it could still be someone just borrowing a car intending to use the spare to steal it later....). But yeah, I specifically mean a situation where someone doesn't have a key, turns up with the car on a trailer and asks for the key for it - in that case yeah, why would a dealership unlock and provide you with a key for a random car that you can't prove ownership of? That would be just weird.
- ghaff 5y agoYeah. That would be very weird especially if it were a dealership you had no previous dealings with. (I don't actually know how interconnected a manufacturer's dealership network is at the back end.)