4 ms·
So how did this pair get away with it for 5 years? Surely it only takes a single false claim for someone to be able to take it to police as fraud? And it lo
by londons_explore 5y ago
So how did this pair get away with it for 5 years?
Surely it only takes a single false claim for someone to be able to take it to police as fraud? And it looks like these guys must have claimed hundreds of thousands of videos... And yet none of them found a suitable way to get this addressed for four years?
Seems like a pretty open and shut case too... Lots of paper trail...
- pjc50 5y agoThe police basically don't investigate difficult cases or "commercial disputes". You'd have to take Google to court, and who's going to run that risk?
- elliekelly 5y agoEven trying to report identity theft to the police is a massive pain. They’ll try to pawn it off on the police department where the fraudulent transaction occurred and that PD will tell you they don’t have jurisdiction and it’s really the PD where the victim is located who should investigate. Most police departments just don’t have the technical knowledge to look into these things. They send you around in circles, and maybe to an FBI form that goes nowhere, and wait for you to give up.
- danlugo92 5y ago#BitcoinFixesThis
- southerntofu 5y agoThat's what you get when entities get so big and powerful we users don't have a single recourse against them. The ContentID system being a fraud has been well-known in librist circles since whenever it was launched. It's a bit similar to how higher-ups in the police and secret services have run massive drug imports in France/USA for decades and everybody knew about it but it took many years for the competent authorities to react. When your entire society is based on obedience to a higher authority, we all become come to depend on the goodwill (or lack thereof) of that entity. Google is not exactly reputable when it comes to dealing with user complaints, and they have exactly 0 financial incentive to fix this huge problem.
- 123pie123 5y agowill the owners of the videos get any compensation back from the prosection or google? I doubt it
- dd36 5y agoWe need private rights of action against companies that don’t reasonably investigate claims of fraud a la FCRA. These private rights of action should have minimum statutory damages so individuals can find contingent counsel.