3 ms·
> My conclusion is that Risc V is a terrible architecture. Kinda stopped reading here. It's a pretty arrogant hot take. I don't know this guy, maybe he's som
by kelnos 5y ago
> My conclusion is that Risc V is a terrible architecture.
Kinda stopped reading here. It's a pretty arrogant hot take. I don't know this guy, maybe he's some sort of ISA expert. But it strains credulity that after all this time and work put into it, RISC-V is a "terrible architecture".
My expectation here is that RISC-V requires some inefficient instruction sequences in some corners somewhere (and one of these corners happens to be OP's pet use case), but by and large things are fine.
And even then, I don't think that's clear. You're not going to determine performance just by looking at a stream of instructions on modern CPUs. Hell, it's really hard to compare streams of instructions from different ISAs.
- mhh__ 5y agoCalling it terrible is definitely something from the book of Linus T. Bad? Quite possible, it was meant as a teaching ISA initially IIRC, but terrible? Who knows.
- foxfluff 5y agoThat's the difficulty here, people are already arguing past each other because nobody seems to agree what the ISA is for. If you look at the early history of RISC-V, it does indeed look like as something built for teaching. But I don't think that use case warrants all the hype around it. So how did all the hype form, and why is it that there are people seemingly hyping it as the next-gen dream-come-true super elegant open developed-with-hindsight ISA that will eventually displace crufty old x86 and proprietary ARM while offering better performance and better everything? Of course that just baits you into arguing about its potential performance. And don't worry if it doesn't have all the instructions you need for performance yet, we'll just slap it with another extension and it totally won't turn into a clusterfuck with a stench of legacy and numerous attempts at fixing it (coz' remember, hindsight)! And then if you question its potential, you'll get someone else arguing that no no, it's not a high performance ISA for general use in desktops / servers, it's just an extensible ISA that companies can customize for their special sauce microcontrollers or whatever. Of course it's all armchair speculation because there are no high performance real world implementations and there aren't enough experts you can trust.
- astrange 5y ago> Kinda stopped reading here. It's a pretty arrogant hot take. I don't know this guy, maybe he's some sort of ISA expert. But it strains credulity that after all this time and work put into it, RISC-V is a "terrible architecture". Seems quite balanced with all the other replies here which claim it's the best architecture ever whenever anyone says anything about it. I don't think its vector extensions would be good for video codecs because they seem designed around large vectors. (and the article the designers wrote about it was quite insulting to regular SIMD)
- mlyle 5y ago> Seems quite balanced with all the other replies here which claim it's the best architecture ever whenever anyone says anything about it. RISC-V is pretty good. Probably slightly better for some things than ARM, and slightly worse for others. It's open, which is awesome, and the instruction set lends itself to extensions which is nice (but possibly risks the ecosystem fragmenting). Building really high performance RISC-V designs looks like it's going to rely on slightly smarter instruction decoders than we've seen in the past for RISCs, but it doesn't look insurmountable.