3 ms·
It isn't. Closing off certain places isn't done just because those particular places have an increased risk of infection but also to stop people from traveling
by xg15 5y ago
It isn't. Closing off certain places isn't done just because those particular places have an increased risk of infection but also to stop people from traveling to and from those places.
I live in western Germany. Home office mandates in my country were for a large part to stop people from commuting in crowded trains every day, even if their actual workplace might not have had a high infection risk.
I live near a busy shopping street. Back in march 20, there was a blanket order to close everything in that street - cafes, malls, mom&pop shops, etc. The street consequently was deserted for a few months. Later, restrictions got more targeted, with an overall goal to keep untested and unvaccinated persons out. And this may lower the infection risks for individual stores, but I can just observe that the street itself is as busy again as before the pandemic.
- CamperBob2 5y agoSo shut down the trains. If someone is driving to their cabin, there is no reason to stop them. It was always completely irrational to prohibit solitary or family-oriented outdoor activities. They did that around here for a while, in a largely rural state in the US Pacific Northwest region. Senseless "do something!" edicts like that give a lot of rhetorical ammunition to the denialists and antivaxxers, while doing nothing to address the spread of COVID.
- gebruikersnaam 5y agoAnother reason to keep people from traveling is to make sure they stay where there's available healthcare. If everyone traveled to their cabin and got sick, the local hospital wouldn't be able to handle all the cases.
- CamperBob2 5y agoSorry, that's unconvincing at best.
- xg15 5y agoNot anymore, as the virus is already anywhere. But there absolutely was a reason to stop potentially infected from travelling large distances and carry the infection into other regions.
- CamperBob2 5y agoWhere am I more likely to spread the infection? In a crowded city, or in a private cabin in the woods?
- xg15 5y ago> So shut down the trains. Ok, so mandating work from home and closing down public parks is too heavy-handed but shutting down all public transport is fine?
- CamperBob2 5y agoAssuming you're trying to stop the spread of a communicable disease, yes. Do you disagree? COVID spreads poorly outdoors. That was understood well before they reopened the public parks in my area.