6 ms·
People complain about parking requirements but, in most US cities (and indeed in a great deal of the world) most households have cars. If I lived in Seattle, ev
by ghaff 5y ago
People complain about parking requirements but, in most US cities (and indeed in a great deal of the world) most households have cars. If I lived in Seattle, even if I didn't need one day to day for work/errands/etc., I'd certainly own one for going out to the mountains and so forth on the weekends.
- davidw 5y agoSo let the market work. If people don't have a car, they're doing the environment a favor for all of us and clogging the roads less. It's only fair that they should get a discount: not forcing them to pay for automobile storage they're not using!
- mrep 5y agoIsn't that the case already pretty much everywhere land is scarce? When I lived in Seattle, parking was an extra $300 a month on top of rent but I didn't have to pay that when I didn't have a car.
- davidw 5y agoThe norm in post-WWII North America is to mandate specific quantities of parking per land use type. Some places get really detailed about this. Here's a map of places that have eliminated parking mandates in some way: https://parkingreform.org/resources/mandates-map/ https://parkingreform.org/resources/mandates-map/
- mrep 5y agoYes I know. I'm responding to the "not forcing them to pay for automobile storage they're not using". This website says it costs 25-50k to build an underground parking spot [0] which when they can charge $3,600 per year it is totally profitable to build them without any subsidy by the renters not driving. [0]: https://www.dbsg.com/blog/surface-parking-vs-underground-parking/#:~:text=The%20average%20cost%20per%20parking,tied%20into%20the%20structural%20system https://www.dbsg.com/blog/surface-parking-vs-underground-par....
- ghaff 5y agoNot everywhere. Resident parking permits are often cheap. You just need to be eligible. In Cambridge it's $25/year and that's a city with absolutely no surplus of parking spaces.
- mrep 5y agoI should clarify: everywhere land is scarce and the government isn't moronically not charging what they should for street parking. I have an even worse example than yours: my brother and his gf live in lower manhattan and are somehow able to find and park their car completely free on the street somewhat close to them. My jaw dropped when I heard that as I think it is beyond ridiculous.
- notJim 5y agoI think for many people, Zipcar or other car shares would cover their mountain needs. But for those who need one all the time, they can buy or rent a parking spot if street parking doesn't work for them.
- whimsicalism 5y agoWhy should we subsidize a car storage spot?
- KittenInABox 5y agoForgive me, since I don't own a car: Wouldn't it be cheaper to rent a car if you're only going to use it once a week or so? I mean, with the payment itself, plus insurance, plus gas, regular maintenance, is it worth the price?
- ghaff 5y agoIt would probably be cheaper but less convenient. I was in a ski house once with people who lived in Manhattan (carless) and every weekend they came up there was lots of planning and overhead associated with the rental car. Manhattan is obviously extreme but most people who can afford to do sso would rather just have a car they can jump into when they want to.
- milkytron 5y agoI don't have a car either for this exact reason. I could get a car, but the costs are just insane when compared with the alternatives. $8-10k a year in savings is usually what I come out to.
- perl4ever 5y agoDo you find, in general, that buying smaller slices of things from service providers tends to be cheaper?
- ghaff 5y agoIt depends how often you use them. Personally, $8-10K/year seems expensive unless you aren't trying to economize. I have an 11 year old ~$40Kish vehicle that I wouldn't typically pay $1K/year for maintenance and less on insurance. But there is certainly some point at which it makes economic sense to just rent, especially if you are paying to park the car. In a city with difficult parking I wouldn't pay to own a car to use every couple of months. But if you're going to be paying a few thousand dollars for local rentals for trips, plus some Uber, plus deliveries, plus some Zipcar, it starts to become pretty attractive to just own a car if only for the convenience.