5 ms·
It's even worse than that. Because LA is so spread out, merely living in apartment buildings doesn't solve the problem: the apartment-dwellers still need cars
by klyrs 5y ago
It's even worse than that. Because LA is so spread out, merely living in apartment buildings doesn't solve the problem: the apartment-dwellers still need cars to live in LA. When you need 1-3 parking spots for every apartment, the economic efficiency of apartment buildings drops precipitously.
With rose-colored glasses, I can see a path forward; building free-standing parking garages that will eventually be demolished / repurposed when car ownership in a neighborhood goes below a certain level. But that's expensive, clunky, and ugly -- and folks aren't going to want to walk across a wide, busy street just to get to their cars. Probably not politically viable.
- politician 5y agoDream: Build light rail and cluster high density mixed-use housing and commercial around the stops. Reality: LA runs out of water as climate change intensifies in the Rockies.
- ariwilson 5y agoLA will never run out of water; it's not the major water user in CA state and it has a huge body of potentially drinkable water next to it and the cash to use it.
- sydbarrett74 5y agoYep. I'd point to crops like almonds (one of the thirstiest crops imaginable) being grown in the Central Valley. 10% of CA's water goes to this one crop. Unfortunately, farmers are doubling down on this lucrative product while they still can. Whatever happens when most of CA goes dry isn't their concern. I guess they'll retire to Florida.
- politician 5y agoCalifornians will never approve the energy generation projects required to unlock high volume desalination. They'll be drinking water pumped overland from Colorado until the Hoover Dam is dry.
- distances 5y agoRail should have enough stops for continuous high-density housing, I strongly feel that is what makes a city. Trams for connecting routes and subways for the main transit through the city.
- acdha 5y agoYou'd save an order of magnitude more water by cutting back agricultural and landscaping usage. If those apartment buildings are professionally designed, they're likely to be more efficient than random houses with ±30 years age on fixtures. What seems to be working well in LA is building up buses. When I was out last June I noticed buses with dedicated right-of-way (physically separated) and that seemed to be running well during peak times, which is quite eye-opening when you count and realize that the bus which just went by was carrying more people than all of the vehicles in the 4 lanes of stopped traffic.
- clairity 5y agothere’s only one truly dedicated busway here in LA (orange line in the valley). some other buses (like silver line) have sections of busway, but are mostly traveling on shared streets. there’s been a back-and-forth on dedicated bus lanes and some plans for more busways, but there is a lot of misplaced pushback from drivers on this (that it would increase traffic). i do think that buses are a good lower-cost mass transit option, but without the reliability/security that comes with dedicated infrastructure, it will be hard to get more angelenos to rely on the bus for daily use. currently metro is focused on removing fares, but all that will do is lower their budget (modestly) and worsen service, which will be counterproductive to the goal of increasing ridership.
- acdha 5y agoI was out around the G Line, and not for a long trip but it definitely seemed to be working there. The traffic complaints are always amusing because it really shows how people don't want to accept that the current system just doesn't work. I grew up in Ventura and have family around LA, and there have been so many road projects which made traffic better for maybe as much as 6 months until usage increased to match.
- ihaveajob 5y agoSomewhere someone had proposed a new rule that would require all parking structures to be built on level floors, with the idea of allowing a future conversion when the conditions are right. Slanted floors negate this option from the start.
- jessaustin 5y agoThe additional work required to build a level floor over a slanted slab seems minor when compared to the total work involved in converting a garage to e.g. residential use.
- klyrs 5y agoA (pipe-)dream of mine is that parking structures will eventually be taken over by tiny homes...
- alistairSH 5y agoWhen you need 1-3 parking spots for every apartment Part of the problem is parking is heavily subsidized and the real costs not borne by drivers. Free public street-side parking in many urban and semi-urban zones. Parking minimums codified into building codes. Allowances for giant asphalt fields in suburban zones. For a start, in downtown areas (both city and town), remove the parking requirements from building codes and let the market dictate how much parking is needed per apartment, per office, per shop. We currently over-allocate parking.
- beerandt 5y agoDevelopers are typically required to include on street parking in their developments before the right-of-way is deeded over to the public. There's rarely any public subsidies for parking. That's largely a myth. It's paid for in the price of the development by the developer (and is usual a government or zoning requirement).
- bluGill 5y agoThat is still a public subsidy as the city is expected to maintain that on street parking.
- beerandt 5y agoNo- it's part of the consideration in exchange for the developer generating increased tax revenue and dedicating the right of way to the city. If that weren't the case, the developer would likely keep the parking and streets privately held. Which is something that you do see more and more of these days.
- beerandt 5y agoAdditionally, we've decided as a society that providing public access and right-of-way to private property is a somewhat fundamental function of government. Providing streets without places to stop or park would be like building interstates without exits. But the analogy would be if someone built the intestate and exits, and the government subsequently closed your exit. Does it matter if the street, but not the on-street parking, is made public right-of-way? Would it be equally acceptable for the government to repurpose off-street parking or parking garages?
- beerandt 5y agoParking garages cost over $500k per space to build. Probably more in California. No one is building one with as part of a short term plan with the intent to tear it down in less than 30-40+ years.
- clairity 5y agothat cost overstated by an order of magnitude. last i looked, it’s on the order of $30K/space, and roughly doubles/triples for underground parking (depending on depth). i’m a huge advocate for putting all parking underground and leaving ground level space for humans to enjoy fully. it’s more expensive, but we’re a rich city/state/country and we should have nice things.
- beerandt 5y agoOops, Yea- I fat fingered that from $50k. But that's still roughly double/triple or more what street parking will cost (where space efficiency approaches 100% since driveways and additional access pavement aren't needed). Correct on double to triple for underground, but likely more for buildings with compact or less than ideal footprints (inefficient layout and access) and where structural and utility considerations need to be made for the building overhead. But commercial grade (concrete/lanscaped) surface parking can easily cost $30k+/space, even in non-urban areas. A recent multi-acre university parking lot we did was just shy of $50k/ space (which is why parking garages start making economic sense around that price point), and that was in a 5 digit population college town on the outskirts of campus. But the point remains that structural parking costs > surface parking costs >> street parking. And that street parking shouldn't be thought of as subsidized[1], because as soon as it is considered free lunch for other pet purposes, developers won't relinquish control of it, and will potentially set buildings back an additional 8-25' (parallel-angled, per side of the street) to stay outside of minimum right-of-way widths. [1] In addition to the fact that the dedication and assumption of future maintenance costs is in contractual consideration of the value of the land and improvements dedicated, additional generated tax revenue and economic growth, and is typically required by govt building codes.
- 5y ago