4 ms·
> I think that for extremely small perturbations the discrepancy will be linear until it reaches a critical threshold An error of epsilon on the angle of a pat
by pfdietz 5y ago
> I think that for extremely small perturbations the discrepancy will be linear until it reaches a critical threshold
An error of epsilon on the angle of a path toward the scatter will cause an error of ~(distance to scatter/size of scatter) epsilon in the angle from the center of the scatterer to the "impact point". So the errors should grow exponentially in the number of scatterings.
The (effective) curvature of the scatterer CANNOT be neglected -- it is crucial. Modeling this with large flat reflectors is not appropriate.
- antognini 5y agoI spent a bit more time thinking about this, and yes you are correct. Each scattering event increases the discrepancy by ~mean free path / atomic radius, which is about five orders of magnitude. So even starting from a 10^-78 discrepancy, it only takes ~10 collisions to get an order unity discrepancy. I was thinking that the discrepancy due to collisions was negligible compared to the accumulated tidal acceleration, but this is clearly wrong.
- r_parthasarathy 5y agoI'm glad this makes sense; thanks for writing!
- pfdietz 5y agoAbout three orders of magnitude, not five, but yeah.