7 ms·
The Church of the Clocked Screws (2019)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jeffwass 5y agoIn some cases it’s difficult to clock the screw, as clocking it would leave it over or under torqued.
- upheaval7276 5y agoLast 3 paragraphs cover that specifically.
- klyrs 5y agoIf you're screwing into a tapped hole, yeah.
- mhb 5y agoObviously, that's what the shims are for.
- samwillis 5y agoThis is one of those disappearing details due to innovation. So few people now use flat head screws, it seems the technically “superior” Phillips and Pozidrive that taken over in all joinery now. As an aside everyone should know the difference between a Phillips and Pozidrive. It should be required teaching in schools to maintain everyone sanity. Pozidrive screws have a small engraved diagonal cross on the head, the driver has an extra ridge in the cross groove. Use the wrong screwdriver in the wrong screw and you will have a horrible time and wreck the screw head. I have my grandfathers flat head screwdrivers and love them. Long shafts to help with alignment and prevent riding out. Lovely big wooden handles to help with torque.
- progre 5y agoIs this specific to woodworking? For general use everyting is Torx where I live. Clearly superior if you have decent bits (throw away those that come with the box of screws, they seem to be made of mud and sawdust).
- samwillis 5y agoMy experience in the UK. Seeing more and more Torx though. Much prefer it to Pozidrive! Torx really should be used with an electrical screwdriver with a clutch though or you risk snapping the screws if you over tighten. Philips and Pozidrive are designs to ride out before snapping the screw head off.
- GuB-42 5y agoIn France it is mostly Pozidriv, electronics and small appliances are usually Philips, Ikea is hex, we still see slotted screws but they are a dying breed, Torx is getting more and more popular. Still, when you go to your local hardware store, the kind of cheap screws that are sold in bulk are usually Pozidriv. Torx screws are also available but usually in more expensive, branded, retail packaging.
- Xerneos 5y agoTorx seems to be the superior head to me as well. The rest of the country (big chain hardware stores) seem to be still stuck with mostly Philips and Pozidrive.
- fho 5y agoAt least for machine screws I buy Torx is easily twice the price of regular socket head screws: [100 'old-school' M3x5 screws](https://www.screwsandmore.de/de/sortiment/schrauben-und-bolzen/innensechskant-schrauben/zylinderkopf-din-912/din-912-edelstahl-a2/din-912-a2-m3/din-912-a2-m3x5/1207/100-stueck-zylinderkopfschrauben-din-912-a2-m3x5?c=39970 https://www.screwsandmore.de/de/sortiment/schrauben-und-bolz...) [50 Torx M3x5 screws](https://www.screwsandmore.de/de/sortiment/schrauben-und-bolzen/torxschrauben/zylinderkopf-iso-14579/iso-14579-a2-tx10-m3/iso-14579-a2-m3x5/2981/50-stueck-zylinderkopfschrauben-iso-14579-a2-m3x5?c=20722 https://www.screwsandmore.de/de/sortiment/schrauben-und-bolz...)
- CapitalistCartr 5y agoBy the way, this applies to electrical plates, too. Vertical is the one true path.
- avs733 5y agoMy first job ever was doing new home wiring…learned a lot that has affected the way I approach engineering. The company standard was that all plate screws were left vertical, no exception. The master electrician and managers absolutely checked. I’ve long appreciated that level of attention to detail and now it drives my wife nuts when she puts a plate in something and I go back and tweak it. Meanwhile they let 14 year old me drive around between job sites to deliver pets but that’s another story :).
- ineedasername 5y agoZoom in on the photo. Lots of the screws are not perfect clocked. Some are pretty far off. Even using the author's method, the screw just isn't going to catch at the same point in the wood every time, so I think that a little margin on torque, or allowing for less-than-perfect, is required.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoI’d rather someone screw the screws in to the perfect amount of tension for the job than worry about making all the screw heads line up and also waste time doing that. So I found the whole article a little exasperating. I guess there is something in there about form vs. function and how people see the world.
- exDM69 5y agoIt's wood and mid-20th century slot head screws. A quarter a turn too tight or loose is fine and there's no such thing as perfect in anything made of wood anyway. The tradition of clocking screws may be a bit silly but it is a mark of attention to detail. It is something you see in bespoke heirloom furniture and it serves no practical value.
- ineedasername 5y agoSomething like this which signals "attention to detail" but doesn't actually improve quality or stability isn't something I really care about. It's easy to be sloppy while putting the image of attention to detail in by non-functional surface appearance like clocked screws. If I'm looking for signs of quality then I want to see attention to detail where it matters, not for its own sake. That said, I can appreciate the aesthetic appeal even if it's non functional.
- mauvehaus 5y agoThey are the brown M&M's of the furniture world. Seeing haphazardly driven screws is an indicator that perhaps you should take a close look at everything else, because the builder may not have. Getting them pretty darned close doesn't require any extraordinary measures, and they're being driven into wood anyway. It's not like you're putting them in with a torque wrench according to some chart of screw size and material and wood species. Just don't over-torque brass screws to clock them. That's a sure fire way to break the head off.
- rob74 5y agoActually, with that much attention to detail, maybe for a church they should have used Phillips screws - also "clocked" of course. Little crosses everywhere...
- jedimastert 5y agoI know you're probably joking, but I looked it up and apparently the Philips drive was only just starting to be circulated to screw manufacturers when the church was built. TIL!
- h2odragon 5y agoSee also "Indexed Spark Plugs" A few actual commercial production cars have tolerances tight enough to use that trick, and are dealership darlings because of that. At least those are documented. Engine tweakers who build that tight often regret it.
- mikestew 5y agoI've heard that for years; but has anyone actually, you know, tested this on a dyno? A brief web search just turned up ad-laden pages talking about it, with no evidence that it actually works. My argument against is that by the time the spark plug fires, the intake valve has long since closed, and the air/fuel mixture has been swirling around and can reach that spark just fine, whether the electrode is "blocking" it or not. Not that it matters, but ex-mechanic here, so I do have some idea how an ICE works.
- h2odragon 5y agoIve got two actual personal encounters with them. Long ago someone who talked up his souped up motorcycle/gokart engine (with reason) explained it to me, shortly before that engine died wide and energetic. That was fun, and may have had other causes :) Then my wife paid $1,800 for a "packs & plugs" job at a dealership, when our usual guy was aware that our Honda Insight had that issue and needed that attention and said he'd have charged $200 for it. Individual part numbers for 3 plugs. But still. She was out of town and they talked her into "it's sputtering but it could blow up at any moment!"
- dw-im-here 5y agoWhat if it's on the other side of the equator, do you have to screw it counterclock-wise?
- sly010 5y agoOr just use hex head or torx head screws. It both works better and has 6x more chance that it will look perfect when torqued.
- ptha 5y agoA little perspective from the other side, why screws aren't aligned in watchmaking: Is it possible to machine a screw, tap the threads, and control the depth of the countersink so as to produce perfectly aligned slots? It is, and it's been done, but it is also apparently a royal PITA, to indulge in some colorful vernacular. In poking around trying to find out if it's ever been done, and how you do it, I ran across the discussion forum at the Practical Machinist, where several different techniques are mentioned. You do find aligned screws in manufactured objects occasionally – Parker-brand shotguns are one example – but the various methods are extremely labor-intensive https://www.hodinkee.com/articles/why-screw-slots-arent-aligned-in-watchmaking https://www.hodinkee.com/articles/why-screw-slots-arent-alig...
- GuB-42 5y agoThat's exactly the kind of thing I would expect on luxury watches. Let's get real, fancy mechanical watches are worse at timekeeping than cheap quartz watches. Their only purpose besides just being expensive is to show the incredible craftsmanship of the watchmaker. That aligning screws is so difficult should add to the value, I'd expect fancy watch people to say "this $10k watch doesn't have aligned screws, but that $100k one does", as an argument to justify the price difference. And I would totally get it.
- throw0101a 5y agoKrishnadev Calamur, writing for The Atlantic as part of their series on the Apollo 11 anniversary a few years ago: > In other words, the Speedmaster and [mechanical] watches like it provide a sense of permanence in an age with little of it. The Speedmaster available today is virtually the same as the one Aldrin wore on the moon, or indeed the one Omega introduced way back in 1957, as a tool for race-car drivers. > It is unchanged because there’s nothing to change: The mechanical watch is, along with the bicycle, an arguably perfect invention. If wound every day and serviced regularly, it can run for perpetuity. There aren’t many things you can say that about in our era of fast fashion and biennial phone upgrades. * https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/07/omega-speedmaster-watch-went-moon/594052/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2019/07/omega-sp...
- cesaref 5y agoWe have a 100 year old grand piano, and our piano tech commented that the lid had previously been removed. He knew this because on this brand of piano, the screws would have been aligned horizontally when they left the factory, and the ones on our piano on this one hinge weren't. Once he'd pointed it out, it was obvious to see, and every other screw on the piano is horizontal.
- btbuildem 5y ago> One of the women on our tour gasped when this was pointed out. “How,” she asked, “did they do this?” They, uh.. paid attention to their work.
- helpm33 5y agoI always clock screws in the electrical wall plates, for a vertical slot.
- buescher 5y agoIt applies to hand assembling electronics with through-hole resistors, also. Install them so the color code reads left-to-right in the most usual orientation of the board. Yes, it does not matter electrically which way you install them, but it makes it easier to read off values. Yes, I thought my boss from years ago who insisted I do it that way was crazy. Once you learn to notice it, though, resistors installed in inconsistent directions will bother you.