4 ms·
"... (no add trolls please, it's just an example)." What is an ad troll. Is it like someone who believes advertising revenue "makes our modern world spin".^1
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
"... (no add trolls please, it's just an example)."
What is an ad troll.
Is it like someone who believes advertising revenue "makes our modern world spin".^1
1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29186326 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29186326
That is interesting because advertising spend is probably one of the least certain investments. It's causal effectiveness online is difficult if not impossible to measure. It is like suggesting casino receipts are what make the modern world spin.
Adtech is, IMO, not a "major path to innovation". Unless one adopts a very narrow view of what innovation looks like.
It is wonderful to hear someone claim "I want to do X, but I have to do Y to feed my family", where X is "something important to the world" and Y is not.
However, if doing Y is diverting attention away from X, or possibly even causing harm, then maybe "not doing Y" is also "something important to the world".
No doubt people working for companies who were selling massive quantities of opioids were feeding their families, and arguably they were not violating any laws. Unfortunately, these criteria were not by themselves enough to stop them from doing harm.
- ok_dad 5y agoI'm lucky that I can work in an "X" category job still, even if I can't do what I described above. I wouldn't be so harsh on those in "Y" category jobs, though, because I imagine the vast majority of folks are doing that, and maybe only a handful are truly in the "opioid pushing" equivalent jobs.
- zelphirkalt 5y ago> [...] It is like suggesting casino receipts are what make the modern world spin. One thing is for sure: Some people inside the casino do make parts of our world actually spin.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoSome say love makes the world go round. I tend to be skeptical when someone says they are "sure" but offers no evidence to support their claim..
- zelphirkalt 5y agoNot sure, whether you got the joke. Or am I not getting a follow up joke?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoNow I got it. :) Nice one.
- generalizations 5y ago> However, if doing Y is diverting attention away from X, or possibly even causing harm, then maybe "not doing Y" is also "something important to the world". I think this kind of analysis discounts the importance of family. Maybe, "not doing Y" is less important than "keeping my family fed".
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"I think this discounts the importance of family." Which family. (a) The family of the person doing Y or (b) the families of the persons who fail to ever see the benefit of X or, worse, who suffer harm from Y. If the answer is (b), then not doing Y benefits the most families. Choice (b) fits better with the idea of "doing something important to the world", especially if one agrees that what he is doing now is preventing him from doing not something that is important to the world. You want to discount the importance of not doing Y/doing X. The "keeping my family fed is more important than [something important ot the world]" argument is just not very convincing. Because the question is not all-or-nothing. It is not either-or question. It is possible to keep a family fed without working on adtech. And if no one was in fact keeping their family fed while working on more important things, then it stands to reason the world would be even worse off as a result.
- generalizations 5y ago> Which family. (a) The family of the person doing Y or (b) the families of the persons who fail to ever see the benefit of X or, worse, who suffer harm from Y. If the answer is (b), then not doing Y benefits the most families. Choice (b) fits better with the idea of "doing something important to the world", especially if one agrees that what he is doing now is preventing him from doing not something that is important to the world. This is how you get neglected kids with parental issues. I've seen it happen. If you're going to have kids, they need to know that they are your first priority, and they need to be treated that way. > You want to discount the importance of not doing Y/doing X. Nope. I just want to make the point that however important X is, or not doing Y is, the hierarchy should be family > ( X | !Y). > It is not either-or question. It is possible to keep a family fed without working on adtech. If you're lucky. But you're sidestepping my point, which is that if you have a choice between not working on adtech and feeding the family, feed your family.