12 ms·
The lost world of physicality
- jgrahamc 15y agoAh, I see this is getting some love from the HN crowd. Very interested to hear people's opinions and very, very interested in original research that covers any of the topics mentioned.
- wladimir 15y agoYou might also be interested in Nicholas Carr's blog, he writes about similar things. I think it is worth following it, if only as a contrast to the tech-utopianism of HN: http://www.roughtype.com/index.php http://www.roughtype.com/index.php
- revorad 15y agoTo me, Carr mostly comes across as trolling.
- wladimir 15y agoIt's not just baseless ranting (well, not all the time), as he does provide arguments. But he's very contrarian in this day and age. His views sometimes border on Luddism :-) But there is some truth in it. In a way, in our quest for efficiency, comfort and safety, we are losing touch with nature, and even with the physical world. I feel that as we become more dependent on technology we become more like domesticated pets of "the machine".
- revorad 15y agoI didn't want to call him a Luddite, as that seems rude, but I'd have to agree with you. Of course there is some truth in saying that technology has some unwanted effects on our lives. But, the question is what alternatives or solutions does he propose, if any? You can improve the world by solving problems for a lot of people or you can improve it by writing books about problems which new solutions may or may not create. I think Carr has chosen the less useful option, if he is indeed trying to improve the world and not just trolling.
- _delirium 15y agoThere is quite a bit of room for interesting middle ground, I think. A lot of the public debate currently is framed more or less between the "very optimistic" and "very pessimistic" poles represented, respectively, by Clay Shirky's Cognitive Surplus: Creativity and Generosity in a Connected Age, and Nicholas Carr's The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains. They make for a nice pair of dueling books, but I'd rather read something with a bit more detailed analysis about the good and bad parts of a networked age, and in particular what meaningful choices we can make that are more fine-grained than "embrace technology" or "reject technology".
- revorad 15y agoAgreed. The middle ground is where we have to deal with real data instead of justifying our preconceived notions. I think that is what the OP is trying to do with his post - a call for existing studies and data.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- wladimir 15y agoSometimes describing a problem can be useful, even if you don't have a solution ready. But that's only the first step... He's not a luddite; I think the alternative that he poses is to be more suspicious of technology and the companies that push it, judge its merits and disadvantages on a case-by-case basis. Not to entirely reject it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mcphilip 15y agoNice post. Obliquely related, but you may enjoy the PBS Frontline episode Digital Nation -- you can watch it online through the PBS website: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/digitalnation/view/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/digitalnation/view/
- revorad 15y agoSome quick reactions: To have a fair discussion, you would have to look at both the problems and benefits of losing physicality. There is a danger of clinging on it to it purely for nostalgia, which I think is largely the case with books. My hunch is that kids' imagination will actually expand with virtual worlds. Another advantage is they will be better educated. Like my wife says, "I wish I had Google when I was a child. I wouldn't have to believe all the lies my parents told me to shut me up." I'm not even sure we will net lose physicality. We will probably just have new types of physical objects.
- pagejim 15y agoIt would be interesting to know what kind of behavioral changes have been seen on a mass scale in countries where computers etc are an inseparable part of life and countries where you would have to be affluent to afford a comupter ... I think that could point out some of the differences that are there ..
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoRationalization? Its very much a part of our physical development to interact with the world. Also emotional formation like empathy depends upon experiencing physically the results of your actions. Things we lose by losing physicality: Reading, hearing stories read to you. Interacting with others over the media you view. Spending time in a single environment stimulates imagination, sensory acuity Respect for the physical world - it hurts to wreck your car, shoot a man, insult someone face-to-face The lies your parents told you (mine anyway) were designed to simplify the world for a 5-year-old. This is necessary. They are moldable, easily confused and frightened. Let the world occur to them in easy stages, not as a fire-hose of internet weirdness. Ultimately I fear a world of socially-inept fat autistic young adults. The cure? Go fishing. Barefoot if possible.
- scrrr 15y agoNot sure what the paragraph about talking to children has to do with the rest. But I've been seated next to children that traveled alone before so perhaps it's just your perception? Often if we feel uncomfortable with something, we make others uncomfortable, too.
- jgrahamc 15y agoNo, I was referring to this: http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2010/06/british_airways_seating_policy http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2010/06/british_airw... (see also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airline_sex_discrimination_policy_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airline_sex_discrimination_poli...) The point of the children paragraph is that many things are leading people to keep children indoors (fear of men, fear of the Sun) and this combined with a virtual world means that they are more and more cut off. At least, that's the hypothesis. Looking for data.
- narag 15y agoIt sounds a lot like Asimov's novels. In Caves of Steel humanity lives under domes and feels unconfortable outside them. In Naked Sun humans inhabiting another planet have become totally reclusive and never contact others in person, but using holographic teleconference.
- estel 15y agoWhilst I don't disagree that there is a widespread culture of fear in many communities, I'm not convinced that this has manifested in a significant trend of parents not allowing children to play outside. Do you have any data for this?
- usedtolurk 15y agoMy parents were always worried that I "spent too much time on the computer", but it was always balanced by weekend outdoor pursuits in mountains and rivers. Both did me a lot of good. I don't want my children to live in a "risk-free" society with all the restrictions that it would imply. We live in semi-wild country on the outskirts of a large flat city with lots of manicured lawns and pavements. When children visit from the inner suburbs they trip over a lot because they are not used to running on uneven ground. I think it's a great pity.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mootothemax 15y agoReal worlds are filled with dirt, hazards, sensation, pleasure, effort and more. The virtual world is clean, colourful, free of danger and effortless. Heh, and then come along malware authors, spammers and scammers. I doubt virtual worlds will be entire free of danger; just as it's possible to break a leg through stupidity, I imagine it'll still be just as easy to delete C:\Windows ;)
- khill 15y agoYou are correct in saying that the virtual world is not free from hazards. However, the difference is in feedback and evolutionary development. In the real world, you feel the snakebite or the hot stove burner. When approached by a stranger or walking through an unknown neighborhood, thousands of years of predator-prey evolution gives you the feeling that something is wrong and you should flee. We haven't evolved these levels of intuition for the virtual world. I can open a harmless looking email and infect my home network with a virus and never know it happened. I can't reliably tell if the person I'm chatting with is a predator or a friend.
- freakwit 15y agoAnd here the physical world comes to the rescue - get yourself a new computer when your old one is infested with malware!
- wladimir 15y agoYes, the virtual world is in no way safer, cleaner than the real world. And certainly not always more colorful. It's a bit of a misconception based on the fairytale told by marketing departments of tech companies, which try to push their happy-go-lucky walled-garden virtual worlds.
- icebraining 15y agoThere was someone in a talk or podcast (damn, when can we get search engines for our memories?) who discussed the idea of creating physical tokens as representations of virtual objects or events. With the arrival of cheap 3D printers, there is now the possibility of making personalized tokens. As for offered books, I think hardcovers will become the tokens; for example, for Cory Doctorow's With a Little Help (which I've never read), the hardcover edition comes with an SD card with the ebook and even a audiobook. And the reality is that at least for me, only one in ten books or so actually have any meaning besides the content; most are just books I bought for myself for no special occasion, and I don't really benefit from the space they take.
- Hyena 15y agoI have the opposite experience: freed from absolute reliance on physical objects, my experience and enjoyment of them have multiplied. I find myself carefully selecting the objects I share space with and I have more time to wander public space because I'm not tethered to a single location.
- shubble 15y agoSo you've been doing the minimalist living thing? Do you find yourself spending more or less time in the virtual world, having made the physical one a little less comfortable? Also, as an aside, how do you deal with the expectations of the opposite gender?
- jsvaughan 15y agoWell, my 3 and 1 year old also have playdoh and lego, and love playing outside. And can also play Angry Birds. If the physical world is being 'lost' then an alternative cause (in the UK at least) might be the amount of it available per person because of increased densities of living. Wolfram Alpha shows: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=uk+population+density http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=uk+population+density 2011 - 663 people per square mile 1911 - 425 people per square mile
- arethuza 15y agoOne thing to note is that access to "wild" land in the UK is generally a lot easier today than it would have been in 1911. The high level population density in the UK is pretty misleading because quite significant chunks of the country are fairly lightly populated - making us all cram into what parts are left (e.g. the Central Belt of Scotland).
- hessenwolf 15y agoWouldn't that mean the population density is underestimated?
- swombat 15y agoIt does, but it means it's also a misleading statistic within the context of this argument, because the high population density (600 people per square mile) would indicate that you can't ever walk 50 meters in one direction without bumping into someone. In fact, you can easily walk miles without meeting anyone - if you go into the countryside. On the other hand, you won't be able to walk anywhere near 50 metres without bumping into someone in a town centre.
- arethuza 15y agoI think my record, at least so far, is walking for four days in the Highlands in winter without meeting anyone. Not bad for an island that people generally consider as rather densely populated.
- RyanMcGreal 15y ago> The virtual world is clean, colourful, free of danger and effortless. Actually, the virtual world is highly dangerous: the life-long risks of sedentary inactivity are well understood. From a risk management perspective, I'll take the dangers of the real world any day.
- rsaarelm 15y agoOn the Kindle every book is Twilight. What does this even mean? Text is already digital (made solely from a discrete alphabet), all about setting up a completely artificial virtual reality of sorts, and not fundamentally tied to any specific physical medium. Strangely, I nevertheless don't see many of these types of essays condemning novels on the same breath as social networking and video games.
- pointyhat 15y agoI think it means that everything is mediocre crap. (bar 1984 which goes missing).
- bricestacey 15y agoI wonder if anyone making that claim actually owns a Kindle. After buying a Kindle, I am reading a lot of older texts that are out of copyright and are far superior to most of today's crap.
- ristretto 15y agoActually the difference is not that big. It's all in our brain anyway, and most virtual experiences evoke similar brain responses as real ones (theater, TV, cinema, mirror neurons etc). What virtual items lose is fine properties like touch, smell, permanence etc. I think the bigger problem is both city planning and immobile technology: most of us are forced to live packed away from the nature in cities planned for the long-gone industrial era, and until recently we were forced to sit in front of our heavy information devices. I believe the mobile revolution is going to bring back a lot of those "physical" elements that we are missing now. It's not the first time societies face transfomations. We already eat virtual food, i certainly don't remember slaughtering that many chicken, pigs and cows lately, and i 've only milked a goat once or twice in my life.
- suprasanna 15y agoYou bring up some good points with the parallels in the brain however I think more is lost in the exposure to different experiences that you simply can't replicate online. For most, it'll be difficult to differentiate between things (physical books, library visits, spending time outdoors, etc) that we don't want to leave behind for nostalgic reasons and things that we shouldn't leave behind because they help us with maturity, growth, etc. I'm wondering what people's thoughts are on this. Technological change is a part of society, yes, but is it always best for the individual?
- Hisoka 15y agoA side effect of losing touch with the physical world is that it wrecks your brain. You begin to feel isolated from the rest of the world. What doesn't help is the growth of cities, and overpopulation. We start to view other people as competitors and enemies. Have you ever gone through some days when you encounter many people, whether it's in a commute, or whatever and ask why people are so useless in your life? What does he/she matter in your life? Life has become so impersonal, and it's not our fault. But I think we have to do something about it, as individuals (not as collective). In the past, we had tribes. Small communities where everyone felt a sense of belonging. Why? Because everyone was important to the success of the whole. You could save the world, because the world was not 1 million people. Everyone mattered to each other, and everyone had stake in each other's lives. The world has become something like this: We RUSH and STRESS to go to places for 40 hours we hate, to work on stuff we don't like, with people we don't care about.
- paulnelligan 15y agoI don't think that being a member of a tribe enabled anyone to save the world, just their village and their families. I would argue that the internet has empowered far more people than ever. I get the Author's point, however I think he's overexaggerating by a long shot. Kids still play with lego, adults still buy books, and certainly do still have real sex with actual people - in fact they can't get enough of it!
- Hisoka 15y agoIn a tribe, the tribe is your world (it's all you know and exposed to). Today the world is a billion people. We're surrounded by people we don't care about. We can't be compassionate to everyone. So it all ends up being impersonal
- anamax 15y ago> We start to view other people as competitors and enemies. Hold that thought. > In the past, we had tribes. And different tribes were enemies and competitors. And, if you don't think that there's competition in a tribe of humans, you're claiming that groups of humans are different from every other group of animals. (Simple example - even in tribes, 40% of males don't have genetic children while only 20% of females are dead ends. That's not all boys dying before breeding age.)
- joshklein 15y agoThe OP would do well to read "Walden" by Henry David Thoreau or, perhaps more pointedly, read up on the teachings of Epicurus[1]. And, more generally, I highly recommend "The Pleasures and Sorrows of Work" by Alain De Botton. And then there's the defining entry from 1960's philosophy, "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" by Persig, which is precisely about the intersection between nature and technology. These concerns with modernity go pretty far back in our history, and some very smart people have come up with workable solutions you can adopt as an individual without needing to go change society. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epicurus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epicurus
- sheeps 15y agoAnother relevant one is E.M. Forster's "The Machine Stops": http://archive.ncsa.illinois.edu/prajlich/forster.html http://archive.ncsa.illinois.edu/prajlich/forster.html
- jgrahamc 15y agoThank you both for these suggestions. I recall reading E. M. Forster's story at school and my contribution to English class was that he was wrong about there being a separate button for everything: in reality things would have been multiplexed and the person would have used a keypad or similar :-) I have not read Walden. Will put it on my Kindle.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- colanderman 15y ago> I have not read Walden. Will put it on my Kindle. I recently did the same, and my fiancée won't let me live down the irony.
- Tichy 15y agoUpvoted for using a Kindle
- 15y ago
- BenSS 15y agoI have to balance my long sessions of hacking and screen time with something physical. Gym, home projects, or something that's making my body work too. I know others have experienced the same thing, with different solutions. Loving the virtual and code isn't a problem, as long as there's an offline component to balance things.
- cmurdock 15y agoThis struck a chord with me. I tend follow up long days at work with lifting sessions in the gym. Helps me get a grip on the world outside the computer sometimes.
- lukev 15y agoThe trend away from physicality began long before the internet. In fact, the ability to spend mental energy and effort on non-physical things is quite possibly one of the defining features of humanity itself. Stories, religion, relationships, philosophy, basic societal concepts such as "ownership" or "justice"... all of these are abstractions from physicality. The invention of writing allowed us to make these abstractions even more elaborate, as did the rise of the intellectual class and the invention of printing. Electronic media is merely the next step on this same journey - it allows us to manipulate and record even more abstract ideas, and communicate them more effectively. In my humble opinion, although physicality and its accompanying physical experiences are certainly pleasant and integral to the experience of being alive, the ability to form, manipulate and care about non-physical abstractions is one of humanity's most noble defining features, and nothing to be afraid or ashamed of.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- TheSOB88 15y agoWe are physical beings, and our physical selves are wasting away the more we neglect them in favor of the electronic world. Sigh... We were not meant to sit around and play video games all day. Our brains and bodies just don't respond effectively to it. It's not healthy.
- lukev 15y agoWe are physical beings, but we are not just physical beings. Playing video games may well be a waste of time, but it's not because they're not physical. All the accomplishments which I admire most are informational or abstract in nature, not physical.
- lukev 15y agoWe are physical beings, but we are not just physical beings. Playing video games may well be a waste of time, but it's not because they're not physical. All the accomplishments which I admire most are informational or abstract in nature, not physical.
- ctdonath 15y ago"On the Kindle every book is Twilight." Struck me in church, standing there reading the Bible from an iPad, that the value of sacred texts may fade or alter, being indistinguishable from any other momentary array of pixels upon a slim universal reader. Being naturally physcial-focused, my toddler children may come to not grasp the "specialness" of some books - where I want them to learn value beyond bits and pixels.
- lukev 15y agoBut the specialness of any book is precisely related to its contents, not its physical manifestation. The Bible is thousands of years old, and yet even the oldest physical copies begin to crumble after a few hundred years. Teaching a reverence for physical objects is in a very real sense untruthful... the ideas they contain are what should (or ought) to matter.
- ctdonath 15y agoIt's not the reverence for physical objects I'm getting at. It's that digital content is ethereal, easily lost amid the terabytes ... while physical books bring a substantial reality to the content. Ideas can be lost in the deluge of limitless content; physical manifestation thereof requires choosing and limiting which content will persist. I think nothing of adding hundreds or thousands of books to my digital reader, and think nothing of forgetting any of them therein. I select and prune with care which ideas and content will fill the limited capacity of my hard-earned hand-made physical bookcase, keeping only the greatest ideas and making that concentration of what matters accessible to the young minds who are growing to peruse them.
- ilkandi 15y agoI totally disagree. The immediate "specialness" of the hot coffeeshop barista is not her "spiritual manifestation". Part of the uniqueness is presentation. Size, shape, weight, age, smell...I'm talking about books... the roughness of the pages etc. Bookreaders reduce this to a lowest common denominator that limits sensory bandwidth and cheapens the experience. Can a person have the same religious fervor with an ephemeral Bible/Koran etc on a Kindle, as they would for a leather bound, gold-edged King James Version with the red tassel bookmark? And the cutout pages that let you thumb to the right chapter? These things should only be tools because in the end we're all animals. And, trying to virtualize everything limits us to half of our birthright.
- wnight 15y agoSheesh, what do people have against ebooks? And where do they all get the same fetish for fondling paper? You can't grep dead trees. Books just aren't as effective. You also can't store tens of thousands of paper books on a tiny USB stick.
- colanderman 15y agoYou also can't build redstone computers out of Lego bricks. Capability wasn't the author's point.
- CountHackulus 15y agoYou can certainly build a computer out of legos. Or at least a Difference Engine, and what really is a better introduction to computability than making your own calculator? http://acarol.woz.org/difference_engine.html http://acarol.woz.org/difference_engine.html
- wnight 15y agoBut capability is the point of books. If you want a work of art buy a sculpture/etc. There's a huge undercurrent of people who romanticize books, I was asking where/why they came from.
- colanderman 15y agoThe author answers your question in the article: "In the real world the physical book has a meaning of its own: it's the book your wife gave you as an anniversary present, it's the book your late father got part way through and you dare not remove the bookmark he left in place, it's the children's book read and read until the pages are torn and worn. These physical remnants augment the book with personal meaning."
- wnight 15y agoSure. You'd likely have as many sentimental books as you'd have sentimental tie-clips, rings, photos, favorite songs, etc. But why do some people romanticize nearly all books?
- mixmax 15y agoSome six years ago I bought a boat that I now live on. This means that I'm in daily contact with other people around the harbour that also live on boats. These people are outside a lot, get a lot of exercise (if you've ever owned a boat you'll know how much physical work must be endured to keep it ship-shape), and generally don't sit much behind copmuterscreens. I've noticed that there are quite a few people that live on boats that are 70+ years old. One of my neighbours, age 69, has just come back from a 2 year solotrip from Denmark to the mediterranean and back. He sailed alone. These people are much more fit than the average 30 year old, and they're having a blast while most other people their age are sitting in a nursinghome. Anecdotally it seems like a lot of this can be traced back to the hands-on hard outdoor life that keeps you in shape all year round. So I'd say that getting out is much more important than people think. Especially if you're getting older.
- giardini 15y agoBut such anecdotal observations are often subject to "survivorship bias": you see only those who have survived and not the 30-to-70 year olds who tried and died: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- horseshoes 15y agoOn the Kindle every book is Twilight. Supposedly you can read pdf's and HTML on a Kindle so in a roundabout way you can read Hugo, Coetzee, Kernighan, &c with extra effort for success in that area. I don't have a Kindle I'm just telling you what I looked up on amazon. http://askville.amazon.com/read-PDF-files-Amazon-Kindle/AnswerViewer.do?requestId=12972464 http://askville.amazon.com/read-PDF-files-Amazon-Kindle/Answ... Machines don't decompose or smell the same way books do but they acquire knicks and marks and eventually disintegrate in one way or another. My first laptop had a small field of worn-out coating on the case from where I rested my palm and thinking of it makes me smile a lil. This won't be a relevant point when data someday somehow no longer need a solid physical form but when that time comes we will find other things to be cool about them. Sex: what happens when pornography becomes the default means of getting sexual pleasure. Hopefully less syphillis less prostitution and less pretending to like someone so I can j my hilariously tiny w. Also, there have been pornos ever since computers were just the antikythera mechanism and we're here today so I think people still got laid. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erotic_art_in_Pompeii_and_Herculaneum http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erotic_art_in_Pompeii_and_Hercu... Pornos probably won't be the 'default' unless parents or sex ed programs put a big emphasis on 'when you meet someone you like, ignore them and find porn'. It'll still feel weird to want pornos. Also: The word 'real' when used in phrases like 'the real world' assumes a tacit and acceptable definition of 'reality'. I'm not trying to be irritating I just don't think there is one. This isn't because there are embedded devices and servers everywhere it's because of skepticism. Something the post reminds me of: When I see two people less than two meters apart from each other and nearly no one else nearby, speaking on cell phones but not with each other it bugs me a lot.
- corin_ 15y agojgc, some of your thoughts in this piece are worded badly, implying a (possibly subconcious) bias which I don't think you intended to be in there - though perhaps that was purposeful? For example in paragraph three you have a list for virtual, and a list for real - "pleasure" appears in one of the lists only, and as it would be clearly incorrect to imply that virtual worlds cannot give pleasure, it was just left off that list, which is a subtle suggestion that pleasure is only found in the real world. Books, I'm completely with you on that personally, I far prefer actual books to reading on an iPad or a Kindle, and I'm generally quite sentimental in most areas ("my dad's watch", etc.) But would losing that be a bad thing? It would for me personally, because that's how I think now, but if I was brought up not thinking of these things as sentimental for the object not just for the content, would I be worse off? Not sure. Sex: A big leap to suggest that porn will become the default blah blah. And while I really have no idea what was in the heads of people 40, 100, 500 years ago, surely we have always been able to imagine pretty much any sexual scenario for pleasure anyway? And, porn is hardly new in the digital age (though much more easily accessible, certainly), and we haven't got there yet. Making: My 9 year old nephew loves playing with his DS, his Xbox, he's always picked up technology (e.g. iphone use) fast, since he was young. But that doesn't mean he doesn't enjoy being read to. Or reading himself. Or playing with lego. Or playing on the swings at the park. Or playing with our train set. Sure, some kids might never leave the computer screen, but some kids will also spend all their spare time reading, that doesn't prompt blogs about books being bad. Children: I saw your link somewhere here to the flying story, and while some people may think like that, certainly not everyone. And ultimately, sitting in front of a screen doesn't have to be bad. Everything in moderation, etc. Playing video games with friends online is (less so now, but still to an extent) considered geeky and lacking social skills, but is it really different from playing football in the park? (Ignoring the excercise aspect). Does playing with PHP help you improve your thinking skills more or less than playing with lego? Etc.
- glhaynes 15y agoFisking mode on, devils-advocate-to-some-extent option engaged. I think that the world of TV, computers, video games has caused us to lose our connection with the physical world. Add on top of that fear: fear of letting children play in the street, fear of chemistry sets, fear of ultraviolet light. This combination means that people (and especially the young) spend hours indoors away from the physical world immersed in virtual worlds. In my experience (and I'm only talking about my own experience), the fear is driven by "predators". People aren't significantly more worried by actual dirt than they used to be — kids in my neighborhood are filthy often. But there's a perception that there are dirty perverts behind every corner ready to snatch your kid from you — it's not so much of just a concern as much as a near-certainty. This is driven by "news" shows that focus on the handful of negative events out of the billions of positive ones - in other words, it doesn't at all reflect the reality than one sees in statistics. But, many people aren't statistically minded. Some kids are definitely losing out because of this. All we can do is allow our own kids the reasonable freedom that they're entitled to… I see many people doing so. Books: as books move to electronic form they take on a different meaning. The words of the book transcend and the physical presentation is lost. On the Kindle every book is Twilight. In the real world the physical book has a meaning of its own: it's the book your wife gave you as an anniversary present, it's the book your late father got part way through and you dare not remove the bookmark he left in place, it's the children's book read and read until the pages are torn and worn. These physical remnants augment the book with personal meaning. Speak for your own ebook reader - mine isn't filled with Twilight. Are more people buying Twilight than deep eternal classical philosophical works? No doubt, but that's not at all necessarily related to medium. Sex: what happens when pornography becomes the default means of getting sexual pleasure. Does fantasy start to wither in the brain? If every fetish or desire is available (for free) at the touch of a button what happens when we are presented with a real other person to have sex with. And what's the cost of reality not matching screen fantasy? Masturbation has always been the default means of getting sexual pleasure. It's assisted more now and I agree that's something to be cognizant of. But I remember wails a few years back of how rape was skyrocketing as corner convenience stores started selling pornography. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but my understanding is that rape, like most violent crime, is decreasing and is (in developed countries) at pretty low levels historically. While we're theorizing, we could speculate that many peoples' sex lives are better now: as (widely-desired) taboos are normalized, more people get to engage in them. How many married couples have gone through life both wanting and desiring "more" (more pleasure, more intimacy, more "dirty", etc) but neither getting it because they both considered it off-limits? I've known far more couples whose sex lives have been improved by watching porn together than the opposite. Making: as a child I had Lego, Play-Doh, and other toys to occupy my hands. Now imagine that these are all virtualized and I play with them on screen. There's no difference felt in my hands between them. No texture, smell and pliability of Play-Doh, no satisfying click of Lego, no hunt for the right coloured piece. If an infinite amount of virtual stuff is available does my imagination atrophy? If I can always find the right coloured, right sized Lego piece is this an advantage or a loss because I'm no longer forced to invent? If you ever build a technological thing that makes kids not play with Lego and Play-Doh, it'll be because it's so immersive, fun, and imagination-stimulating that they don't want Lego and Play-Doh anymore. Every kid I see is surrounded by technology but still loves playing with these physical things too. Children: as an adult man I'm now viewed by many to be a threat children. I can't be seated next to a child flying alone on a flight. I'm afraid to talk to a child in the street, and we've seen schools instituting policies against any sort of physical contact between children and teachers. I agree: this is a huge problem. It doesn't seem, though, to be driven by technology but by its offshoot, media. I don't know what the answer is here. As above, I guess it's about making people statistically-driven rather than anecdote-driven. Good luck with that. Horror is more exciting than mundane news about the world being OK. As long as you have a free media, you're going to have this problem. Only possible remedy I see is a heavy educational emphasis on making statistically-based decisions.
- boredguy8 15y agoThis passage seems relevant as it points at the contours of what I take to be the underlying 'problem' that the OP hints at with the litany of questions. It's also an interesting background from which to approach the writings of people like Kurzweil. There is, it seems, a deep desire to escape our bodies. The drive is present in many religions and it is present in futurism of diverse sorts. Lastly, the final sentence seems especially relevant at a time when it seems that most 'misfortunes' get transformed into 'moral failings'. From the essay "Really Bad Infinities", in the journal parallax, written 1999: In ‘Body Fluids’, an essay as remarkable for its prescience as for its rigour, Isabelle Stengers and Didier Gille ask in the context of what we have come to know as safer sex discourse in the AIDS pandemic: What will we say to those who ignore advice and continue to make contacts known to be at risk? Will we treat them as irresponsible, to be lectured to, put under observation, and converted? In that case, our future scenario is assured: that of the child in the glass bubble, for whom the outside envi- ronment means death; that of the obsessional struggle against all unmonitored contact as potentially the source of death.‘ Much has happened in the fourteen years since Stengers’s and Gille’s essay first appeared. We have learned, for example, that the pandemic is interminable, that we are, and will be, in what we call our being, of AIDS (with the full force of the partitive: we belong to AIDS as its ownmost), and that we can therefore no longer think of the future as the restoration of a putatively uncontaminated past; we have learned, perhaps, that so-called safer sex is not a state of being, and that latex is no guarantee of immortality; we, some of us, have learned the hard way (there being no easy way) the existential irrelevance of both hope and despair; we have learned that the fact that we both are and possess bodies means that our bodies are our unavoidable exposure to danger, that there never is, has been, nor can be a place of safety; more, that the fact of our embodiment is the fact of our utter nontranscendence, our finitude. And we have had to live the future scenario of which Stengers and Gille warned us in 1985; absolutely nothing has happened to deprive their question and their warning of their cogency, for we have seen technical advice pertinent to our pleasures pressed into the service of a thoroughly authoritarian, albeit thoroughly stupid, moralism. Indeed, safer sex discourse, including not only verbal admonition but an entire range of material and institutional practices, has become an essential part of an entire scientific medical technology of social control such that all illness, disability, and death itself have become essentially moral failings rather than misfortunes.
- jgrahamc 15y agoJust to add a note of thanks to all the people who have commented in this thread. Wonderful to see the thoughtful reactions from the HN crowd. Much to think about.
- kylek 15y agoI'm guessing this article is great as the site has been down a while (congrats! I think?). However, I'd like to read it :), cached version anywhere?
- thaumaturgy 15y agoSince nobody else has directly brought this up so far: our perceptions are strongly distorted by our environment. If you tend to spend a lot of time at the computer, you will tend to think that everyone else spends a lot of time at the computer. I live in a semi-rural area (Grass Valley, CA; local population approximately 25,000). Here, the neighborhood kids get together on my street and play outside. On the weekends in the Summer, the local highways have boats on trailers, headed out to the various local lakes for the day. The locals that don't have a boat all congregate at one of the various local rivers during the Summer, and hang out with their dogs off their leashes and chat with each-other and jump off of cliffs into questionable landing areas. I needed to get away for a bit last weekend, so some friends and I went hiking deep in the mountains and bagged some 8,000-foot buttes while we were there. Along the way, we met a bunch of other people out having fun too, including a small, but full, campground of folks. Here, there are farmers' markets somewhere almost every day, and big street events downtown. There seems to be a kind of informal local contest to see who can put on the biggest events. Last weekend, while I was out hiking, we had the brew fest (which is usually a pretty big attraction), and the "Miner's Picnic", which also gets a good draw. I have a couple of tickets to go and see a local production of "Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead". I'm trying to improve my juggling skills, so I hang out with some locals for a "circus jam" in one of the local parks every Sunday afternoon. On Tuesdays and Fridays I get together with some older friends and we play Go for a few hours at one of the various cafes. My girlfriend goes out to various places throughout the week and sets up her massage chair and offers $1/minute massage to interested people. Yes, there are people here who spend a lot of time behind computers. I'm one of them. There are kids who spend a lot of time playing video games. I've met some of them. But, that's not the whole picture, and I know it's not, because I go out and participate in and experience everything else that's going on here. I've also seen these dichotomies-of-community in lots of other places, too: San Diego, the East Bay, Seattle. If you feel like other people are spending too much time in the virtual world, or that the virtual world is overtaking the physical one, or that experiences are being cheapened somehow, or that there's too much fear among people ... you need to get out more. :-)
- sneak 15y ago> so some friends and I went hiking deep in the mountains and bagged some 8,000-foot buttes while we were there. It's cool that your mom and your friends get along so well. PS: I love downvotes nearly as much as a good "your mom" joke. :)
- VladRussian 15y ago>Sex: what happens when pornography becomes the default means of getting sexual pleasure. i stopped reading that rubbish here. If he can't distinguish between sex and pornography ....
- mahrain 15y agoI have considered the same thing, and it's true for me too. Take your office, for instance: I don't use folders, everything is on the computer. Same for photos and albums, I don't need to store those, or CDs, LPs and the like. I have lots of shelf space and closet space to spare. It took me some time to "back port" the concepts I know to the situation my colleagues grew up in: they got memo's in in- and outboxes, they read, copied and replied to stuff that went in folders on a shelf, and projects contained physical snipplets from newspapers, photograps and typed files to review. (Thank Mad Men for my insight here.) These went into filing cabinets alfabetized. I can hardly imagine the inefficiency!
- mnemonicsloth 15y agoWhen the internet was just beginning to show up on the collective radar (ca 1997, let's say), most people saw it as an isolating, anti-social influence. You could order a pizza over the internet without ever speaking to another human being! (Except the driver, but that was a minor detail.) The internet was obviously the thin end of a wedge. Today AOL says "you've got mail," tomorrow we're all living in one-person bunkers underground, getting all the necessities of life from Amazon's delivery robots. In 2001, I read a rebuttal by a former IT consultant in a contrarian magazine. People had the same worries about the telephone, she explained. But the urge to connect with other human beings had survived somehow, eking out a meager existence on the fringes of society. No amount of advanced technology would ever be able to kill it off completely. If our social instincts can survive suburbs and the telephone, we'll probably find an excuse not to drift off into the ether.
- mathattack 15y agoThis isn't that new of a concept. Parents have been lamenting kids being lazy (and too much time in front of the computer, though that's not really being lazy!) since the start of time. Relevant to this discussion is Silicon Valley Snake Oil by Cliff Stoll. http://www.amazon.com/Silicon-Snake-Oil-Thoughts-Information/dp/0385419945 http://www.amazon.com/Silicon-Snake-Oil-Thoughts-Information... In 1996 he predates a lot of these ideas by 15 years. And he's gone from physicist-hacker to Klein Bottle (Mobius bottle?) Maker. http://www.kleinbottle.com/ http://www.kleinbottle.com/