5 ms·
Here's a potentially scary thought for you: in ~2000, this would have been proof positive of state involvement. In 2011, this is barely newsworthy. In 2021, t
by patio11 15y ago
Here's a potentially scary thought for you: in ~2000, this would have been proof positive of state involvement. In 2011, this is barely newsworthy. In 2021, this will be about as within the reach of the average middle class teenager as a three ounce device capable of instantaneous worldwide encrypted communication.
This is not going to be a happy adjustment for people who have to maintain physical security of e.g. a base in Iraq or a community center in a small town in Iowa outside which the president is speaking. At the moment the man-portable drones mostly carry cameras, but the US is proving in spades that cameras are really lethal if you do them correctly. The smart money is not on "a camera will be the most lethal thing ever attached to a $100 electronic device the size of a seagull."
- Natsu 15y agoThey've already clamped down on model rocketry as a hobby. I wouldn't be surprised to see restrictions on flying devices capable of carrying payloads larger than a certain size. As you point out, it's not hard to imagine nefarious uses. Which is, of course, one of the reasons we can't have nice things.
- plugger 15y agoConsidering there are multiple teams shooting for over 100k ft flights at Black Rock this year I'd say the US isn't as restrictive as they could be. For instance, here in Australia it's nearly impossible to get a waver for 100k ft flights due to the financial considerations.
- arethuza 15y ago"They've already clamped down on model rocketry as a hobby" Someone should tell these guys: http://www.copenhagensuborbitals.com/ http://www.copenhagensuborbitals.com/
- jws 15y agoThey do have to leave their country to pursue their hobby. That may be some evidence of clamping. (they probably have to take to the water for safety reasons, but they seem to go amlot further outthan safety demands.)
- mixmax 15y agothat's not quite correct. They're still in Danish territorial waters when they launch. The reason they launch at sea is safety. It's hard to know exactly where the rocket will land, and there just aren't any good places in Denmark where there's a 50 mile radius where you can be certain that nobody will be hit by debris. The part of the Baltic they launch from is actually a millitary training area that they borrow every year for launches. Disclaimer: I'm involved with Copenhagen Suborbitals.
- mturmon 15y agoOr these guys: http://www.rocstock.org/roctober.html http://www.rocstock.org/roctober.html
- burgerbrain 15y agoThe differences between model rocketry and model aircraft are significant enough that any "clamping down" on model aircraft would not be effective. The materials are too generic.
- plugger 15y agoI disagree. You can pour your own sugar motor in nearly any impulse you desire. Granted technically it's not simple, but the materials required are easily obtained. Here's some good reading on the subject. http://www.aeroconsystems.com/motors/sugar_motor/sugar_motor.htm http://www.aeroconsystems.com/motors/sugar_motor/sugar_motor... As for the rest of the rocket, I don't think the materials could get more generic. Fiberglass, carbon fiber, metal, and phenolic are all easily obtained.
- zby 15y agoA sting with poison does not weight much.
- jgrahamc 15y agoI wrote this over a year ago: http://blog.jgc.org/2010/08/within-diy-reach-flying-killer-robots.html http://blog.jgc.org/2010/08/within-diy-reach-flying-killer-r... I think 2021 is a long way off for this, I'd imagine within five years it's on ThinkGeek.
- rdtsc 15y agoI am interested in what kind of protection or defence is there against the drones. First is how would one detect them and how would one knock them out. Can one make another drone that patrolls an area looking for these spy drones and then somehow shoots them down. Homes in on them then autodestructs... A radar + a laser? An EMP device that would fry their electronics? Would a small heat seeking missile work? Well then there is always the moral side of it. If it is a plane with a human pilot in it, or a patrol car with a human in it, destroying it is equivalent to murder. Disabling or blinding one of these drones is just property damage. Yes, this will be used as trigger to start a war: ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Georgia%E2%80%93Russia_crisis#Georgia_drone-downing_incidents http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Georgia%E2%80%93Russia_cri... ) but it is still far from killing a person.
- sliverstorm 15y agoYou'd need to pick a scalable solution; where we have one drone today, we could have 20 in the same place for half the cost in the future. In my opinion, the best solutions I can think of are: 1) EMP. May not shut off the motors, but should shut off the brains. 2) Base station with targeting system. Laser would be too slow, too dangerous. Maybe a high-powered water jet. Knock them right out of the sky. Break their wings. 3) A swarm of predator drones. Good ones would not be self-sacrificial.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI think a laser would scale much better than a water jet. Not to mention, isn't it hard to justify spraying water at every bird that flies by when you're stationed in a desert? I think in the end, the cheapest thing will be something like a small gun mounted on turnable mount, with a camera attached. If it sees small something flying overhead, it shoots - normal airplanes will be too far up to hit, and if you have a lot of low-flying traffic, you could replace the bullets with rubber. Make certain - by physical means, not software - that the gun can't swivel below a certain angle to avoid shooting basketball players in the head.
- sliverstorm 15y ago
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoSeveral years ago I thought about writing a short story which included an attack/assassination of an important political figure. The point was to do some brainstorming about ways such an attack could be conducted. After an hour or two, I decided never to write about this subject. The exercise was very eye-opening. The difference between a normal, naked person and a person armed with tech is increasingly dramatically. I do not think this is a similar situation as we had with machine guns -- you could just outlaw all of them. Nobody is going to want to outlaw RC planes, or wearable cameras, or some sort of AI-augmented robotics. And even if you could, vast numbers of people would simply break the law. Disarming the population is not an option here. But the trend that you describe is definitely unmistakable.
- pavel_lishin 15y ago> Nobody is going to want to outlaw RC planes, or wearable cameras, or some sort of AI-augmented robotics. Never underestimate the power of a well-funded PR campaign spreading FUD. "Could HACKERS be targeting YOUR CHILDREN with ROBOT BIRDS? More at 11."
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoNo, thinking about it some more, you're correct. And they'll do it just the same way they're doing the internet: a little nibble at a time. It will be efforts to "Save children" "protect orphans" "help the little guy" "control the evil corporations" and every other overused FUD campaign that's worked so well in the past. They'll just re-purpose it -- and take tiny bites. If they told us up front how much control they wanted, nobody would ever agree to it. (This is a systemic problem and not related to some hypothetical "they". I anthropomorphise and use hyperbole simply to express how frustrating it all is. The really sad part is that "they" -- who will be different people in different situations -- mean well and only want to help out. I think it would be much easier on everybody if Darth Vader showed up. At least it would be obvious what was going on. Reasoning about systemic problems is not for those with cartoon ideas of good guys and bad guys.)
- 15y ago
- Estragon 15y agoThe really scary thought is that when these are available as consumer items, and can be coupled to visual processing software which can recognize people's ethnicity, the resulting industrialization of ethnic oppression will make the Holocaust look tame.
- tuomasb 15y agoIt's already possible for amateurs to use an RC plane/drone without a line of sight, it's called FPV(first person view) piloting. They have a videocamera onboard and transmit the video signal into their VR googles. Then they control their plane with a normal radio controller. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M9cSxEqKQ78 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M9cSxEqKQ78 (this one made the news recently) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_K0-RvC4cg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_K0-RvC4cg More recent designs involve head tracking: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5OZCWaJBdc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5OZCWaJBdc Damn that looks cool. Wish I had money to start a new hobby. Since electrical systems already exist for driving servos and other devices, all you need is a detonator and some explosives to make a lethal and accurate flying bomb that can be remote controlled from a distance.
- VladRussian 15y agorepetition of the same old story from century and a half ago about Smith and Wesson, etc...
- indrax 15y agoin 2031 your secure communicator and your [lethal] personal drone will be the same device. You will talk into the headset of your nokia murderator.