3 ms·
The Pi generally has pretty atrocious power management, with linear regulators and no option to sleep or save power in any way aside from turning off stuff like
by moffkalast 5y ago
The Pi generally has pretty atrocious power management, with linear regulators and no option to sleep or save power in any way aside from turning off stuff like USB controllers. It would probably cost them like $2 in parts to add switch mode power supplies and they'd reduce power consumption by at least half if not more. But no we can't afford a few dollars worth' of parts on an $80 product to improve quality of life significantly lmao.
Imagine all the battery powered applications where this would be a night and day difference.
- andai 5y agoDoes anyone offer a comparable product that does that? Might be worth building one just to scare them into fixing it.
- foxfluff 5y agoThere are tons of SBCs out there, but none of them scare Raspberry Foundation because none of them have the wide distribution, brand recognition, and large community that goes with it. It's very much a popularity feeds popularity market.
- johndoe0815 5y agoThere's the clusterboard from pine64 which fits up to seven CPU boards: https://pine64.com/product-category/clusterboard/ https://pine64.com/product-category/clusterboard/ You can use two different CPU boards with the clusterboard: - SOPINE A64 compute module with a quad core ARM Cortex A53 and 2 GB RAM - SOEDGE AI NEURAL MODULE with a dual-Core ARM Cortex A35, a NPU IP from Verisilicon Vivante and 2 GB RAM Note that the pinout of the SOPINE/SOEDGE modules is not compatible with the Raspberry Pi 1 and 3 compute modules (DDR3 vs. DDR2 SO-DIMM socket and obviously a different pinout), so you unfortunately can't mix them. Pine64 also recently announced the SOQuartz module with a more powerful SoC (Rockchip RK3566 with four ARM Cortex-A55 cores, a Mali-G52 GPU and a 0.8 TOPS NPU), which uses the same form factor as the Raspberry Pi 4 compute modules. This might be an interesting alternative for future cluster solutions based on the new form factor. https://www.notebookcheck.net/PINE64-SOQuartz-Compute-Module-W-US-34-99-system-on-module-launched-that-can-be-used-as-a-Raspberry-Pi-Compute-Module-4-carrier-board.577956.0.html https://www.notebookcheck.net/PINE64-SOQuartz-Compute-Module...
- bri3d 5y agoI don't think the Pi uses linear regulators anymore - the Pi 1 certainly did, but for example the Pi 3B+ uses a MXL7704, which includes several buck regulators together. https://assets.maxlinear.com/web/documents/mxl7704.pdf https://assets.maxlinear.com/web/documents/mxl7704.pdf
- moffkalast 5y agoHmm seems like you're right and they have in fact improved, and with synchronous ones no less which should be really up there in efficiency. Then it really is a mystery why the Pi is still so energy inefficient when compared to other ARMs of similar capability.
- easygenes 5y agoWhat are you comparing it against? Even the Pi 4 is Cortex-A72 on a 28nm process node. Pretty sure any other core that’s similar on those vectors will have approximately the same consumption. It’s just 6 year old tech now.
- moffkalast 5y agoMost smartphones draw roughly one third of the power of an idling Pi at max load (without counting the screen draw), that's what I'm comparing against. I'd check some benchmarks, but the gap in consumption is so hilariously large I don't quite see the point. Something like 6W for the Pi 4 and 2W for the average flagship smartphone chipset, both under max load if I recall right. Some of them even have double the core count.
- easygenes 5y agoYes, well you're comparing silicon photolithography process nodes that are a decade apart and core architectures that are 5+ years apart, that's the difference. The Pi 4 is using Cortex-A72 cores, released in 2016 [1]. And is made on the 28nm node, released in 2011 [2][3][4]. Compare that to the Snapdragon 888, which uses the 5nm node (and the low-power version of it, at that), and Cortex-X1 cores from 2020. That's where your difference comes from. It's like comparing a Pentium III to a Core i7. The Pi is cost-optimized to hit an entry level price target of $35. They have to use old cores and cheap lithography processes. High-end smartphones are cost-optimized for a $700-1200 price window with massive economies of scale and stiff competition, so they will naturally use the latest process nodes and cores. It's completely apples and oranges. Compare the RasPi to other sub-$100 SBCs and it compares quite favorably. There are lots of reasons the 28nm node has such longevity, mostly coming down to the fact it is the last silicon process node which uses simple gate topographies and is thus highly cost-effective to produce. [5][6] 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_Cortex-A72 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/32_nm_process#28_nm_&_22_nm 3: https://www.tsmc.com/english/dedicatedFoundry/technology/logic/l_28nm 4: https://www.techinsights.com/blog/review-tsmc-28-nm-process-technology 5: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/04/chipmaker-says-it-will-ramp-up-production-of-older-28nm-chips/ 6: https://omdia.tech.informa.com/OM016176/28nm-to-be-a-long-lived-node-for-semiconductor-applications-in-the-next-five-years