2 ms·
I'd prefer an attempt at a statistical analysis (yes, that's what I was getting at) which is upfront about assumptions and methodologies. Essays are worthwhile,
by scott_s 18y ago
I'd prefer an attempt at a statistical analysis (yes, that's what I was getting at) which is upfront about assumptions and methodologies. Essays are worthwhile, but are only honest if the author is upfront about their assumptions. This author presents her assumptions as fact. That's when I tune out.
In particular, this essay is predicated on the assumption that our culture is more emasculated than in the past - if this is not the case, then the entire thing falls apart. I think there are reasonable ways to test this assumption, but the author, as a reporter, is probably not equipped to do so.