3 ms·
Microarchitecturally Intel CPUs are not RISC. Most instructions translate to a single uop, at least in the fused domain, including read-modify and modify-write,
by gpderetta 5y ago
Microarchitecturally Intel CPUs are not RISC. Most instructions translate to a single uop, at least in the fused domain, including read-modify and modify-write, which is antithetic to RISC. Also ups are not fixed size.
Also microcoding, which is distinct from uop splitting, predates RISC by decades.
- adrian_b 5y agoWhen it appeared, RISC did not claim to be something distinct from (vertical) microcoding. Because at that time it became feasible to have fast cache memories for instructions, the speed of executing a sequence of instructions from the instruction cache became the same as the speed of executing the equivalent sequence of (vertical) microinstructions from a microcode memory. Because microcoding complex instructions could no longer provide any speed advantage, the RISC proponents advocated the removal of the complex instruction decoder and of the microcode memory and the use of the space thus freed for faster execution units and larger cache memories. So RISC CPUs were conceived as just (vertically) microcoded CPUs which exposed the micro-operation ISA directly to the programmer, instead if using it for implementing a complex ISA to be used by the programmer. A few years later, the VLIW CPUs appeared as an alternative for RISC, which were conceived as CPUs with a horizontal micro-operation ISA exposed directly to the programmer.