3 ms·
Is the lack of distinction of number or case in second person pronouns (they are all pronounced and spelt “you”) also confusing as hell? This usage only became
by gumby 5y ago
Is the lack of distinction of number or case in second person pronouns (they are all pronounced and spelt “you”) also confusing as hell? This usage only became ubiquitous in the mid 20th century.
(Is my conservative use of spelt (not the grain) equally confusing?
- pezezin 5y agoI was sure someone would ask me abound the second person. In my opinion, the second person is less ambiguous, because in a normal phrase who is the first person and who is the second person is very obvious, even if they are plural. Still, it seems to be confusing enough that some dialects developed their own second person plural pronouns like "y'all" or "you guys".
- saalweachter 5y agoInterestingly, the second person pronouns went the same way -- we dropped the second person singular in favor of using the second person plural exclusively. So it's kind of amusing that people continually invent new second person plurals when, from a certain angle, that's the one we've got. I wonder if in another hundred years we'll be arguing about "they all" versus "thall".
- hn_go_brrrrr 5y agoThe lack of number on "you" can indeed be rather confusing. The lack of case is fine. Unless the sentence is specifically constructed to be ambiguous, I've never missed cases in English.
- pezezin 5y agoEnglish pronouns definitely have case, e.g. I/me/my/mine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_personal_pronouns#Basic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_personal_pronouns#Basi...
- hn_go_brrrrr 5y agoThey have distinct forms for some of the cases. There are many that are indistinguishable.
- pezezin 5y agoThat happens in any language with declensions. I mean, look at a table of Latin declensions, and depending of the declension and number, some cases have different endings, some cases don't. Anyway, it's interesting that in the European languages that lost grammatical case, the pronouns are only words that keep them.