4 ms·
From the more detailed article linked [1]: "Police later told Deanna that their plan was “shock and awe.” Using the department’s BearCat armored tactical vehic
by ryandrake 5y ago
From the more detailed article linked [1]:
"Police later told Deanna that their plan was “shock and awe.” Using the department’s BearCat armored tactical vehicle, the SWAT team toppled Vicki’s fence and drove through her front door. They also used explosives to blow through her garage door and fired more than thirty explosive tear gas canisters through the windows. When they finally stormed the house, they found that Little had committed suicide in her bedroom. The only living thing remaining inside was Deanna’s dog which was left deaf and blind from the explosions."
Why on Earth did the police feel it was necessary to do all this just to catch one guy? No checking whether the guy might have offed himself? Or did they ever consider just waiting for him to come out and then arresting him? Nope! Just reach right away for the cool bang-bang toys! These tools and tactics are what soldiers use when they want to destroy an enemy fortress, not what civilian police ought to be using...well...for any reason.
1: https://ij.org/case/texas-swat-destruction/ https://ij.org/case/texas-swat-destruction/
- jimt1234 5y agoThe militarization of police. Don't expect this trend to reverse anytime soon. :(
- UnpossibleJim 5y agoI read something about one of the reasons the police have become more militarized and it wasn't the reason I expected (I'll see if I can find the article and link it). It had to do with city budgets and the way they were pushed out and continued. The gist of it was, the police had to allocate spending their budget within a short time frame or the budget they had would be put into the cities "general fund" (I believe this was Seattle, as that's where I live... mileage may vary). The next year's budget would be reduced to reflect the lack of spending. In order to reduce the risk of not having enough resources, police departments would make sure to spend all of their remaining money on 'necessary' equipment for their units. They could get A LOT of military equipment for a good price because of our 20 odd year wars over season, and our love of specialized units in the police departments, it was a match made in heaven.This type of short sighted, feast or famine spending coupled with readily available surplus military equipment has lead to an ever increasing militarization of the police that has a less effective, effect on community policing and crime, statistically. But all of this is because of how our government handles its accounting practices and sells its surplus military gear. I think I heard it on Freakonomics, but I'm not sure.
- 0x0nyandesu 5y agoWhen police do stuff like this it's just an excuse to use toys with no repercussions. They get to blow up a house with zero personal accountability. So they are either man children or cowards. Probably both. Not a great look either way.
- onepointsixC 5y agoThis right here. Qualified immunity means they will face zero legal liability, and any sort of civil suit only means that the city or county may pay, not the department.
- jimt1234 5y agoIt was/is called the "1033 Program". Obama attempted to limit the program, not necessarily stop it. But, it didn't matter, because naturally, Trump reversed all that. And it's been a steady flow of military equipment to the cops ever since.
- verisimilidude 5y agoThese programs ran rampantly for years under Obama. He only put restrictions in place half-way through his second term because of public pressure after Ferguson. It’s pretty disingenuous to try to pin this on Trump. (And I’m no fan of Trump.) Both parties are very complicit.
- selimthegrim 5y agoTrump tried to veto the last defense appropriations bill that had a rider limiting 1033 because he didn’t like the bill not cracking down on Big Tech but his veto got overridden on 1/1. Five days later we had other things on our minds.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gota 5y ago> Why on Earth did the police feel it was necessary to do all this just to catch one guy? The following is an opinion and may be an unjust one: They had toys and a rare chance to play with them. I don't think much else is required or stands in the way.
- the_af 5y ago> They had toys and a rare chance to play with them That's one of many things the author of "The Rise of the Warrior Cop" argues. He also argues a fundamental flaw in recruiting for SWAT and similar police units: these squads should be all about de-escalation and defusing violent and complex situations, but instead are full of guys who just want to blow shit up. The kind of police officers who would like to join SWAT, he argues, is precisely the kind who should be rejected. Good luck fixing that, though.
- 0x0nyandesu 5y agoCops used to be held in check by the mob. Can you imagine them pulling any of this in an old Italian or Irish neighborhood? Nope. We ended up with just one gang and they walk around with badges.
- alostpuppy 5y agoThat is a really interesting thought.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Cops used to be held in check by the mob No, they weren't. Cops were a mob, and their primary purpose was originally to hold the other mobs in check. > Can you imagine them pulling any of this in an old Italian or Irish neighborhood? Yes. In the North, the original major police forces were basically ethnic gangs given government sponsorship and deployed first and foremost to do battle with other ethnic gangs, so that’s exactly the kind of neighborhood the police would be using major force on, if it wasn't the one they were drawn from. That’s so what less the case now because the police became an independent political force with a union and lobby that tends to be decisive in local elections, so they became able to effectively pick their own targets, and going in strongest against soft targets and mostly avoiding the harder ones is a lot safer, if you have the clout to swing it.
- onepointsixC 5y agoBecause of qualified immunity they do not fear any sort of repercussions from the law and since they got all of these military hand me down toys they've been itching to find an excuse to use them. They can do a no knock raid on the wrong house, kill the occupants, and face no repercussions.
- notreallyserio 5y agoFurther, despite 2A advocates claiming it is there to defend against tyranny, the police do not actually fear violent repercussions after the fact because it pretty much never happens. (Of course they do fear attack in the moment, when they're instigating.)
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> the police do not actually fear violent repercussions after the fact because it pretty much never happens On the rare occurrences when it happens it does change how the agency involved approaches things in the future. See Waco vs Bundy ranch.
- MontagFTB 5y agoDo you mean the Branch Davidians?
- barry-cotter 5y agoWhat do you mean? No one faced any repercussions for the deaths of all those people. No one was fired. The officers in charge continued to have successful careers.
- ctdonath 5y agoNo government agency attempted anything like the Branch Davidian raid for the next 15 years.
- 5y ago
- nitwit005 5y agoFrom some other incidents, it seems as though the motive is often to use their cool toys. These swat teams never get a chance to use most of this stuff, because their community doesn't actually need a swat team. A siege is an excuse to drive around their huge armored vehicle and throw grenades.
- wnevets 5y ago> Why on Earth did the police feel it was necessary to do all this just to catch one guy? probably because doing this kind of stuff is fun when there are zero consequences. If you're a sociopath its probably even more fun because you don't need to feel bad about other people's lives being ruined.
- someonewhocar3s 5y agoI want to generally remark that 'violence makes no sense'. Basically, my best effort at resolving violence entirely capitalist-inhumanist (economic stick/carrot, culturally agnostic solution, allowing an individual to be hobo's, addicts, foreign diplomats, aliens or robots basically) leads to a strange capacity-assurance metagame. Basically it ends up being pretty Cyberpunk 2077 by the example of their 'medical extraction teams'. There's something oddly desireable about that style; professional and expensive, highly capable performance orientation. And, by that example, enforcement operations are actually very similar. That example also makes you realize very quickly that you're 'putting a gun in the first chapter' (it tends to be used later in the story). How would a gang war be possible if both sides had: - Health insurance (you pay my healthcare costs) but also - Prevention Bonds (if you do not prevent it, you forfeit your upfront) Basically, a gang member is expect to potentially operate with a security company. The usual conflation of professional life or lifestyle is sort of removed with that - violence is worth money, but it's worth better money when it's legal violence. Prevents the idea that one's raison d'etre is their relationship with their gang. Similarly - a vested interest in issue prevention can be forced upon the entire circumstance. Machine Learning to validate the effectiveness. Could be very fun once we have AI prevention mechanisms, to throw rocks at people and just watch them somehow not reach the target. Or, idk, have the 7G mast spazz your muscles out before you toss it or something. Getting the control mechanisms right is clearly important, and things like adapting a poison dart to a person for their allergies should be pushed directly by (tuneable) financial incentives. Basically, could be made very unattractive 'overall financially' if things go badly with individuals. Regions of the US could be given higher taxes or 'forced commitment' to a qualifying group of enforcement organizations, if certain criteria are met. Basically - 'talking' to such communities' lack of harmonic practices through their pockets. Could end up as a forced reroll on any neighborhood that produces issues; it's often a consequence of not being in a good circumstantiality and it'd benefit a lot of these monkeys to just land elsewhere. I'm positive this fiscal-first approach makes it 'right-wing' or something, but the appearance of a great deal of scalars for tuning the security circumstances through fiscalities strikes me as a left wing affect.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> Why on Earth did the police feel it was necessary to do all this just to catch one guy? It's because they had a good time doing it.
- lysp 5y agoIf all you have is a hammer - everything looks like a nail.
- pacomerh 5y agoBecause Americans obsession with weapons and toys for destruction.