6 ms·
Pushed Around by the Stars
- JPLeRouzic 5y ago> Everything affects everything else, and the correct questions to ask are how much? I wish this kind of statement would be applied to biology, indeed there is system biology, but it does not seems to be used widely. I read avidly everything which is published in neurodegenerative diseases. Most of academic publications claim that one or another of ten of thousands molecules have a positive influence on these diseases. Clearly the biotech or pharmaceutical industries does not trust most of these publications as little of these suggestions are translated in clinical trials. I do not want to say that the biotech/pharma industries are more rational either as it happens that: - They seems to apply one molecule to multiple unrelated diseases until they find a suitable target (which more than often they do not find) - They apply repetitively the same molecule to the same disease even when clinical trials show it is not effective (for example memantine and ALS).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dsizzle 5y ago> Everything affects everything else, and the correct questions to ask are how much? I don't think this is true. It's true that interstellar mass movements affect atomic motions on earth (the theory is well understood!), but it's not true that the movements affect, say, whether a particular computer program correctly meets a given spec: they're simply at different levels of explanation. One can't even imagine a theory that connects them. Maybe the interstellar motion could cause a bug in a particular computer, but we can consider a computer program's properties independent of a particular execution on a particular hardware. Furthermore, we can even test this using an ensemble of physical computers in the presence of error-producing radiation or whatever.
- finite_jest 5y agoThis video by Veritasium on the unexpected effects of the cosmic rays is pretty interesting: https://odysee.com/@veritasium:f/how-distant-galaxies-mess-with-our-lives:3 https://odysee.com/@veritasium:f/how-distant-galaxies-mess-w....
- autokad 5y agoyeah, pretty funny how a cosmic ray can flip an election.
- smegger001 5y agoand frustrating that ECC ram is not standard
- perl4ever 5y ago>One can't even imagine a theory that connects them. You are saying that atomic motions on earth cannot affect computer programs? Or are you saying that some atomic motions on earth cannot affect computer programs? If the latter, then how, theoretically, would you divide them into those that can and those that can't?
- dsizzle 5y agoThe distinction I'm making is not between different types of atomic motions, but between properties of an algorithm (eg whether it meets a spec) and the physical instantiation of the algorithm running on some computer: ie software vs hardware. Hardware is subject to physics (cosmic rays etc), but software is not. There are lots of examples like this where the subject of interest occurs at different levels of emergence/analysis. I wouldn't be going down this tangent if the author didn't make such strong, overbroad statements that amount to "everything affects everything," and instead said something like "small, distant phenomena can have surprisingly non-negligible effects" or something, but I get the impression the author would argue against this change on fundamental (vs pedantic) grounds. For what it's worth, I like the story referenced in the blog's name https://eighteenthelephant.com/2013/08/02/167/ https://eighteenthelephant.com/2013/08/02/167/
- r_parthasarathy 5y agoYour comment is a good one, and I don't have time for a long reply, but I'll point out that the motivation for my being a bit "overblown" is the unfortunate and very common tendency of many people to have a nonsensical "null hypothesis" that there's precisely zero effect of something on something else, as if it's at all sensible that there are zero connections. I work, for example, on microbiome research, and there's an unending stream of papers testing the "hypothesis" of "the gut microbiome affects X" rather than "what's the magnitude of the effect of the gut microbiome on X". I'm writing quickly, but hopefully this makes sense. Glad you like the blog name, by the way!
- dsizzle 5y agoThanks for the reply. I would be interested in your longer reply, if you get the chance! I get where you're coming from now that you mention the microbiome. That similarly reminds me of headlines like "antidepressants alter the brain," specifically variations that imply something groundbreaking; on some level it IS impressive that physical effects can be observed, but on another, it's almost trivially true that it affects the brain, because where else do thoughts originate? In fact, speaking of depression, there's probably studies exactly like what you described where depression is X. I think this could be usefully tied back to the software/hardware distinction I raised. Some might say that, in a lot of cases, depression is due to faults in "software" -- negative thinking, assuming the worst, etc, -- or at least is better treated as though it were. This is opposed to faults in "hardware" -- insufficient production of serotonin, or whatever (and I'm sure there cases where this is the best explanation/treatment). So maybe a certain microbiome state is like a computer running on the Mars rover where its hardware is subjected to fault-inducing radiation? The software/hardware distinction probably isn't as clean in the brain compared to our silicon-based computers! We know so little in this area that it probably does make sense to proceed as though everything affects everything, as you say -- but I also think it's important to allow that it may not.
- antognini 5y agoYeah I'm not sure about this math. Midway through the article the author correctly notes that their original argument was wrong. The relevant factor here is not the gravitational force, which scales as 1/d^2, but the tidal force, which scales as 1/d^3. But the author claims that after they make this correction, it only changes the result by about 30% or so. But given that they would have to be off by a factor of 1/d (which, in their example is ~4 x 10^-18). Now there's admittedly a non-linear factor here, but even still I have a hard time believing that a change in one of the inputs by 18 orders of magnitude will only result in a 30% change in the end result. Another hint that something is wrong with the math is that the author does not have a term for the width of the balloon, which is a relevant quantity when calculating the tidal force. Even though the math here is dodgy and the example is somewhat artificial, the same idea is super important when accounting for the effect of Galactic tides on the kinematics of stars and clusters in the Galaxy. Tides play a role in disrupting open clusters and dispersing young stars into the Galaxy.
- pfdietz 5y agoThe point he made is that because the discrepancy in angle grows exponentially, the change from 1/d^2 to 1/d^3 has only a small effect on the time until the change builds up to O(1).
- antognini 5y agoI don't think there's the exponential dependence they claim. I think a more correct derivation would look like this: Let's suppose that we place a 1 g mass at 4 ly. How does this affect the internal dynamics of a helium balloon? The relevant change is the tidal acceleration induced by the 1 g mass: a_tide ~ GMl/r^3 where l is the mean free path in the balloon (l ~ 1 / n sigma), where n is the number density and sigma is the cross section of a helium atom. At room temperature, we have l ~ 4 x 10^-5 m. Now, we want to calculate the change in angle induced by the tidal force across a single mean free path. This is (ignoring factors of order unity) delta phi ~ delta x / l ~ al / v^2 Noting that the mean velocity is v ~ sqrt(kT / m_He), and substituting in the tidal acceleration, we have delta phi ~ GMml^2 / kTr^3 Given these numbers this gives us delta phi ~ 10^-78 At this point it should be pretty clear that this is not going to be a big effect. But let's see how long we would need to follow these interactions until the delta phi had built up to be large enough that a collision that would have happened doesn't. This is: phi_crit ~ r_He / l ~ 10^-6 Now, I think a critical error that the author made is in assuming that the delta phi's build up exponentially. There is a non-linear dependence here, but I don't think it's as fast as described. Consider, for example, an atom bouncing head-on between two stationary atoms. Classically, the atom would continue indefinitely. How long would it be before an atom perturbed by delta phi would miss one of the stationary atoms entirely? There will be a linear increase in delta phi over time, along with a non-linear increase of order ~y / r_He where y is the vertical displacement. But this non-linearity is essentially a cosine, which is very close to zero initially. So the non-linear term will be essentially irrelevant until the linear term has grown to be large enough (i.e., of order unity) that the non-linear cosine term can take over. So it will require of order 10^78 collisions, which given the velocity of the atom of ~1000 m/s, means that it will take ~10^68 years for the atom to miss. Now, due to other non-linearities in the system it would probably in practice be much less than this. But it would certainly be nowhere close to the few microseconds claimed by the author.