3 ms·
On the most recent episode of Penn & Teller's "Fool Us" a magician fooled them with a simple mathematical trick that could probably be done as a party trick. T
by tzs 5y ago
On the most recent episode of Penn & Teller's "Fool Us" a magician fooled them with a simple mathematical trick that could probably be done as a party trick.
This episode was filmed under COVID restrictions so the magician was appearing via video but earlier he had a box delivered to the studio. He asked Penn to open the box and remove the top item. It was a big foam rock.
Then he had Teller look in and remove another item, which turned out to be a big pair of scissors.
Finally, he had Alyson (the host) remove the big wad of paper that was left.
He then wrote a prediction on a big piece of paper, and told one of them (Penn I think) to pick any two of the items and have the people holding those items to swap them. This was done, and then the prediction was revealed which was something like "Penn loses to Teller" which was correct.
He then wrote another prediction down, and this time had them do two swaps. Again the prediction was right.
Then he had them do more swaps, revealed that he had not written a prediction down instead saying he made his final prediction before starting the trick. He asked them to un-wad the paper and sure enough, it contained a prediction and it was right.
Penn and Teller thought the trick worked using multiple outs. E.g., if the final configuration did not work with what was written on the wadded up paper (which until he told them to un-wad it they had no idea contained a prediction) he had some other prediction hidden in the box that he would have revealed instead.
In reality, given three people, P, T, and A, holding in some order rock, paper, scissors, there are only two possible configurations as far as who beats whom goes: P > T > A > P and P < T < A < P.
Any swap toggles between these two configurations. The magician controlled packing the box and told them how to unpack it, so he knew it would start in P>T>A>P. So he writes down "Teller beats Penn", gets them to do a swap, and the prediction is right. It doesn't matter which two do the swap.
Same for the rest of the rounds. He knows how many swaps he is going to ask them to do, so he knows which of the two states they will end up in.
The only contingency he has to deal with is if when he asks Teller to remove an item from box Teller had grabbed the wad of paper instead of the scissors. That's probably not a big risk because Teller would probably think the paper was just padding for shipping.
If that does happen, the magician just needs to get in an odd number of extra swaps before going to the prediction on the wad of paper.
It was a bit surprising that this fooled Penn and Teller because they have had in their act tricks that used the same general idea of something having only a couple of states so that while it seems like the person they are doing the trick to is making choices leading to a combinatorial explosion in possible outcomes it really is only flipping a bit.