3 ms·
Seems like an awesome plan, but making it scale requires a lot of work. In this system, how do banks ensure their site shows up as secure in people's browsers?
by JoshTriplett 15y ago
Seems like an awesome plan, but making it scale requires a lot of work. In this system, how do banks ensure their site shows up as secure in people's browsers? How do random sites of varying popularity?
Actually, for many people their bank seems like a good start for the trust chain; visit them in person and get the information you need for your trust root. And unlike the certificate companies, banks have end-users as their customers, not people who want certificates.
- bigiain 15y agoStartup opportunity? I'd consider subscribing to a few services that provided plausible claims to properly curate lists of ssl cert fingerprints for at least the majority of my security-critical domains. Even if it were just limited to the major internet properties (start with google/yahoo/amazon/paypal/twitter/facebook/etc), and add in major (and minor) banks, government institutions... If someone started up a service claiming to have telephoned the appropriate security people at those places and confirmed the cert fingerprints via non-internet/real-world-confirmable means, I'd certainly consider paying a few tens of dollars a year for that... Especially if it integrated nicely with a browser/os plugin.
- tptacek 15y agoSo start with the CAs, and then allow your friends and their friends and the EFF to subtract from that set.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoA blacklist-based approach seems like a bad idea for security.
- tptacek 15y agoBlacklists are bad in authorization scenarios. But we're talking about authentication and trust.