10 ms·
> He called out my mistakes using words like “crazy,” “nuts,” “ridiculous,” and “stupid.” One of the things I liked when I was a student at Caltech is that (1)
by tzs 5y ago
> He called out my mistakes using words like “crazy,” “nuts,” “ridiculous,” and “stupid.”
One of the things I liked when I was a student at Caltech is that (1) most people recognized they were surrounded by people at least as smart as they were, (2) most people knew that even the most brilliant people occasionally make mistakes (often even elementary mistakes), and (3) most realized that someone calling your idea "stupid" doesn't mean they were calling you stupid--they would freely admit that they too occasionally offered stupid ideas.
When you had a stupid idea someone would tell you, without a lot of tiptoeing around or trying to work in some praise too to balance things out. Just say it and we move on.
This would have been a quite plausible conversation at Caltech:
tzs: we should try X.
someone: that's a stupid approach. It can't work.
tzs: [thinks about it a moment] Yeah, you're right. Never mind.
Also plausible would have been a conversation that starts with the same first two sentences but ends like this:
tzs: no it is not.
Someone: [thinks about it a moment] Oh...yeah X should work. Let's try it.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoThat only works when both people are in on it. If someone doesn't know "stupid" is code for "that idea is stupid" and not "you are stupid", it isn't a very effective communication mechanism. People are complex, and it is not helpful to assume everyone should just go about their day to day as an emotionless robot. I mean, you can assume that, but unless you're a CEO or a famous Professor, you'll just be thought of as an asshole to be avoided.
- leephillips 5y agoIt's not "code". Saying "that idea is stupid" is different from saying "you are stupid". Nobody has to be "in on" anything. However, unless one is used to this frank style of communication, I'm sure it can be off-putting.
- crispyambulance 5y ago"used to" is basically the same thing as "in on it". Moreover, context matters a lot with language style. One can't just lift Feynman's way of talking, transplant it somewhere else and expect it to be effective.
- watwut 5y agoIt still makes you a rude jerk in most situations.
- luckydata 5y agoIn the USA it does, in Europe it's way more normal.
- blitzar 5y agoIf I throw a bad pass in a ball game, and it gets called out as such, does that imply that they consider me a 'bad person'? Possibly some totally irredeemable piece of shit that should be locked up and not around children? Or is a bad pass, like a the bad idea thrown out there, just that?
- whimsicalism 5y agoIt's a line. I would not want ideas in my workplace to regularly be called "stupid" but I wouldn't mind "bad" nearly as much.
- smcl 5y agoOk first - no it doesn't make you an irredeemable piece of shit or a bad person. But if you do it in a weird way it does mean that you're someone who's lacking in social skills. We're talking in abstract ideas so I can't possibly know what you meant but: blitzar: what the fuck is wrong with you, smcl, that's two goals you've cost us because you lost your man and blitzar: for fuck's sake, smcl, focus, watch #11 he's killing us with those runs. we're not out of the game but you need to step it up are two ways you as a teammate could probably admonish me for costing our team a couple of goals. Both involve swearing, both are blunt and establish some fault. One is useless ranting, and will probably heap misery on the teammate and make them wish for the final whistle. The other is relatively productive and could possibly help (depending on how useless or hungover I am). So it depends, if by "called out" you mean something like #1 then I strongly disagree. If it's #2 then cool, I'd like you as a teammate :) But on that original topic, I think that when someone says they think "that's a stupid idea" is unconstructive or damaging, it doesn't mean they want to be coddled, given a treat and told they're special. It just means that's a needlessly confrontational approach. If that person at the top of this thread is really on the same wavelength with some people that they can openly talk like that, more power to them. But I suspect what's actually happening is a handful of students were talking that way, and most people secretly resented it and didn't enjoy being around them because of how they acted. Then again, if it's coming from Feynmann I imagine there's something in the tone, delivery or context that would soften the blow :)
- SavantIdiot 5y agoYou have incorrectly interpreted the thread. It literally starts with Feynman saying, "That's stupid," and the subsequent poster claims that it is to be implied the idea is stupid, not the person. I point out that lacking "that idea", it becomes code.
- slingnow 5y agoSo can you explain exactly what the "that" in "That's stupid" is referring to?
- SavantIdiot 5y agoYou are free to say whatever you want and speak however you like. Just remember not everyone fills in the blanks the same way, and when being critical it is important to be specific. If that bothers you and you want to grind away at it to prove your way of speaking is correct, good luck with that. I hope you end up working with people who feel the same way.
- inputvolch 5y agoYou didn't answer the question, and instead leapt to something hand wavey about how people fill in blanks. Nobody is grinding away at anything, perhaps other than yourself. It seems many people here are mystified by your unyielding interpretation of a two word sentence and nobody can seem to get a straight answer out of you, other than repeating the truism that "it's not obvious".
- OnlineGladiator 5y agoIt's not code. "That's stupid" is short for "that idea is stupid." There's no way to change it to "that idea is stupid and therefore you are too" without the person making the leap on their own. It only says how insecure someone is to assume that.
- jolmg 5y ago> without the person making the leap on their own. It only says how insecure someone is to assume that. Not necessarily. There are social environments where things aren't said directly, but rather communicated through choice of words, body language and actions. People can make their thoughts abundantly clear without saying them directly, and some would expect you to understand even if they don't communicate it directly. Figuring out if a person/group says things directly or indirectly is part of the code. It's not necessarily about insecurity. Even a person secure in their own abilities can benefit from understanding when people communicate heavily between the lines.
- deltarholamda 5y agoIt's an old saw, but we teach children the "sticks and stones" bromide because it's true. Having to bracket everything you say in qualifiers and conditions is why press releases are completely unreadable dreck. If you're in a field where Things Have To Get Done, stopping every few words to make sure nobody's getting their feelings hurt is a cost with very little benefit, other than airy and nebulous principles like "inclusivity." Not to mention you will never--and I mean never--get people of a certain temperament to go along with an ever-changing set of rules designed to inflict zero emotional distress. And the people of that temperament are very likely to be in technical roles. I mean, you can want it to be different, but you might as well want the sky to rain cheese.
- j7ake 5y agoIf you're in a field where "Things Have To Get Done", why add superfluous words like "That is stupid, it won't work because X", when "it won't work because X" is sufficient and is easier on the ears to the listener?
- washadjeffmad 5y agoWhy waste time say lot word when few word do trick? It's not the word count, it's the density of meaning.
- whimsicalism 5y agoEh, I think a big part of getting things done is to creating an environment where people feel comfortable getting things done.
- whydoyoucare 5y agoI think that is largely a difficult and expensive task, since there is no universally accepted definition of "feeling comfortable", and it is impossible to comfort a snowflake. I'd rather be happy letting people go than chasing some elusive target in the name of political correctness. Sooner or later, I will either end up being miserably alone or with enough smart people who just get things done. I think this risk is worth taking.
- stronglikedan 5y agoIf someone mistakenly interprets "that's a stupid idea" as "you're stupid", then that's on them. You can't stop someone from thinking the world revolves around them like that.
- pythko 5y agoIn the article, the author says "The harsh words stung at first, and caused me to question whether I belonged in theoretical physics." What prevented the author taking this to heart? "In the next breath, he would always be encouraging me to try a different approach and inviting me to return when I made progress." The appropriate takeaway is that when you call someone's ideas stupid, that does make them feel stupid unless you counteract it with positive feedback in the same conversation.
- JanNash 5y agoThis! Also, tone and general behaviour matters. I think many comments here mistake this beautiful article for advice to use words like this. I’ve read both his biographic books multiple times, read into the Feynman Lectures and watched many an interview and other stuff with and about him. If I’d ever gotten to meet him (he’s a top candidate on my “if you could have dinner with any person, living or dead” list) and he’d have called an idea of mine stupid, I’m pretty sure that my reaction wouldn’t have been to be hurt. I would have hoped for him to explain to me why it’s stupid or give me a hint on where to look to find out for myself. Context matters. Character matters. Don’t call people stupid. Don’t call things (or ideas) stupid unless you can explain what’s stupid about the thing or idea and why. If you’re passionate about something, try to appreciate when someone tells you, without euphemism, why it won’t work. If anyone has an idea on how one could get to travel back and meet him, we can find out together why it’s stupid. Or “impossible” :)
- burkaman 5y ago> someone: that's a stupid approach. It can't work. Can't you just say "it can't work"? What additional information is communicated when you say it's stupid? If both people are on board with this conversation style then obviously it's fine, but I know lots of smart people and none of them communicate like this, even when they're telling me clearly and concisely that I'm wrong.
- inkblotuniverse 5y agoThat it can't work because of a retroactively obvious critical flaw, or it's overcomplicated, or something.
- watwut 5y agoPeople who barely finished high school routinely call each other "stupid" or "ridiculous" and it has nothing to do with them realizing any of your points. Many subcultures are rude or swear a lot or insult other a lot. This does not imply they call everything stupid because they are too humble while being aware of how intelligent they are. This just means that Caltech had using words like "stupid" normalized. Frankly, this just shows that Caltech student can twist run-of-the-mill rude behavior into tale of their own greatness.
- slingnow 5y agoI finished high school and college, and my friends and I routinely communicate with each other in this way. I also never went to Caltech. Any other odd blanket statements?
- watwut 5y agoThat is my point. Nothing special about people using insulting language. Only some groups, here including some Caltech students, then claim that it somehow shows how great, intelligent and secure in their intelligence they are. You really need to be full of yourself to conclude that saying "stupid" is somehow consequence of unique greatness.
- ksec 5y ago>One of the things I liked when I was a student at Caltech How long ago was that?
- g42gregory 5y agoI fear Caltech is one of the very few educational institutions that kept its scientific integrity in the last decade. Even Princeton is seeming going down in the woke wake. Unfortunately, Caltech is not for everyone in terms of work and dedication involved. Which presents a difficult dilemma for the graduating high school students: where do you even apply for the undergrad studies?
- whimsicalism 5y agoThe "woke wake"? Just get your mind out of the culture wars, I guess. I went to one of these schools and was fine just putting my head down and studying. People are way too overconcerned over these things that don't really matter at all. The idea that "cancellation" is anything new is an example of a "stupid" idea. At my school, for instance, some people will get "cancelled" who I don't think should get cancelled (Chelsea Manning), others will get "cancelled" rightfully in my mind (Milo Yiannopoulos, maybe Charles Murray but haven't thought too much about it). This is nothing even remotely new, and I don't pay it too much mind - regardless of which faction is getting cancelled today.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hellbannedguy 5y agoI heard teachers are so scared of being vilified by students, they don't bother to state a fact, or even argue anymore. It's not just an argument in class; it's plastered all over the internet and could have far reaching future problems for their future. I like the fact students have more of a say. In my day, I had a chemistry teacher harrass me to the point I needed to change schools. I remember going to a school counselor, and the counselor said, "Dr. Bezergian is crazy, and you are the type he likes to go after. At the time, I didn't understand "the type". It turns out he would make life in his class difficult if certain students that didn't return his advances. I started putting it all together when I was in a bar celebrating finishing second semester of Organic Chem. after enrolling in a different college. I was giving my usual Dr. Berzergian stories. A guy from another table chimed in and knew the PhD. He filled me in on his personality picadillos. My point is even if we had the internet back then I probally wouldn't have said anything about the guy, but the other guys who had to switch schools for chem, or just drop out of college, probally would have posted something about the man. Hell, we woukd probally have our tuition paid over his sexuality and the way he tried to get his dates? I lost my point. I guess it's just discussing topics in class shouldn't be posted on the internet, unless those topics are causing damage to the students. I guess we will argue over whats bad enough to ruin a teacher's reputation in school, and socially?
- gugagore 5y agoHurt feelings aside, sometimes a naysayer misunderstands, and a quick dismissal of an idea misses out on some good ideas, and some bad ideas that are still worth dissecting to figure out the reason they are bad. Why not: tzs: we should try X. someone: that can't work because of some reason [...] We have emotions, and sometimes an emotion tells us an idea is bad, and that is more economical than analyzing carefully why an idea cannot work to ultimately arrive at the same conclusion that our gut already made. But sometimes your gut can be misleading, and sometimes it is worth putting in the work to possibly discover an incorrect assumption. In both of those examples I don't really see any communication about the reason why something ultimately works or doesn't work. All I see is people thinking to themselves.
- thomasahle 5y ago> We have emotions, and sometimes an emotion tells us an idea is bad, and that is more economical than analyzing carefully why an idea cannot work to ultimately arrive at the same conclusion that our gut already made. I think this is exactly right. It also fits with what OP was saying that it is liberating to be in an environment where you can express your feelings like that. Ylu shouldn't always just blurt out your gomut reactions, but if you have an environment of mutual trust, it's understandably a nice thing to be able to do.
- lupire 5y ago> Ylu shouldn't always just blurt out your gomut reactions case in point :-)
- Jensson 5y ago> We have emotions, and sometimes an emotion tells us an idea is bad And communicating those emotions is probably the most valuable thing a human can ever do! Those emotions is how you got where you are, they are what guide you when you yourself reason, not communicating them and helping others understand how you think and reason is such a waste! Instead people here argue that we should be cold, make sure we don't communicate any emotions since then others might pick up on that, and boy it would be bad if others understands of you think! Really? Why would that be so bad?
- asmos7 5y agoin the age of diversity hires I can't imagine calling someone's ideal stupid and still having a job
- whydoyoucare 5y agoYup, one reason why the bar is getting lower by the day across Universities and workplaces.
- jkmcf 5y agoFresh in my mind after reading two bios of Feynman, is when he, a newly minted PhD from Princeton, arrives at Los Alamos and tells Hans Bethe his idea is stupid and can’t possibly work.
- tdsamardzhiev 5y agoWhen Niels Bohr was on a visit to Princeton, he wanted young Feynman's personal input, because he knew Feynman would tell the truth rather than be intimidated into agreeing with every word.
- onemoresoop 5y agoWe have to be careful, there are toxic people who would constantly dismiss other people into submission by calling their ideas stupid repeatedly. This is abusive and it better not be permitted. They could use a more civil word for it. Here's the thing, I don't mind people I'm familiar with (and who earned their trust) calling me or my ideas stupid, but if it comes from other people they don't really have that privilege, they ought to measure up their words, especially if do it repeatedly where it could become downright harmful.
- gumby 5y agoThis kind of pattern is also quite common at MIT (or was when I was an undergrad). I found it great. However your caution is warranted. Even if the person saying “that’s dumb” is a nice person the listener might not know that, or might have been conditioned by someone like what you describe. Years ago I was on a panel: there was an organizer (who chose the participants) and me. The first words I spoke were, “I think [organizer] is completely wrong and in fact has things utterly backwards.” We spoke for a while and as we walked off stage, Organizer said with a smile “That was great. I think it went very well”. As we parted an audience member came up and said they were shocked at how hostile I had been to Organizer. I happened to know both people and they had attended MIT as well. Moral: jargon is contextual jargon, even if it consists of ordinary words. Think of your audience.
- onemoresoop 5y agoYes exactly. I'd endear a friend back and forth laughingly calling each other POS but in our context it was actually ok banter. We were even talking about what a good friendship we have so we can allow each other to use those words and cross a line without any real threat. Such are the contexts that are okay for this type of thing.
- gumby 5y agoAdvice for Australians in the US: you probably call someone you don’t like a bastard and call your best mate a real bastard. Don’t learn the hard was as I did: things do not work that way in the USA.
- pythko 5y agoMuch of the conversation so far in the comments has ignored the context of that sentence in the article: > He called out my mistakes using words like “crazy,” “nuts,” “ridiculous,” and “stupid.” > The harsh words stung at first, and caused me to question whether I belonged in theoretical physics. But I couldn’t help noticing that Dick did not seem to take the critical comments as seriously as I did. In the next breath, he would always be encouraging me to try a different approach and inviting me to return when I made progress. If you have many repeated interactions with the same people where you make it clear you don't think they personally are stupid, and also you are almost never wrong when you call something crazy/nuts/ridiculous/stupid, perhaps you can get away with it. If one of those things is not true, it is not a good way of communicating (in North America, at least).
- luketheobscure 5y agoThe problem with this approach is that it pushes out a lot of people, especially women and minorities. When you are conditioned from birth to believe that you belong somewhere, a bit of criticism like this is easily brushed off. White men especially are used to seeing board rooms full of similar looking people, or equally homogenous computer engineering teams. We don't often stop to question if we belong in a STEM field. We assume it. When you've had to fight for your seat at the table, having your idea called stupid by a high ranking faculty member might rattle you enough to leave. Not because you don't deserve to be there, or are somehow intrinsically less capable of receiving criticism, but because you don't have the misplaced confidence of some of your peers.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoI'm not a scientist so I'm speculating, however: if one doesn't have that... weird level of self confidence to detach their ideas from themselves, can they actually make it in science? I'd guess no. Does society want people who don't have a lot of self confidence in science? Won't they end up fudging data to conceal the fact that their hypothesis is wrong, rather than just acknowledging the fact and moving along, feeling just as smart as yesterday?
- luketheobscure 5y agoWhile we celebrate individuals, in my experience real work is done by teams of people, and there’s lots of research that shows heterogenous teams perform better than homogenous ones. I’ve seen teams where a single toxic “rock star” destroys productivity, and I’ve been on teams of quiet, thoughtful individuals where we somehow become much more than the sum of our parts. And often excess self-confidence can become a barrier to accepting constructive criticism.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoAre you a scientist?
- ciphol 5y ago
- triceratops 5y agoYou don't have to call a stupid idea "stupid". You also don't have to work in praise or tiptoe around it. The Socratic method is quite good at exposing bad ideas. And it (mostly) doesn't result in hurt feelings or egos. When done well, everyone (even the questioner) can learn something.
- deanCommie 5y agoThe amount of abusive behaviour that gets normalized in Academia is outlandish. As is the hero-worship that becomes associated with stories of geniuses like Feynman. > The harsh words stung at first, and caused me to question whether I belonged in theoretical physics. But I couldn’t help noticing that Dick did not seem to take the critical comments as seriously as I did. In the next breath, he would always be encouraging me to try a different approach and inviting me to return when I made progress. This is survivor bias through and through. Plenty of people faced the same harsh words, and took them personally, and left theoretical physics. You might say "good riddance", they wouldn't have belonged or succeeded in the first place, but I don't believe that's true. Feynman came up in a different time, so let's look forwards not backwards. There is a way that you can be 1) direct, 2) precise, 3) honest, 4) efficient without being a dick, being rude, aggressive, and unintentionally demoralizing others.
- otikik 5y agoI don't doubt that was your personal experience, but I strongly doubt that everyone would behave like that all the time with everyone else.
- BeetleB 5y ago> most realized that someone calling your idea "stupid" doesn't mean they were calling you stupid--they would freely admit that they too occasionally offered stupid ideas. Surprising that only one comment has highlighted what I'm about to say so far, so I'll repeat it: This is great if you know you're in a community where you know that people say an idea is "stupid" they are being intellectually honest and not manipulative. The number of such communities out there is a rounding error near zero, and likely has always been - even within academic circles. The reality is that there are plenty of people who will say an idea is "stupid" because they have an ulterior motive, and they thrive in places that normalize the use of such phrases in the name of intellectual honesty. This is clear when you look at the numbers: There exist very few places where you can reliably accept that calling an idea is stupid means little more than that an idea is stupid. For context, I went to an engineering program ranked higher than Caltech's equivalent department, and this technique was definitely weaponized there. I don't doubt that Caltech is as you describe it, and it is indeed really nice to be in such an environment. However, trying to use this as a general policy elsewhere will very likely end up attracting and fostering truly toxic people.
- darkerside 5y agoI have to say, it's lazy to call an idea stupid with no explanation. That's ok if you're talking to a friend you know very well, who you are comfortable being lazy with, and vice versa. If you don't have that relationship, it's being an asshole. Just as easy to say, that doesn't make sense because X.