6 ms·
I'd expect it to be more like 1 in a hundred staying. Certainly I'd take it as an excuse to cut the tie and try to find which discords people had fled to. They'
by pjc50 5y ago
I'd expect it to be more like 1 in a hundred staying. Certainly I'd take it as an excuse to cut the tie and try to find which discords people had fled to. They'd probably lose a third of their users simply by annoucing the plan.
There is one plan which they've never considered and probably never will: something like Twitch, where you can pay for the "content creators" you like.
- Nav_Panel 5y agoNot just Discord, every little social circle would spin up local mastodon instances. It would be really good for decentralization actually, I kinda want them to do this lmao
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago>Not just Discord, every little social circle would spin up local mastodon instances. The Hacker News force is strong in this one. on edit: born of familiarity with the genre here, but no there is not going to be a great upswelling of everyone running to spin up local mastodon instances. Except in some of the techie market, and not even all of us have the time for that.
- cyber_kinetist 5y agoMaybe a bit tangential to the original comment, but starting my potentially controversial rant on Mastodon and Twitter: The real problem with Mastodon, is that it's too similar to Twitter! People try out new sites because they have something different in terms of content creation or consumption (Discord, with its real-time communication and flow of conversations, Tiktok for its instant video creation and consumption, etc...) But Mastodon has nothing new to show off, since it's basically a Twitter clone (yeah, with some extra features like federation, but seriously why use it when you have Twitter?) Mastodon has basically become Twitter for ex-Twitter people who don't want to deal with ratios and wild crowds and have their own "cozy" space. And I've observed people trying to move to Mastodon and realize it's a very quite place and immediately jump back in on Twitter after a month... I understand that there is a niche of people who dig that kind of cozy stuff, but most people still just love the wildness of Twitter where anyone can be commented on, retweeted, quote-tweeted, "ratioed", and "get judged and fucked by the audience". Yes, it's also one of the most horrible and deranged places of the Internet, but people accept that and still log in because we have our own death drives to fulfill. We know that cigarettes and drugs are harmful, but isn't that the point?
- rapnie 5y agoThere is only so much that one microblogging app differs from another, or one chat app from yet another chat app. But there's more to Mastodon than what you describe. The fact that you have chronological timelines, and not some random algorithmically generated list and recommendations flying in from everywhere, is really refreshing. This means too that when you first use Mastodon, your UI is mostly empty. It seems quiet. The impatient ones then already leave. If you take the time to build your following, then you get a great personal timeline. And the server instance you choose can already give you a nice community in the server timeline. The fediverse is small compared to Twitter user base, but with millions of users there's plenty to explore and engage with. And there's better netiquette in general.
- cyber_kinetist 5y ago> The fact that you have chronological timelines Twitter also has chronological timelines, there’s a button on the top right. > The fediverse is small compared to Twitter user base, but with millions of users there's plenty to explore and engage with. …no, there isn’t. The population mainly consists of cartoon child porn artists and enthusiasts (pawoo.net), tech people (official and semi-official instances), small groups of queer people (on smaller closed instances), and that’s mainly it (from what I’ve seen). Engagement on smaller instances seems to be very low, with most toots being 0-1 likes and almost no comments posted on them. > And there's better netiquette in general. No, mob/clique mentality from Twitter is already there (but even more amplified by the federation aspect, since instances can ban other instances) The reason Mastodon doesn’t have that much drama is simply because there aren’t enough people there, and I predict a mass migration to Mastodon will be accompanied by the most dramatic controversies.
- Nav_Panel 5y agoOh, I totally agree on all counts. I have no reason to use Mastodon while Twitter still exists and is free. OTOH I'm currently working at a company building a social platform specifically targeted at crypto communities, and it's fun to think about what sorts of different features we can offer to that space of users and their specialized needs.
- Kye 5y agomasto.host is pretty much the standard managed platform for people who don't want to run their own Mastodon. $7 is only a little more expensive than this proposed price, and you can host a few friends on it.
- tata71 5y agoSecond this, hosted private (allowing interop with public) spaces will become ubiquitous.
- downWidOutaFite 5y ago> The Hacker News force is strong in this one. Since I don't have enough karma to downvote I'll say why I hate this kind of comment. 1) It violates HN's comment guidelines, "Be kind." "Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community. " 2) It tries to put you above all the "nerds". As if you're so much smarter than the borderline asperger nerds that are somehow incapable of putting any thought into usability of products. 3) You're one of us, you're here on Hacker News. This is a giant non-monolithic forum. 4) It lacks imagination and it's stuck in the status quo. Innovation doesn't just appear fully formed out of a slick FAANG press conference. Innovation happens one curious motivated hacker at a time pushing barely usable tech forward while people like you sneer at them.
- Nav_Panel 5y agoMy main point is that "Free" is a strong force to reckon with, in the face of a monthly subscription fee. Of course, Mastodon isn't actually free, but it's the sort of situation like IRC, where only one ops guy willing to spend a little bit can host the space for everyone. At least, this is the logic I and the rest of my Twitter circle (which is fairly large! I've met probably 50-100 people irl through Twitter, got my job through Twitter, have two accounts with follower counts in the thousands, etc) would likely use if planning to jump ship. People who treat Twitter as a pure feed rather than as a social space might be willing to pay, but part of what makes Twitter such a great news source is that _anyone_ can post current happenings, and how many of those _anyones_ with small accounts will be willing to pay just to use the platform once every week or two? Of course, Twitter could get around all this by having paid accounts for power users only, but then many of the most important and largest accounts would jump ship and devalue the platform for everyone else, leaving only paid marketing accounts that cater to fans and brands. Not a great situation. Point being, it's a hard problem, for Twitter to monetize without losing the thing that makes it a great platform, and my guess is charging all users a flat subscription fee ain't gonna cut it, and would produce an exodus to the next-most-similar platform, i.e. Mastodon.
- vineyardmike 5y agoWhile i agree with you that this is an unlikely future, trump is launching a mastadon instance for himself and his followers, so it is totally a thing that people are doing - slowly. In fact, the domain of your account could actually be a huge social symbol. Maybe celebrities use @verified.social while everyone else gets @twitter.com or @trump.social or whatever.
- basscomm 5y ago> There is one plan which they've never considered and probably never will: something like Twitch, where you can pay for the "content creators" you like. Twitter rolled out Super Follows[1] and Twitter Blue[2] a few months ago [1] https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/product/2021/introducing-super-follows https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/product/2021/introduci... [2] https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2021/introducing-twitter-blue https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2021/introduci...
- moralestapia 5y agoAnd it was pretty much DOA, IIRC.
- judge2020 5y agoSuper Follows work well, Twitter Blue just doesn't have much pull to it since it doesn't allow editing tweets. People won't drop Patreon immediately, but over time we'll see Super Follows more since Twitter can provide more chances of discovery over Patreon.
- notatoad 5y agotwitter blue launched in the US on november 9. i think it's a little early to call it DOA. super-follows launched widely around the same time, after being in private beta since september. at least in my anecdotal experience, i see quite a few high-profile twitter personalities have enabled it - no idea how many people are actually paying them though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chrismorgan 5y agoMind you, this is talking about daily addicted users, not the total user base.
- Akronymus 5y agoI don't even think that discord is that good an alternative. Matrix and/or IRC works REALLY well for me, for the most part. I am on discord mostly because pre-existing communities/not having any alternative.
- Nav_Panel 5y agoDiscord is great because of community discoverability and ease of joining IMO. My main gripe with IRC is that I need to add a whole separate server with a separate login to access different channels (which is, ofc, a feature and not a bug). This means I end up with like 4-5 different servers coexisting in my irssi instance. On top of that, I need access to a persistent server session, as some of these servers ban cloud IRC providers like IRCCloud. Overall, Discord is just a lot better for getting small groups spun up quickly. That said, I also have to use Discord for certain work client communities (mostly in the crypto space), and it's annoying to maintain a separate professional Discord identity from my social one. The compromise I've settled on is that I use social login in the web client and work login on Desktop, but on mobile I have to pick one or the other, or do a lot of annoying login switching. So, to some extent, I totally agree. Ironically easier to SSH into my server on my phone and run tmux if I need to access my various IRC sessions.
- abernard1 5y ago> There is one plan which they've never considered and probably never will: something like Twitch, where you can pay for the "content creators" you like. They will never do this. Twitter has become a self-absorbed status tool for people who believe the supposedly correct things. These days, one of those things is thin-skinned censorship. Allowing payments would reveal that their most popular users are people that do not agree with the worldviews of the Twitterati. If it comes down to charging marketers for some hand-wavy conception of "reach" that can't be attributed, or direct attribution that would definitively show that Twitter is a biased dumpster fire, Twitter will always pick the former.