5 ms·
Or ya know, that startups talk about having an exit that's either getting bought by someone or an IPO. Nobody in the startup world seems terribly interested in
by Spivak 5y ago
Or ya know, that startups talk about having an exit that's either getting bought by someone or an IPO. Nobody in the startup world seems terribly interested in building a lifestyle business.
- dd36 5y agoThe media only talk about companies with investors. Investors want exits. Investors influence the media to talk about companies they’re invested in.
- jimnotgym 5y agoOr the intermediary making money out of the investors want exits, and only get paid when a deal moves through. For many investors they need neither exits, dividends or anything other than capital growth.
- dd36 5y agoThe intermediary is effectively invested, right? If you mean like a banker. IME, investors want a way to get their cash out. A private but successful lifestyle business isn’t going to get publicity.
- willcipriano 5y agoBack in my day, businesses that made income by selling goods or services to customers were just called businesses, not lifestyle businesses.
- BrianOnHN 5y agoAnother crazy old idea: Businesses that prioritize people over capital.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOr governments take care of people, businesses focus on selling products and services.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoOr, maybe.... just maybe... both businesses and governments consider and prioritize the humans in the equation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Pxtl 5y agoBusinesses that don't prioritize winning in the market will be outperformed by businesses that do. Let the government do the job of setting the boundaries on the market so they can do what's best for humans, and let businesses do the job of optimizing for victory within the market. That's where their respective incentives lie, so that's what they do best at. tl:dr; don't hate the player, hate the game.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- actually_a_dog 5y agoOk. That's what your economics textbook thinks. What do you think? Competition is not the only way to get things done. Humans are definitely capable of collective action. You may recall a few weeks ago where hundreds of millions of Americans just said "fuck 2 AM, it's now 1 AM" early one Sunday. How would you harness that?
- Pxtl 5y agoThose millions of Americans followed rules set by the government. That the game. Make the rules do useful things. If you want business with social conscience, legislate it; don't whine for the uncaring hand of the free market to deign to suddenly show empathy.
- Spivak 5y agoHow do you think startups make money? We're talking about two different things -- one is the value the business provides to their customers which is selling goods and services, and the other is the value the business provides to the founders and investors which is profit. Whether or not something is a lifestyle business is a shuffling around of who owns the business and gets the profit, not at all about how the business operates except as second order effects.
- dspillett 5y ago> How do you think startups make money? Do you think most modern startups actually do make money? A great many don't, they lose it hand over fist. Especially those that intend to grow fast and get bought (or IPO) fast. It worked for a number of current big names, and many smaller names that those big names since bought.
- Spivak 5y agoYou're just describing a growth strategy. The whole time they're burning cash they're still providing value to their customers. Nonprofits don't make money either and still provide value.
- lol768 5y ago> Nonprofits don't make money either and still provide value. They can make a surplus? And then reinvest it to further their cause?
- logicx24 5y agoWhich is also what growth companies do? They reinvest their own earnings along with outside investment, which is the same as nonprofits (via donations).
- willcipriano 5y agoAre the providing value or reallocating it from VCs temporarily in order to obtain enough market share to then extort consumers for higher prices (less value per dollar) later on?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> businesses that made income by selling goods or services to customers were just called businesses, not lifestyle businesses No, they were called shops. Where the business stops working without the owner-manager’s labor. “Business” referred to industrial-scale activity. (Before the industrial revolution, “commerce” was the broad term including trade merchants and shopkeepers.) Similar to the industrial revolution’s change in nomenclature, the advent of modern computing has delineated small businesses, which include shops and shop-like tech firms, from enterprises, which are industry-like ones. Mom-and-pops thinking of themselves as businesses is a modern phenomenon.
- donkleberriest 5y agoIf the owner-manager of Delphi goes home for the night, automotive parts do not stop being made. If the owner-manager of JBS goes home, McDonald’s still gets their hamburger patties. Semiconductors. Raw ore. Train wheels. All of those things were enterprise businesses, not shops, long before computers were heard of Your response is through the same exact lens being critiqued. Even today there’s a vast economy of businesses, not shops, that fulfill key parts of the world economy and aren’t building for an exit. The idea that that’s weird/lifestyle is a modern, SV VC phenomenon and has nothing to do with computing nor the industrial revolution at all This is obvious enough to most people that we sometimes wonder why we call startups businesses. Really they’re a new model of offshore R&D which often amounts to a hole into which to pour capital speculatively in hopes it will grow a tree
- jhgb 5y ago> “Business” referred to industrial-scale activity. (Before the industrial revolution, “commerce” was the broad term including trade merchants and shopkeepers.) That sounds very weird to me because OED has plenty of meanings not related to industrial-scale activity that predate the industrial revolution. For example, "In general sense: action which occupies time, demands attention and labour; esp. serious occupation, work, as opposed to pleasure or recreation. c1400 Apol. Loll. 3 Hatyng to be enpliȝed wiþ seculer bisines. 1532 More Confut. Tindale Wks. 826/1 Occupied in honorable businesse. 1600 C. Percy in Shaks. C. Praise 38 Pestred with contrie businesse. 1653 Walton Angler Ep. Ded. 3 To give rest to your mind, and devest your self of your more serious business. ..." And there's more of those where this came from, like "a task appointed or undertaken; a person's official duty, part or province; function, occupation" (dating back to Chaucer).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CivBase 5y agoYeah, that's one thing that's always bugged me about startups and VC. There seems to be general agreement that two big problems we're facing in the economy are 1) a slow consolidation of businesses into a handful of mega-corps which span across many markets and 2) an obsession with short-term gains to appease investors and shareholders. Yet the startup world seems to be fixated on "exit strategies" which perpetuate those two problems.
- Spivak 5y agoBecause founders and early stock-holding employees want to get paid out, move on to something else, and let someone else handle the long-tail maintenance of the business. This is valuable work in the economy because you want people who are good at starting businesses, proving markets, getting investors, yada yada to be doing that and people who are good at running businesses to do that once it has roots. The intractable problem is that corporations with loads of capital are the ones equipped to run businesses long-term. I would love a world where an exit is turning the business over to the employees and a newly hired CEO in exchange for a payout from the business itself but massive corporations will pay more, have cash on hand, and won't default.
- XMPPwocky 5y ago"This is valuable work in the economy because you want [...trimmed...] people who are good at running businesses to do that once it has roots." In my experience, things tend to get dramatically worse for users when a business is acquired or sold, not better. Long-term sustainability also seems to be significantly decreased by acquisitions, not increased- even when the business isn't closed outright (e.g. Pebble). And, from your second paragraph, it seems like you recognize this too. So, yeah, you might want people who are good at running businesses to do that - but selling a business does not seem to put people who are good at running businesses in charge of it. If anything, it's the opposite.
- notahacker 5y agoThere are markets where one potential acquirer being unable to do so doesn't completely scupper your chances of any exit though. If the antitrust regulators came down on Microsoft again, I don't think we'd see their lawyers argue that there's no other route for B2B software vendors to cash out except to sell to them.
- mikepurvis 5y agoIsn't there a selection bias going on here? The only entrepreneurs allowed in the club who don't fit the go-for-broke mold are those who make it there by being celebrities in other ways (thinking Fried/DHH or someone like Maciej Cegłowski).