4 ms·
The whole argument that something needs to be replaced because it has been around for such a long time has always struck me as a bit peculiar. Odds are that if
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
The whole argument that something needs to be replaced because it has been around for such a long time has always struck me as a bit peculiar. Odds are that if something has stuck around for a long time, it is exactly because it works pretty well and whatever perceived benefits of doing it differently haven't panned out, or have been small relative to the hassle of changing the paradigm.
- jes 5y agoI think you're describing a fallacy known as the Appeal to Novelty: [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_novelty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_novelty
- JohnWhigham 5y agoI don't think this is a case of that. I honestly think it's the author just looking for battle-tested things that have been around for so long, erroneously concluding "they've been around so long, there must be potential for disruption here!", and then scouring for evidence to support this. Almost mindlessly searching for something to improve.
- henrik_w 5y agoAlso, the Lindy effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoThis, exactly. "Ooohh ... Shiny!" is quite common, these days. It has resulted in some ... entertaining trainwrecks. Every now and then, though, something new does work, and it then becomes ... something old, as it is mainstreamed and adopted. Circular steering wheels are an example. At one time, they were new and radical. We didn't need keyboards, until we needed them. Maybe, one day, we won't need them. Until then, there's absolutely nothing stopping people from designing new types of text input devices. There's no "QWERTY Cabal," killing off alternative keyboards. If someone designs something that really works (not just in the technical realm; but also in the social, educational, manufacturing, cost-relevance, and distribution realm), then, it is likely to do well.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI think it's easy to overlook that it isn't enough that there is some benefit to changing things around, it needs to be a significant benefit to outweigh the hassle. Dvorak probably is the better keyboard layout compared to QWERTY, but by a fairly small degree that doesn't even materialize for most typists. If it made the average person type twice as fast, nobody would be using QWERTY. Another example is NEMA plugs. Compared to Schuko, their safety features are quite lackluster, but the cost of changing the power plug standard is extremely high and safety features of NEMA are probably good enough.
- cbm-vic-20 5y agoAre we talking about people, or keyboard layouts?