6 ms·
Real first world war: A monumental account of the Napoleonic Wars (2020)
- a3w 5y agoWW0. Indexing starts at zero.
- kergonath 5y agoWas the seven years’ war WW-1, then?
- wins32767 5y agoThe Seven Years War was a truly global war with fighting in North America, the Caribbean, and India in addition to Europe. It was even kicked off by a young George Washington. It definitely gets my vote as the first truly global war.
- kergonath 5y agoWhy does the article need to apologise that the book does not address “questions of gender, race, or generational relations”? There’s more than one prism through which we can look at the past (or the present, for that matter). Anyway, the article makes a good case. And yes, they know about the seven years’ war. Archived here: https://archive.md/GAOgo https://archive.md/GAOgo .
- panzagl 5y agoI'd still argue for the Seven Years War as a better candidate- it actually addressed global issues (the fate of N America and India), whereas the Napoleonic Wars were very much about Britain trying to maintain a status quo antebellum in Europe.
- barry-cotter 5y agoI suggest you read the book, because Britain cared about keeping France from completely dominating Europe and from having ports on La Manche a great deal, but the status quo antebellum not at all.
- bobthechef 5y ago> Why does the article need to apologise that the book does not address “questions of gender, race, or generational relations”? Not surprising. These fetishes are currently in vogue, so the author of the article is prostrating himself before them either as lip service or because he is a true believer.
- kergonath 5y agoSounds like lip service, to be honest, he does not allude to it after that sentence. Still, I dislike the fact that he felt he needed to write that. It brings nothing to the discussion.
- lkrubner 5y agoYour question amounts to "Why does an article about history have to address what is currently seen as the cutting edge of historiography?" Presumably a historian is interested in the interests of their own profession, and therefore is aware of what has been, for the last 50 years, the changing focus of historiography. That a professional should be aware of what is happening in their own profession is not a surprising idea, nor is it surprising that a reviewer would also want to give acknowledgement to those professional concerns.
- pomian 5y agoThis review, is a great cheat sheet for high school students studying the Napoleonic era. Quick - forward it to them before finals! This is also just a good book review, too bad it's pay walled - thanks for archive link below. (strange to hide an ad, high form ad, but still an ad. They should have a switch - free for reviews.)
- pomian 5y agoAnother idea: for those interested even only a little, I highly recommend the audiobook series Master and Commander, read by Simon Vance. Fantastic journey around the world in Napoleonic times. Great for road trips or as nightly sedative. British Point of view, but charming, exciting, and informative. About sailing, history, team work, good and poor management, and the foundations of ecology.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoI’m currently reading the Aubrey-Maturin series, can’t recommend it enough. I also liked the Hornblower series set in the same era by C.S. Forester which is centred around quite a different character who plays the role of a naval officer. There’s a good TV adaptation of it too which I think is available on YouTube.
- brnt 5y ago+1 on Hornblower the TV series. Had no idea it was based on a book!
- BoxOfRain 5y agoIf you liked the TV series I think you’ll like the books too, and they cover a lot more of Hornblower’s life which is cool. There’s some debate on which order to read the books, either the order they were published or the chronological order of the story.
- matthewmorgan 5y agoYou might also enjoy the Flashman series
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoSaw title, came to comment about the Seven Years War, but saw everyone beat me to it.
- asah 5y agoHighly recommended: Master and Commander (2003 film)
- Symmetry 5y agoMost of the way through the book right now and it is indeed living up to its promise. I had become aware of a lot of holes in my understanding of events around, e.g., British consolidation in India during this period or the broader diplomatic context of South American independence movements and the book is doing a good job of filling them in.
- duxup 5y agoThe politics and scale of the Napoleonic wars has always confused me. It’s not a world I recognize and honestly that extends to WWI even.