2 ms·
ET302 (the second crash) is worse in some ways. That crew correctly diagnosed the stab trim runaway, (eventually) executed the stab trim cutout procedure, got t
by sokoloff 5y ago
ET302 (the second crash) is worse in some ways. That crew correctly diagnosed the stab trim runaway, (eventually) executed the stab trim cutout procedure, got the aircraft somewhat under control (albeit still at full thrust), flew for a time, then (somewhat correctly) judged that unless they were going to pull power, they needed to use the electric stab trim (the manual trim was difficult to move because of the high airspeed), turned the stab trim back on and commanded electric nose-up trim (which the airplane did), then for some unknowable reason stopped commanding nose-up trim while leaving the stab trim powered, whereupon the aircraft MCAS commanded the final round of nose-down trim that they couldn’t overcome.
They were this close to saving the airplane, had ID’d the issue, patched it, largely recovered control, and lost the airplane subsequent to that.
(This is not meant to denigrate the crew. They were dealt a bad hand, including continuous stick shaker activation which surely added to confusion and likely led them to leave the thrust at max. Additionally, they were getting split airspeed and FD command bars for the crew. It’s frustrating how tantalizingly close they were to saving it even with those hurdles.)
https://aviation-safety.net/database/record.php?id=20190310-0 https://aviation-safety.net/database/record.php?id=20190310-...
- kayfox 5y agoHopefully the final report on that crash will come out soon. It will probably be like the final report on the Lion Air crash where the training factors are downplayed in contrast to fixing blame on Boeing and noone else. I worry that this obsession with fixing only the hardware is the industry trying to sweep the training factors under the rug in hope that the current trend towards accidents being a result of serious training deficiencies will remain widely unnoticed.
- WalterBright 5y ago> the industry trying to Perhaps, but the Frontline episode didn't play like an industry point of view. It was pretty anti-industry. Aviation Week is more of a pro-industry publication, and their coverage of the MAX seemed pretty even-handed to me. Cars are designed for people who don't read the manual. Airplanes cannot be that way, but I get the feeling that non-aviation people expect this to be possible. An airplane cannot just pull over and call AAA.