4 ms·
(Disclaimer: I wasn't there at the very beginning. I joined in Nov. 2005 when the motto was already in place.) The origin of "don't be evil" had nothing to do
by AlbertCory 5y ago
(Disclaimer: I wasn't there at the very beginning. I joined in Nov. 2005 when the motto was already in place.)
The origin of "don't be evil" had nothing to do with politics. It had to do, especially, with selling search placement, which was something that search engines before Google regularly did. Whether you bought ads on Search or not had no bearing on where you came out in the Search results, and you can doubt that all you like but it was true.
I'm not AS sure about this one, but another evil practice which inspired the slogan was: giving preference to your own products in search results. Google didn't need to do that back in the day, because it didn't really HAVE any other products. It pretty definitely succumbed to that evil once it had some.
If the case is not tossed, the judge will probably construe the term for the jury, similar to how a patent claim is construed. The two sides will fight over the construction, but the judge's ruling will stand. I'm pretty sure he'd construe "don't be evil" by what it meant to Google, and not what the three ex-employees thought. If they were in doubt, they could have asked.
- bborud 5y agoWhile I was there (about a year later) I can remember it being used generally in meetings to judge if something was ethical. I can remember things being nixed (by engineers) for being too “evil”. Some of those things would probably be okay today - now that Mr Zuckerberg has moved the goalposts for how creepy a company can allow itself to get - and everyone must follow or risk losing out.
- titzer 5y ago> It had to do, especially, with selling search placement, which was something that search engines before Google regularly did. Whether you bought ads on Search or not had no bearing on where you came out in the Search results, and you can doubt that all you like but it was true. Which, with the slow boil of reducing the yellow background of ads down to next to nothing, then moving them ahead of results, and slowly fading the background to nothing, whittling the little "Ad" chip down to nothing [1], is today exactly what Google is doing. [1] https://www.webprofits.com.au/blog/google-search-change https://www.webprofits.com.au/blog/google-search-change > another evil practice which inspired the slogan was: giving preference to your own products in search results. Which it absolutely does, and did worse (sued in EU over Google shopping results). I joined in 2010. At no point did I ever drink the koolaid that Google would ever really live up to this vague ideal, but I was, at the time, impressed by how ethical and careful the company seemed to be. That completely changed, little by little, and I lost that trust, or rather, that trust was broken and slowly evaporated. Today, Google is a behemoth that will seemingly stop at nothing to keep that 20% YoY gravy train going. It's getting ridiculous. They're paving over cyberspace with ads and gobbling every profitable thing and potential competitor. They won't be stopping the growth mindset. The self deception at the top is staggering. Google is becoming everything the internet never should have been.
- Groxx 5y agoThe ad marker isn't even colored any more, it's just plain text: "Ad · https:// https://..."
- ok_dad 5y agoI use a adblocker, but I turned it off and made this screenshot to show how it's really hard to differentiate ads now: https://i.ibb.co/pwt1JT0/image.png https://i.ibb.co/pwt1JT0/image.png
- titzer 5y agoThe whole first page is ads. It's pretty disgusting. The entire apparatus treats every query as having commercial intent, or even if it doesn't, force commercial intent, on users. The abject hunger to monetize literally every interaction you will ever have with a computer is what finally turned my stomach and I really couldn't take it anymore. I run an adblocker, unapologetically. Even then, you notice the next level of distortion; the search engine will push you to over-optimized ad-laden, super-dumbed down and aggregated sites that are practically devoid of information but loaded with trackers and spying and ads. Google sends you there because it will inevitably send you to what is in its interest, which is either one of its own properties or something participating in the great ad sideshow, all of which are subject to its tax as the biggest monkey in the jungle.
- native_samples 5y agoOh come on. What non commercial results do you expect for a query like "new computers"? Do you really think anyone who searched that is looking for Wikipedia?
- titzer 5y ago> Oh come on. Completely unnecessary tone here, but yeah, I do think that some percentage of queries for "new computers" might just be interested in finding out what new computers are out there, and not just buy the first thing shoved in their faces. Stupid search engine rounds up 90 or 95% to 100% and forces everyone to think about buying stuff all the time. It's really grating being lumped into whatever crap category the engine thinks is the most profitable and being shown the result of a bidding war for my attention for every. single. thing. in this life.
- asddubs 5y agoalthough ads clearly do sell search placement, only that those placements are separate and labelled as ads. although over the years the notice that a result is an ad was made less and less obvious. remember when ad results had a yellow background?
- MereInterest 5y agoWas it just my memory, or were the ads also restricted to the columns to the side of the results, not being within the column containing the results?
- AlbertCory 5y ago> "Was it just my memory" Yes. There were 3 top ads and 7 right-hand-side ones in 2008. The top ones had a colored background to clearly distinguish them from search results. As many others have pointed out, the color's gone, and the ads have run wild.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ksec 5y ago>The origin of "don't be evil" had nothing to do with politics. - "The road to hell is paved with good intentions" - Somebody - "Most evil are created by those who think themselves as so righteous" - Me It doesn't really matter what are their intentions. The moment you label yourself as "no evil" ( or Saint ) is the moment some people will absolutely scrutinise the heck out of you. To some ( if not many ) on HN, the act of selling ads itself is "evil". I will add this Tech / Silicon Valley startup "saving the world" as the force of "Good" started with Google. When the media and PR were hyping Google could do no wrong. Further helping to enhance its image as Saint. ( And possibly good for hiring ). At least I dont see it during IBM or Microsoft era. It is nice this finally backfire, only 20 years too late. Not sure if I will see the days of things backfire from Apple. I am already old.
- skeeter2020 5y ago>> If they were in doubt, they could have asked. Would the fact that they were disciplined repeatedly for their actions and told they were unacceptable be construed as guidance that they were out of line with the intent of "don't be evil"? It doesn't sound like they were fired on the spot but rather reprimanded on numerous occasions which Google most certainly documented. This would all be shared openly in a trial which would likely paint a pretty poor picture of the individuals.
- AlbertCory 5y agoIf you go into a proceeding like this, you can expect Google to smear you worse than you ever imagined. I'm not defending this practice, but that's what they'll do.