4 ms·
Proof of Authority might be better than staking. There are some interesting winner take all like properties in both systems. One is easier to regulate for the b
by verdverm 5y ago
Proof of Authority might be better than staking. There are some interesting winner take all like properties in both systems. One is easier to regulate for the broader good when things go awry.
- iskander 5y agoInteresting, hadn't heard of it before. What gets slashed in PoA? Is there some kind of quantified reputation that you lose through misbehavior?
- verdverm 5y agoIt's a permissioned system, so there is a cartel like group who decides who can do what. It's very similar to what we have today. It's also not like anyone can add code to Bitcoin, so there are permissioned parts of the system.
- nostrademons 5y agoPoA is centralized, by definition. You are approved to be a validator by some trusted entity. In theory, this can be a group or consensus (you could imagine a PoA scheme where the set of authorized validators is passed around like a HOSTS file), but you still need to trust the mechanism that authorizes validators. You lose your right to be a validator through misbehavior; you are removed from the list of authorized validators, and hence can't do it anymore.
- chpatrick 5y agoAt that point haven't you just reinvented the banking system?
- verdverm 5y agoYou can still have smart contracts and shared ledgers. There are efficiency and collaboration gains. This will likely happen anyway, regardless of what happens in the public permissionless space.
- anonporridge 5y agoThat's exactly what a lot of bitcoin critics want.
- tata71 5y agoSort of, but with transparency.
- chpatrick 5y agoReally? Random crypto companies in the cayman islands are less transparent to me than banks which are subject to a huge amount of regulation.