2 ms·
> Some of that is on men who are already creating communities, for example by adopting the right community rules to ban toxicity and allowing (respectful) discu
by Spivak 5y ago
> Some of that is on men who are already creating communities, for example by adopting the right community rules to ban toxicity and allowing (respectful) discussion of topics like mental health. Often, communities for men are taken over by trolls shifting the conversation to blaming women, instead of focusing on the problems men face in an overly gendered society.
This is the biggest barrier to getting men's issue into the broader public discourse. It is frustratingly difficult to gain any traction and form communities for men's issues because men's rights appropriating misogynists use them as lightning rods organize and "legitimize" their crude hatred of women. Feminism has the same problem but managed to reach critical mass in large part by leveraging academia as a way to organize, raise the quality of the discourse and distribute it. It's fundamentally an education and exclusion problem. You need the history and literature to be taught and known by a large body of people so the movement can identify and shake off the nutjobs.
- harpersealtako 5y agoThough I somewhat agree with you, I can't help but think there's a bit of a double standard here with man-hating being taken less seriously than woman-hating. In the linked wapost article, there is even an anecdote where the trans man hears a woman saying "men are such a-holes" on the bus, and how the author is certain the situation would have played out very differently if the genders were reversed. Support communities for men probably attract men who are disillusioned with women, in the same way support communities for women are likely to attract women who are disillusioned with men. Is it any surprise the conversation is going to drift at some point to less-than-charitable over-generalizations about the other sex? (e.g. among sexual assault survivors) I do think there is a point there though, because there is a subtle difference between an emotional overgeneralization made by a sympathetic victim (which is probably not a good idea to censor if you want to actually help these men), and more insidious misogyny. It doesn't help that the former is sometimes purposefully mischaracterized as the latter by opponents of men's issues, however.
- ravel-bar-foo 5y agoInterestingly, the early suffragette movement didn't do a great job of shaking off the nutjobs. The violent rump is acknowledged in academia even now. As an example, the famed SCUM manifesto is a vile and hateful piece of work, and its author was convicted of attempted murder. But supposing that your message is not vile and hateful, the trick is to ignore the lies that people spread about you and speak the reasonable truth until you build a core audience. (Having fuck you money helps.) You will be labelled as a nutjob and outcast, but who cares, if your message is getting out?